Hey guys, I too am in quite the soup, regarding my car purchase.
Called up the Popular Nexa at Kochi, and they brought the 1.6 Alpha to my house, even though it was a good 1 hour away from the showroom. +100 for that Nexa.
Now, I had just taken a TD of the new Abarth punto yesterday, and that is still fresh in my mind. So even though I know the two cars belong to totally different segments, I am sharing my views on them
In a way, I suppose the DDiS is what the Abarth should have been. Even though I am a fan of linear accelaration and redlining, I guess that many are right when they said that a hot hatch should be exciting. While the Abarth is quite effortless, and dare I say, a bit lazy, this is a monster. The torque makes its presence known.
As i pulled out of my house on the main road, I was immediately bogged down by choc a block traffic, and was merely pootling along. This is a fine time as any to talk about the turbo lag. Yes the lag is there, and yes its annoying. But there is torque, not a lot, but sufficient enough to not be a liability on the open road. As i passed a little junction, I saw a gap in which I could overtake a Super fast KSRTC and a Bharatbenz in one go. The RM sensed what I was about to do, and he said "Go for it sir, but do hold on, she torque steers like a mother if you put your foot down." A coy smile and a moment to brace myself later, I went for it. Holy cow.
You can feel the front of the car rise a bit in response to the tidal wave of torque and the tires were scrabbling for grip as I just kept my foot welded to the carpet. God, the way it picks up pace is just mind boggling.
Right. overtake over, I was cruising again and thinking.Hang on, I have seen power like this before, and yes you guessed right , it was in the Cruze. Although I can say, despite the spec sheet and the torque to weight ratio , the Cruze feels faster. Maybe because this is a new car? (Odo reads a mere 430km) The Cruze literally kicks your behind when the turbo spools up, this not so much.
Anyway, back to the road.. After Perumbavoor town, There is a super long stretch of road and behold , it was completely empty. This really must be my lucky day. I glanced at the RM in the back seat, and he was belted already. We grinned at each other and I put my foot down. The speeds climb, and I keep looking out of the windshield, and the RM says " Have a look at the speedo sir". Well, it was way into the triple digits. Bloody hell, it feels like 80! I don't give in, and keep it going. Higher and higher the needle climbs, and now we're doing seriously silly speeds. There was a corner dead ahead. I step hard on the middle pedal, and the speeds come down without much fuss, but yes, I can feel the tires struggling. The brakes are good, but no, they're nowhere near the Fiat in terms of pedal feel and precision.
And so I keep going, at sane speeds. On the way, I got to try out the cruise control, and it works as advertised. I even overtook a couple of autos using just the buttons on the steering. Man, that felt weird. Right. I'm nearly at the next town, so I take a U-turn. U turn done, I'm now heading back to Perumbavoor. On the way, I test out the GPS and the Bluetooth streaming. Yes most bugs are fixed(compared to the Ciaz), but there are some gremlins still remaining.
It's at this point I realised I hadn't tested the ride yet. So I took a deviation that's mostly used by the KSRTC boys and it was in a terrible condition. Perfect.
It's a bit lumpy at low speeds, but gets brilliant once we get moving. The ride is super composed and mature once the speeds climb. And all this on JK Elanzos. What will a set of soft Michelins do I wonder.
Fast forward another 5km, and here are some twisties. Right, into 3rd gear, foot down. Tight right hander, I throw it in, squealll.. Next corner, this time to the left, squeaalll... The one after that again a medium right hander, squeaaAAAAllll.
You get the gist. The composure of the car is amazing. No body roll and a FLAT ride. Wow. But all that ruined by those tires.
While the Fiat feels heavy and doesn't change direction quite so quickly, the Scross will let you get away with bloody murder on the road. Only if the gearshift was better. That's not to say this isn't good , but both the swift and polo have better gearboxes. I especially missed the 'clack-clack' of the Swift.
Fiat vs Maruti.
Is the Fiat faster? Probably.
Is it better to drive? No, I liked the Scross better.
Forget the engine, how about otherwise? Even so, the Scross despite being big doesn't feel that way. When you throw it into corners, The car seems to shrink around you, while the Fiat doesn't.
Again, I know comparing those two doesn't make much sense, but the Fiat is without doubt one of the best handling hatches we have in India, and with the Scross also being such a delight in the corners, I couldn't help comparing the two.
Despite having read all the reviews, I never expected to be smitten by the Scross this way.