Absolutely fantastic review Omkar ! In keeping with the great tradition of outstanding reviews from TBHP, your's is as unbiased, covers all aspects in entirety with nuanced inputs, this one makes for a great reading.
Agree, Tata's have been making a terrific effort on making any car a successful venture on Indian soil & Tigor is an perfect example of that. In a highly polarized,lop sided competition, it's really more of a brain game than producing engineering masterpieces.
Quote:
Originally Posted by needforspeed88 Sadly Tata's have gone in for three cylinder options which lack both performance and refinement. The compact sedan segment is cut throat competitive and the consumer has plenty of choices.
2] The inability to fit in a third passenger comfortably in the back seat is a setback in this segment.
3] Not having even an option of Airbag in lower variants a big no no.
4] Tigor looks good, has good dynamics, excellent ride quality, good interior, music system but it is fighting an uphill battle with those mediocre engines, lack of Airbags in lower variants and Tata's questionable sales and service experience. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by PraNeel Just look at the long list of + points which are negated by a single -ive point of 3 cylinder engines. Common Tata you already had a good base set by Tiago. Instead of projector headlamps, auto ac, led tail lamps etc proper 4 cylinder engines would have given a good chance to this car to grab some numbers from other compact sedans.
Some might say that price is low and it it trying to create a new segment of it's own, but sedan with a weak engine will put most of the customers off!! Tata is not in a position to create new segments, they need to establish themselves.
All recent Tata products have USP, however they need to realize that an all rounder nature is required for the product to succeed. Just take a look at new Maruti Dzire, which has a 3 months waiting period. Reason standard safety features, wide pricing range and choice of AMT and manual gearbox.
|
When does a customer who's just entering the world of sedan's looking whether the engine is a 3 cylinder or a 6 cylinder one. Mass of people do not make choices based on engine, power, safety; at least the evidence does not show that. Otherwise the likes of Zests/Figos/Puntos would have flooded the marketplace by now.
Also, a word on safety, forget people looking for an air bag to make a safe buying choice, how many people belt up on their own ?
Tigor weighs a whole 150 kg more than the market leader, goes to show the amount of steel gone into making a stronger shield.
Quote:
Originally Posted by COMMUTER If only Tata brings up effective measures on giving their existing customers peace mind for a minimum of 10 years then only they will see their sales gain steam. They need to make the service transparent, acknowledge the manufacturing defects even after end of warranty period, make their spares affordable and make their dealers toe the line. They have to take each and every niggle like a life threatening incident and act upon them diligently even to the point of issuing recalls or at least in making the process of getting replacements less hindered by fleecing dealers.
They should not bank on just making the car more VFM and feature rich but on keeping their sales starved dealers in check to make their products a grand success.
|
Isn't this precisely what they are aiming to be doing ?
From the slew of models they are trying to bring in rather than clinging on to their age old machines Tata's are looking like people on a mission. Manza was a semblance of a success aside of being a fabulous car, in came "Zest" & then "Bolt" both of which are decent enough vehicles with a pioneering manual AMT, yet these did not create any ripple whatsoever.
Here's is Tiago & now Tigor & we are already bashing it for three cylinders.
On this very forum many people have only good things to say about the much improved TASS effort & also that the uncaring, callous attitude is a thing of the past. At least I have not had any complaints whatsoever in my six years ownership of a Tata vehicle.
Quote:
Originally Posted by vishy76
The 3 pot engines are a bit of a disappointment really. Tata is developing a new diesel for the Nexon, why not plonk that into the tigor? |
Slightly disagree here !
The 3 pot "Kwid" is a success here even in the presence of the mighty, "Alto", albeit from a different segment & exactly the same set of comments were then expressed on the forum.