Re: Volkswagen Tiguan : Official Review Fellow members,
I am in a middle of dilemma and need your expert advice to make a decision between Jeep Compass 2021 and VW Tiguan 2021. Primary requirement- - Crossover / Monocoque
- Less than INR 40 lacs (max budget)
- 2Ltr engine offering at least 170+ BHP
- 5 seater- (4 adult + 1 tall and soon to be teenager kid)
- Reliable and well built
- Petrol/Diesel- preferably Petrol considering the lower mileage (between 10K to 15K Kms max per year), considering stringent and changing registration laws, possibly my last IC opportunity.
- 4WD (good enough to get me out of sticky situation just in case) don't need body of frame offroaders
- Top priority max safety features and good driving dynamics, automatic (preferably paddle shifter)
- Top variant only, to ensure all features are preloaded. I do not like to invest in upgrades or aftermarket accessories, only exceptions- Mats, Mud flaps and any body protection kit (if necessary).
- Should be my pride at least for 5 years if not more. (I generally like to upgrade every 5 years but that’s more of a choice than a rule)
- Only car in my family of 5 and I am the only one to drive
- Sufficient Boot space
My current/past possessions- 1st Gen Polo Highline Diesel (2011)- Used for 4.5 years. No niggles, no challenges, was slightly expensive maintain, but was never an issue for me. My favorite car
 - XUV 5OO W10 AT AWD (2016)- Used it for 5 years and sold it past 1st Jan, 2021
- Current Ride- No 4 wheeler at home. Due to Covid, somehow just suspended investing in anything new until things get normalized. Although following are my current 2 wheeler rides-
- Piaggio Vespa Vx (2013)
- Kawasaki Versys 650 (2019)
My regular Drive- Everyday lone drive to Office and Home (14Kms 1 way)
- Mumbai, Kolhapur or Shirdi: Once every 2 months with family
- Goa- Once every year ( mostly Me+Wife+Son)
Cars I have recently test driven (My comments on each vehicle are my personal observations and views and should not hurt any owner’s feelings as I do loved my XUV 5OO with all the short comings mentioned later in the post as it was my possession)- - Jeep Compass Petrol auto- I liked the built quality, driving dynamics, safety features and braking. I hated the serious lack of power to pull the car in lower RPMs. I am a pretty sedate driver and I am always respectfully drive each vehicle even if it's a demo car, to ensure that I experience vehicle as per my regular driving style and not being a hooligan. It just felt as if the car just failed on me and was unsure if I il be even comfortable overtaking with that apparent lack of power. Anyways, I won't be considering a Petrol option anyways with Compass, as it lacks 4WD option and only went ahead with test drive as that was the only option available at dealership and wanted to use my visit to at least experience the built quality and driving dynamics. From what I have understood from fellow members- diesel has a decent power and should be able to deliver on my expectations. I am yet to test drive it.
- Citroen C5 Aircross- Good power, built quality and braking capability. Didn't really felt anything special about the comfort USP Citroen has been shouting about, I rather felt the rear bench is more uncomfortable than my XUV 5OO. No AWD. For a car that cost INR 32lacs ex showroom it seemingly lacked features that even Creta might be offering. To me post price reveal, it was a Dead of Arrival product. I gave the exact same response when their sales representative checked with me post price reveal.
- Skoda Superb L&K (2020 variant)- Took a TD of car post my wife's insistence on trying out a sedan. To be honest, I loved everything about it, except- INR 42 lacs on road cost that breaches my budget (no I will not consider sports variant- as I said earlier in the post, I only always consider top end variant). Lacks 4WD (but I am ready to forego this if I can afford this
). Though, I would be seriously having my heart in my mouth every time I approach a speed hump. - Volkswagen Tiguan Allspace- Loved the driving dynamics, braking and overall built quality. Simplistic and minimum design language both exterior and interiors is what I somehow am fan off. At the same time, that extra length I just didn't like as it gave the car an estate look more than a crossover, and the last row seats are absolute useless and didn't make any sense for me to carry that extra bulk.
Few others I have test drove just for experience- - Ford Endeavour (Loved Driving and comfort, hated braking and lack of features, interiors look a generation old)
- Toyota Fortuner 2020 (Hated it, period)
- Skoda Karoq- Just felt it’s too small a car for what it's worth. Though, loved driving dynamics, braking and comfort. Lacks 4WD.
- Hyundai Tucson- Good car, but definitely felt like a generation old especially on the interiors (I hate the new variant exterior design). Somehow, I am not confident investing in a Hyundai in that segment (budget) understanding their primary focus on Creta and below segment.
My Plan
Have good long test drives of the following 2 cars (possibly back to back) and take a final decision- - Jeep Compass Model S Diesel Auto
- Volkswagen Tiguan 2021 (5 seater)
At this point my preference would be for Tiguan more than Compass, as I have past experience dealing with VW and I am keen to avoid diesel on this occasion. What might tilt the balance in Compass’s favour maybe- exorbitant pricing by Volkswagen, too many features dropped from India variant, and most importantly further delaying launch of Tiguan.
In worst case, if none of these 2 options workout for me, I may just wait for few more months and invest in Skoda Superb L&K
I am specifically not considering upcoming Mahindra XUV 7OO or Tata Safari- I have owned a Mahindra for 5 years now and while the overall engine and transmission performance was good, I simply hated it’s built quality, scary uncertain braking, wrongly angled driver seating position. I had purchased it in 2016 as at that time it impressed me with a feature list that matched (almost) with the feature list of Honda CRV (my aspiration at that time) on brochure, but it was limited only on brochure only as it lacked the finishing and qulaity. Within a month of ownership, I could see plastic, fibre panels falling apart in a INR 21lac vehicle and it gave me nightmares, until I decided to escalate things due to slow moving service centre, by reaching out to Anand Mahindra on Twitter. They got it fixed within next 2 days, but that gave me enough lessons to not go for feature list or what your wife loves :P (she just lived XUV 5OO exterior design and road presence). No offense, but I would stay away from Indian manufacturers in this segment while being very well aware that each of them own a renowned international brand and share technology and platform. I am aware things have improvised a lot in past 5 years, but I ain't looking to risk it this time, as that's what I had heard 5 years back. Conclusion
I hope this post, offers enough background and context to my question, and would love to hear what the forum has to say.
Last edited by bblost : 17th May 2021 at 21:44.
Reason: removed extra smileys.
|