Hi All,
I have been contemplating buying a sub 4 meter petrol compact car for a couple of months now. To be driven in the city (not for daily commute), and highway drives. Reading reviews, talking to friends, getting test drives, prices to fit the budget and family's approvals landed me to THE only option: Ecosport Titanium Variant
Reasons:
1. Price Point - Not exactly bang for bucks but the best option due to the second point.
2. Safety Features - That was the prime concern. And it ticks all the boxes, with some variation among variants.
3. Build Quality - Ford is known to build safe cars. Helps with the second point. The doors give a solid thudd sound (similar to VW)
4. Looks and Interiors - The facelift changes have enhanced the beauty of this beast. Feels young and sporty. Interiors feel plush. Although I like the Nexon interiors better.
The Other Choice:
The new Creta looks fabulous. A real head turner!! It's also more spacious. In city it drives really well, soaking up the bumps! The clutch is smooth. But the top end with all the safety features was going to be a tough stretch, and still I was unsatisfied with the features I would be getting at their price proposition (e.g. no rain sensing wipers, no ventilated seats, no AT top end, no front sensors, brake issues - Hyundai is really enjoying their market position at the moment!)
Being a person who loves driving, the launch of the Ecosport 'S' sealed the deal. Powerful ecoboost engine, Sunroof, better looking MID display, TPMS, introduction of an additional gear!! What else could you ask for? It was finalized immediately. Even the auto vloggers gave it a thumbs up. (We would be very soon getting our own Team BHP review of it
)
Met the dealers in Pune. Talera Ford did not have that model for test drive. Hmmm. Looked at the display model. Felt good about it.
Went to Dhone Ford. They had the Ecoboost S model for test drive. Had an extensive TD. Twice! Took it to a long bad patch of the road which was not built yet plus it was raining on and off. Perfect conditions. Also drove on the highways.
Obsevations:
Disclaimer - I do not own an Ecosport, nor I have driven one extensively to do any kind of comparison with the previous models.
Positives
1. The suspension felt alright. Was a bit bouncy on the bad patch. Could feel some body roll. But it did not make me uncomfortable. It felt secured inside the way it was handling itself. I was able to quickly maneuver around potholes.
2. The low end turbo lag had been on the back of my mind all the time. So I deliberately tried to pull off in second gear at low speed bumps multiple times and it did not disappoint. Did not try that from standstill position. But it was a dead end in third.
3. I could not push it much on the highway due to traffic but was satisfied with its punch post 2500 RPM. It just pulled and pulled. Realized why people love this engine. I could overtake in third moving from 40Kmph to 80-85Kmph with ease. Good feedback from the steering.
4. Braking was good. Tried with both Traction Control On and Off.
Negatives
1. The sunroof is really small. Could not fathom how it could be used. Probably a good view for rear seat passengers. Personally I do not see a use of it in our weather conditions.
2. The sporty interiors were just okay. Felt the orangish tone was a bit loud inside. Kinda everywhere! While driving it did not interfere but while just sitting still and admiring the interiors, I could feel it. The leather-clothing mixed seats were taking away the premium feel. But that's just my preference. I actually loved them in pictures!
3. I drove the car with both AC on and off. Wanted to check the low end pull in different conditions. Without AC - alright. But with AC on, it suffered. Not every time, but while I was taking U-turns or bumper to bumper traffic, the clutch was pushing back hard and I felt the hard knocking/lag/jerk.
Took note of everything, still it was the best option available. Spoke about the availability, offers if available etc and came back. Thought of contacting the other dealer for the best deal.
Started finalizing the finances.
Told everyone in the family about the choice.
Even got a call that I can get a car was getting unloaded soon and it could be mine!!
But..
Something was not clicking. Something was pinching me. I was not sure what. I told my wife I am not feeling it. She said if you are not happy, lets get our all time favorite Honda City. But it was not about the Ecosport. I realised 2 things:
1. The clutch was really hard and a bit long, which needed to be pressed really deep! The 3rd negative point mentioned above also meant tougher driveabilty for other family members. I realized I will be stuck with all the errands, big or small, and my wife will give up after few days if she won't enjoy the drive. Also, the 16" vs 17" tyre debate was always a deterrent.
2. I could not live with that interior. I had even asked the dealership if I could remove the orange trims to replace with usual matt/piano black but he said these things are company fitted and do not come as accessories. The other plan was to put some seat covers. But after paying so much money, put some more??
Decided not go ahead with the booking and felt immediately at ease.
Long story short, got the T+ AT model for test drive. All black interiors were charming. 1.5Lt Dragon petrol was smooth. Tried the S mode, it was as expected. Liked the video game kinda feel of the paddle shifts.
Result - Ford Ecosport Titanium+ AT Booked!!
With AT, the compromises are - fuel economy, punchy Ecoboost, the fun of manual shifting for sudden power requirements, sunroof, better MID. How to deal with it?? Booked a bike for myself!!