Quote:
Originally Posted by CircleOfLife Good year last longer compared to Continental or Michelin. Michelin wouldn't have survived the impact. They would have been first to give away. Honda city is a much lighter car. It's not apples to apple comparison here.
In terms of side wall strength Good year > Conti > Michelin
It's a odd size tyre for the moment but you had a option to upsize them easily with no deviation. It's a missed opportunity. |
Well that could be the case. However, what I have heard from various dealers is that goodyear is a good brand and they more reliable in terms of smaller rim-sizes but heard varying opinions for this tyre size.Though I will not disagree that they are better in terms of certain unconditional warranties for accidental damages. While for Michelin/Continental and likes, they have a separate niche in market for these cars with higher rim sizes, though the warranty plainly sticks around manufacturing defects.
I cant comment on the sidewall strength as for me I didnt expect them to give away (regardless of brand) this soon considering ~70kmph speed with sedate driving while seeing my car go over a bad pothole in the middle of a highway so it was my first experience with Goodyears so my reasons could be more impulsive.
Though tyre swap with/without upsize was not on my priority list but I did swap with Michelin's PS4 225/50/R17. Few things are bound to happen one way or the other. Also initial impressions are good, bumps are better soaked, steering has got a nice heft and braking feels more progressive. Mileage has taken a hit ~1-1.5 kmpl.
Quote:
Originally Posted by CircleOfLife Any tyre manufacturer will never compensate for cash other than good will discount or replacement (rare). It's always mentioned in those bullet points of T&C of warranty. Good year did gave you
a good offer. |
Yes thats understandable and not that I expect the company to do anything out the way for warranty but it was my predicament that I need to deal with a set of tyres which are not going to be in-use for a reasonable (4-5+ years) time and dealing with sale for less adapted/wanted size is another story.
Quote:
Originally Posted by CircleOfLife Few consideration one had to take while finalizing car. Understanding the insurance coverage thoroughly, dealer always try to sell vanilla version with basic coverage, it's upto you to get the add on. |
Yes initial insurance quote was *Vanilla* but I did make sure it had right essentials which I find important at the time of purchase including correct IDV (Yes corners are cut here to reduce premium) and essentials are written in nice bold text. Although I had a faint correlation about tyres being covered in one of those add-ons but didnt work that way.
On a positive note, I think I've become more wiser in a week and will be more considerate towards additional add-ons in next renewal.
Quote:
Originally Posted by CircleOfLife You also might have a good understanding on limitation of space saver during purchase. Why point out manufacturer? They are addressing the market demands. In most VAG / BMW models sub is accommodated with space saver. If one isn't up for the risk appetite involved then walk away. |
Nobody is pointing out the manufacturer bud. I am just trying to highlight that due to change in demand and in order to add more-features, non-essentials are given preference which is forced by the customers and manufacturers oblige. IMO Space saver is only usable for point to point commute until one of the impacted tyre is fixed.
Risk appetite could be evaluated on an off-road expedition with a sedan, ex. foreseeing a need to deal with extremely bad roads or for certain other externalities. However when one is expected to travel between 2 major cities, they dont account for 2 tyre failures at once, they can only make sure to have all preemptive checks like maintaining tyre correct pressure on all wheels (including SS tyre), and/or having tyre inflators before starting on their journey. Ofcourse the list is not limited to tyres and there are other attributes too.
Ofcouse when the conditions are known to more unpredictable, you either change the choice of vehicle for the journey or simply switch the destination which is friendly for your vehicle
Quote:
Originally Posted by CircleOfLife Gald that everyone walked off the situation safe & sound. In your shoes & heat of the moment, it's hard to think straight and understand all options on table. You did well .
Do you plan to remove sub and replace with full size spare in future? |
Thanks. I plan to use full sized wheel on highway trips atleast. In city runs, I can hopefully manage broken tyres with more ease and hopefully there wouldnt be a lot of decisions to make.
Quote:
Originally Posted by S.Vats Sorry to hear about your experience. It surely hurts to go through all of this in a brand new car.
Hopefully, you can shake off from this incident soon as you and your wife are safe and no major damage was caused to the car too. |
Yes buddy, I also got my car inspected and luckily other parts of the car are unscathed.
Quote:
Originally Posted by amansanc |
Couldn't thank you before but these outlets as well as staff at Fairmont helped us immensely in this ordeal. People were not unwelcoming when I was calling them at late hours and responded to a lot of my queries. I ended up going to Shyam Enterprises and for the replacement.