[harry10]

Originally Posted by ashthedivx

Sure, will definitely do that in case I would pick one !!

However, overall I do found small niggles which arent that important but if had taken care care it might had taken Manza to an upper level. (I ain't complaining but getting a bit Greedy )

a) Dead Pedal
b) Arm rest for driver and co-driver, may be like something like Safari would had been done.
c) Automatic HVAC
d) Rear AC Vent
d) Audio controls on Rear Arm rest
Expecting too much, huh ?? As I said, as a customer I AM GREEDY

Expect these in the anniversary edition of Manza

@GTO - Excellent review once again

You have covered so many small things which i didn't noticed while checking the car myself. Thanks!
5 star rating given and continue the good work.

[harishnair]

Saw the Tata Manza, it is a big car compared to the indigo but does look bulbous and the boot job is awful considering the fact that Tata always knew that the vista was someday going to be a sedan.

[Souvik]

GTO! This is superb as always.

After some few discussions and reading through the initial reports at T-BHP, I was able to convince my friend to swap his indigo with Manza! Now the new car is booked and waiting period starts.

Souvik

[adits]

The first line of every spec is for the Manza and the next is the comparative figure for the D'Zire

Originally Posted by adits

I am not sure what you want but the basic differences are here

Manza Petrol
Swift D'zire

Spec
Saffire Aura with ABS
Zxi with ABS


Engine

Engine capacity (cc)
1368
1298

Power in BHP@RPM
90@6000
87@6000

Torque in NM@RPM
116@4750
113@4500

GearBox
Man. 5 Speed
Man. 5 Speed



Dimensions


Length(mm)
4413
4160

Width(mm)
1703
1690

Boot space(l)
460
440

Wheel base(mm)
2520
2390

Height(mm)
1550
1530

Ground clearance(mm)
165
170

Tyre rating
185/60 R15
185/70 R14

Fuel Tank Capacity(l)
44
43

Kerb Weight (kg)
1115
1035



Guess in terms of size and power the two are quite similar. The Manza has a 80 kg kerb weight disadvantage though

Another thing I noticed with the D'Zire. The ZXi and ZDi models have asmaller boot than the lower models (LXi, VXi, LDi and VDi have 464 l boots). The same information is available form Maruti's website and their dealers (checked with 2 of them independently). Would appreciate any help in understanding why this is?

@mods the editing to my post completely modified the way the information was supposed to be shown. Can something be done so that such information can be presented in table format so that the effect is cleaner?

[viper_711]

A very well detailed and unbiased review - Thank you GTO!
As someone who has experienced 3 Tata cars through all their bitter-sweet experiences, the Manza does make me feel that Tata has learnt very fast and keeps doing so with every new launch.

[Fordmanchau]

Hi GTO,
Very fantastically written and a very detailed review. You have covered all the smaller nit-wits of the car.
I must say I am pretty impressed with the Manza. Already itching to replace my 8 months old Ikon, but law of economics and finances don't favor that.
May be look at it after 3 years and by that time it would have established itself already.
Happy that Tata has done such a wonderful job.
I definitely would prefer it over Dzire.Recently rode in Dzire and it was extremely uncomfortable for 3 people at the back.

[GTO]

Originally Posted by extreme_torque

All said and done Tata is a master in space optimization. The wheelbase to interior room ratio is one of the best if not the best.

Well said, extreme. Tata's an expert at interior packaging. Now, if only they can iron out niggles in putting it together.

Originally Posted by rpmx1000

can you pen down your thoughts on the performance differences between the Dzire and the Manza

The Dzire definitely feels more peppy, thanks to its punchy turbo, lighter weight and relatively shorter gearing. The Manza is a sedate drive thanks to the tall gearing that Tata used to maximise FE. This was the only way in which the Manza could match the Dzire's ARAI fuel efficiency. No mean task.

Originally Posted by Souvik

I was able to convince my friend to swap his indigo with Manza! Now the new car is booked and waiting period starts.

Souvik

I hope his Indigo was an early model!! If not, you need to also get influenced by another thread of mine

Originally Posted by adits

The ZXi and ZDi models have asmaller boot than the lower models (LXi, VXi, LDi and VDi have 464 l boots). The same information is available form Maruti's website and their dealers (checked with 2 of them independently). Would appreciate any help in understanding why this is?

ZXi + ZDi = Alloy wheels = Take up marginally more boot space.

I must say I am pretty impressed with the Manza. Already itching to replace my 8 months old Ikon, but law of economics and finances don't favor that.

No ways! Have to post this thread link again.

[Mpower]

Can someone confirm if the 1.4 petrol comes with VVT (variable valve timing)

The 21 kpl ARAI figure is highway for sure. In the city the Dezire will have the FE advantage due to low weight.

Fantastic car esp for someone who is chauffer driven. Interior is really the highlight of this car.

Originally Posted by tsk1979

I have observed that cars have started coming in with a plastic "liner sort of thing" below front bumper. I first noticed this on the getz, and the cruze. In the west, this is to prevent the bumper from hitting kerb in parking lots. So its entire possible, that this is the lowest part, and usable gc is actually around 10mm more.

Originally Posted by Rehaan

I'm not sure i agree with the plastic liner's sole purpose being to prevent hitting the curb -- however, i do agree that typically ground clearance (on paper) is brought down by one component (bottom of a strut or differential on RWD cars etc)

If you guys are talking about the 2" vertical plastic piece , then its a splitter/spoiler which is an aero device. Its designed to spring back to shape when it gets scraped. Will reduce approach angle.
GC is usually measured for hard hit.

Originally Posted by aaggoswami

Tata discontinued IRS because the rear sags down. IMO, this was case with cabs as they were overloaded. Now they have non IRS but they are not allowed to be passed as Taxi.

Rear sags down? Is this an official statement from TATA?
so will the non-IRS not sag down when you overload it?

[rpmx1000]

Just curious. Forgive my ignorance. What is a dead pedal ? Is it that there's a fourth pedal with no action attached to it ?!

[TeddyBear]

Feeling good after reading this test drive thread. My team mates is booking Aura with ABS model.

[DigitalDragon]

Originally Posted by rpmx1000

Just curious. Forgive my ignorance. What is a dead pedal ? Is it that there's a fourth pedal with no action attached to it ?!

The dead pedal is an inclined widget type of accessory fixed to the left of the clutch to keep your foot on rest in angular position, when you are not using the clutch, practically a foot rest.

Originally Posted by Mpower

Can someone confirm if the 1.4 petrol comes with VVT (variable valve timing)

To my knowledge it does NOT. It's an MPFI engine - 4 cylinder, MPFI, Petrol with IntelLigent Port Resizing.

[pats]

GTO,

It was a fantastic review and you made us all the wait seem worthwhile. Read it twice and my mind is almost decided to go for the Manza now. Punto has probably lost one customer.

[adits]

Originally Posted by jacksons

I mean what is the differance between Manza petrol and dezire petrol car, engine wise ?

One detail I missed earlier.
Claimed Fuel Efficiency
Manza - 14.5 kmpl
D'Zire - 16 kmpl

Am trying to independently verify these figures.

Another thought. Although the discussions on the Manza have dwelled on the impact on DZire and Linea Sales, there should be some impact on the Indigo CS as well.

AFAIK, the price difference between the CS LS Dicor and Manza QuadraJet Aura (ABS) about 1.5L OTR. I guess the difference to the Aqua model will be about 1L OTR. Considering the better claimed FE (21 kmpl for the Manza as opposed to 16 kmpl for the Indigo CS), this should tilt the scales towards the Manza. Also, people coming in to see the Manza, can sway to the CS.

I should be similar among the respective petrol models.

I know this segment is price sensitive but the Manza could still convert quite a few fence-sitters.

I did a comparison of the two models are here they are
Indigo Manza Indigo CS
Q Jet Aura ABS LS Dicor
Engine
Capacity (cc) 1248 1396
Power (BHP@RPM) 90@4000 70@4000
Torque (NM@RPM) 200@3000 140@3000
Fuel Efficiency (KPML) 21 16

Dimensions
Length (mm) 4413 3988
Width (mm) 1703 1620
Ground clearance (mm) 165 165
Boot space (l) 460 380
Wheel base (mm) 2520 2450
Fuel Tank Capacity (l) 44 42

Price (Mumbai) 644,048 481,143

(As per TML website)
Tata Motors | get-price

[kunaldhami]

Awesome review GTO. Your reviews are saving my 100 bucks a month of Automobile Magazines. Thanks a lot.

[Rehaan]

Originally Posted by anmol2k4

p.s. What is the name for the background music / soundtrack in the video.

Royksopp - So Easy.

Have mentioned it in the video details.

cheers,
R