Re: Maruti Suzuki A-Star Auto - Road Test February 2011 issue of "WHAT CAR?" magazine has a comparison between A-Star Automatic and i10 Automatic. Here are the main points:
Maruti A-star VXi: Rs 4.76 Lakhs
Hyundai i10 Sportz: Rs 5.53 Lakhs
Hyundai i20 Asta: Rs 8.35 Lakhs
CITY DRIVING:
The cute little A-Star feels the best in town, showing a lot of enthusiasm off the blocks. There is no lag from the automatic four-speed gearbox and the car moves forth smartly. However, once it is past the initial tug of power, power delivery is flat and you have to be patient for the car to gain momentum. Nevertheless, for city use, it feels adequate and the A-star is at its best in stop-start traffic. Its compact dimensions and light steering make the A-star the easiest to drive in the city.
The i10's four-speed gear box, in comparison, is not that responsive. The torque converter takes its own sweet time to spool up power and the acceleration off the line feels pretty laid back. But the potent 80bhp Kappa2 engine works well to hide this minute shortcoming. Once on the move, there is loads of power on tap and the i10 moves ahead smartly. The little kerb weight also helps here and the car feels quite peppy to drive. Though the shifts are slow and the gear ratios quite tall, it never feels short on power and is more than adequate for city driving.
The i20, on the other hand, with 1.4 litre engine is the most powerful of the three. But this doesn't mean it is the most effortless to drive. The four-speed automatic box feels ridiculously slow to respond and the lack of low-end torque from the engine accentuates this further. You have to flex your right foot to extract decent performance from the 100bhp motor. In stop-start traffic too it feels lethargic and the performance at best is just about adequate.
HIGHWAY DRIVING:
While the A-star shines in the city, it dissapoints on the highway. The small 1.0-litre three-cylinder engine is the least powerful of the three cars here and out on the highway this deficit shows through. Throttle responses are very blunt and the A-star takes time to gain momentum once on an open road. Though the gearbox is pretty good at downshifts, the lack of sufficient torque and tall gear ratios hamper the small Maruti's progress on the roads beyond city limits. Also, overtaking on single-lane highways needs to be planned well in advance.
The i10, on the other hand, feels much peppier at higher speeds. Its relative lack of weight and good power from the tech-laden Kappa2 motor works wonders here. The midrange is strong and the i10 never feels short on power. The four-speed auto gearbox though is slow to shift, compared to that of the Maruti, and could do with quicker shifts. But overall the i10 does a commendable job out on the highway.
The i20 surprisingly feels lethargic to drive, compared to the i10. Yes, it has much more power but the 1.4-litre engine develops most of it towards the top of the powerband. And you have to rev the bolts off the engine to extract respectable performance. The gearbox is very slow to downshift too, which doesn't help while overtaking on two-lane roads. The i20 feels the best while cruising on a multi-lane highway. |