Re: Honda City (Corporate Edition) vs Skoda Rapid (Ambition) Quote:
Originally Posted by abhifever As this is my first entry into this distinguished Forum,let me start off with a BIG Hi!!
I Have been an ardent reader of this community and a huge afficionado of various Test Drive reports in it.Now,for the obvious reasons that this is a car enthusiasts place,
I have found the information on every entry to be worth my time.Looking forward to be a part of this in the coming years!!
Now coming to my query/concern:-
I am in the US since 2007 and am looking forward to owning a Car once I am back next month.
Have paid advance for a Swift ZDI , but the recent price hikes are demotivating and I was wondering why not think about a Sedan considering the 'not considerable' price difference.
My Picks:-
Have been reading a lot off late about Skoda Rapid TDi(Ambition) and the ANHC(CE).Irrespective of my monthly usage I would prefer one of the below mentioned cars
Why Rapid?
Highly successful Diesel Engine.
'Premium' brand value.Not sure how premium though .
Strong build and planted drive,a driving enthusiasts car.
I like the looks on paper.Haven't seen this car in person.
Why not Rapid?(This is where I need your valuable inputs)
I did read in a forum that the maintainence could be 8 to 10K for the first three years following which it could shoot up to 20K annually.Could you please validate this?
Skoda has discounted itself from a 'Premium' brand to a 'not so Premium' brand in India and considering that it's contained
by VW makes its future more unpredictable-could be for good or bad.Having said that can we speculate the resale value of this car 5 to 6 years from today?
Why Honda City?
A very trusted brand/car in India.
Awesome looks,complimented with an even better engine.Good value for money.
Good resale value.
Maintainence is supposedly much cheaper than Skoda Rapid.
Please help me in making a decision.I know it's not a Black or White answer, but your thoughts would be greatly appreciated.
Kindest Regards!!
Abhilash |
No brainer I would go for a Rapid.
a few things for you to ponder over.
1. The sheet metal thickness of rapid is much higher as compared to the city which translates to safety.
2. Diesel Efficiency is future and inflation proof. You wont be able to tell when the fuel prices will be hiked up again. What ever happens, if you own a diesel, you will still have the most economical running machine over petrol(Provided you drive as much - Diesel cars or not meant for the occasional weekend running around).
3. Honda is planning to release diesel cars - when this happens the resale values of the petrol variants of the Honda will be further hit. Also, due to price correction of over 1 lakh recently for the Honda city, I doubt the older Honda owners are getting the same resale value they enjoyed for all these years.
4. the Rapid Ambition is unbeatable VFM.
5. Even if you have budget for Rapid Elegance, you can go for the ambition and use the saving for fitting an high end ICE!! Stock ICE of the Elegance & NHC just does the job.
6. You need to send the city in for service 3 times the first year. Rapid needs visit to the service center only after 1year/15000 kms after delivery of the vehicle(I guess service costs work themselves out).
7. Basically to make your decision easy - Rapid - go for it if you drive and love driving. City - go for it if you want a car to put in the show case with the occasional drive.
If you are the normal working class - after buying a petrol vehicle, your days will be spent deciding whether to take the bike or the car for the regular trips. If you buy diesel car - your bike will most probably be on the classifieds the very next week. |