Looks like over the weekend this thread grew to double its size.
Quote:
Originally Posted by nitinhegde supremebaleno, I can understand that you are a Maruti fan |
I missed replying to this one earlier. Let me first correct you by saying that I admire Suzuki (MUL is just the local guys churning out cars having Suzuki tech) for their practical and reliable cars. And this admiration did not come by reading about their cars in magazines or surfing the web. This is from actual usage of their cars during the past 20 years. Nitin, your experience with the Flair is just 2 months and already you are pushing it as the best car in the segment. If just 2 months of usage can make you a Ford fan, is it wrong of me being a Suzuki fan after a 20-year long +ve experience with their cars ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by revharder you said you never sat in the rear seats of esteem or flair then how can you be so sure of this comparo? whereas esteem feels as if we are sitting on the ground! |
If you noticed, I mentioned that both
look cramped, which means to a layman, the space available in the rear looks less than what is required to seat 3 people comfortably. I am not a rear seat guy - prefer to drive the car - and thus never felt the need to check out the rear seat. Ofcourse, I agree that the Esteem is kind of low, so you might feel as if sitting on the ground. Had the same feeling in my '85 M800.
Quote:
Originally Posted by revharder and why i labelled esteem as scrap coz with so many shortcomings it is nothing better than that, and more so when you have so many better alternatives right in front of you which are also quite cheaper! |
It would be better to weigh cars properly before making loaded comments like "scrap" etc. Every car has some negatives for each person and no car is a 100% fit.
Quote:
Originally Posted by revharder no doubt, esteem has a nice and peppy engine and being a MUL product it has cheaper-to-own factor playing in its favour, but what about the comfort levels? and what about the safety ? esteems are prone to get damaged seriously even with very small mishaps! |
Don't tell me that Ford is safer on the roads. A newer look does not necessarily mean safety. What safety feature does it have that the Esteem does not ??? Safety features like ABS, airbags etc are not present in either car. So, meaningless to talk about safety. And BTW, I do not think that a car that breaks into 2 pieces can qualify as a safe car, by any stretch of imagination.
Quote:
Originally Posted by nitinhegde Speedbuster ,thanks for clarifying..
As rightly pointed out by many others - revharder,speedbuster - the argument was not at all based on power...I laughed aloud at you since you tend to live in a dream world of Maruti Udyog Limited and tend to ignore the other grey areas which are very important for an overall package... |
To be frank, your sarcastic remark (using a proverb) was in response to @prince's comments on power comparison of the 2 cars. Please check post no.44.
Quote:
Originally Posted by nitinhegde I would suggest you go for Esteem if you do not wish to budge from this list..Buy a Car you like and before deciding re-visit your likings/dislikings and priorities...Later on,you must not rue on your decision. |
If he goes for Esteem, the only thing he might rue is the fact that the car's looks are dated. Otherwise, he is going to be one happy owner.
Quote:
Originally Posted by extreme_torque Guys after going through all the replies.... i would suggest Icey to close his eyes and go for Indigo Diesel. The reason is, its got the best of both the Ikon and the Esteem. Its safe, looks better (than esteem atleast) , Cheap Spares, Fuel Average wont be a problem, reasonable performance, solid and safe on the highways, well planted feel, lots of space (better both ikon n esteem here)... the only negetive is niggling issues which "may" crop from time to time, else its a completely reliable and a fine car. |
Looks wise, I would rate the Flair first, followed by Esteem and finally the Indigo. IMO the Indigo looks different, even awkward and that does not mean better. The way you mention the niggling issues, it would seem it is a normal thing to be taken in one's stride. I don't know about you, but if I am spending 5L of my money on a car, I do not expect any issues atleast for the 1st 5 years, if not more.
Icemanz, testdrive all the cars that fit in your budget. Take a friend along if you are not sure that you will be able to judge the cars due to inexperience. List down all the factors that matter to you and identify the car that matches the most.