Re: D1 Sedan Quandary: VW Jetta, Skoda Octavia or Used Laura? Quote:
Originally Posted by flipsyde Actually I was talking about the S60 diesel.
Its no BMW 3 Series when it comes to handling but it certainly feels premium on the inside with all that CBU build quality. And its certainly less cramped compared to a E90. Besides I thought 5 passengers were a rarity. Its not going to matter much if its 3 people most of the time.
The motor doesn't like to be rushed and neither does the AT box but they both in tandem do the job ok I feel.
Anyway I've always felt the Volvo S60 was a good car overall. The build quality has always been well ahead of the competition in that segment. (Keep in mind I speak of a 2010-era used cars) |
I hear you on the safety aspects of the Volvo. However, take my concerns about owning a used car without warranty and multiply it with the paucity of the service network and (assumed) high cost of spares - that safely rules out the S60. GTO's points on the space and driving pleasure add to this conclusion. Quote:
Originally Posted by Santoshbhat After having been used to an AT car, its not easy to go back to manual, esp for in city drives. I suggest you strike off all MT options.
Among diesels, the Octy DSG would be perfect. But the torsion beam rear is a bitter pill to swallow after paying so much. That leaves you with the Jetta highline DSG and the Octy TSI DSG.
I believe the Octy TSI DSG is now available in Ambition trim as well. |
I agree on the comfort that the DSG provides. However, I'm leery of buying a DSG without extended warranty - I had extended warranty on my Laura. If I'm stuck with an MT, I'd prefer something sweet-shifting like the Jetta to one in which shifting gears is an ordeal.
While I know of your running from your thread, I think going to Petrol from Diesel for the same number of annual km's would be difficult to stomach, particularly when the Diesel version (albeit with MT) is priced lower. Quote:
Originally Posted by thebfg The face lifted Jetta has enough kit to keep you happy! The Highline DSG is a gem of a car. Also it's very economical, it gives 12-13 km/pl in the city which is amazing for a D1 car. (Not sure about this. Correct me if I am wrong)
You can have my word on this since I own the pre-facelift Jetta |
Thanks. I too had a Laura DSG which used to regularly turn out 12 km's within the city and 16+ in spirited highway driving Quote:
Originally Posted by shankar.balan The way I see it, you have the following choices;
1. A straight replacement with the recently phased out Laura Top spec (in case you can find any stock)
2. Go for a new Top spec Octy.
3. Go for a new Top spec Jetta.
I would not go for an used option for exactly the same reasons you have put forward above. With this segment and these Euro manufacturers, it is far better to have the advantage of the extended warranty, zero dep insurance and when you buy brand new, at least psychologically, you feel better, since the car is being driven around in a relatively better controlled environment right from the start and there are no gaping black holes in its history.
Whichever car you choose, just ensure that along with all the generic safety kit like ABS and Airbags etc, it also comes with ESP. I do believe that all cars being sold in Europe and Australia these days, have to offer ESP. I would say that ESP is super-important in India where the typically peculiar circumstances here, might force one to make sudden swerving moves while driving on the highways. |
As you know from my earlier thread which necessitated this purchase in the first place, safety features are front and center. All the alphabet soup that they can throw at me is must-have (ABS, ESP etc.) along with as many airbags as possible.
To your recommendations, 1 is not possible since there is no inventory. 2 is limited to the 1.8 TSI Octavia Ambition because of the compromised suspension in the TDI. My reservations against the TSI are above in response to Santosh's post.
The debate is on 3 since the highest end Jetta MT has little to offer over the mid-level variant.
I'm leaning towards the Jetta Comfortline at this point. Quote:
Originally Posted by nitinbose I would second Shankar here. The top trim would have all the advanced features and no need ever to upgrade.
Regarding a used car, you could check for one with an extended warranty, that's been used for 1-2 years. |
Thanks. See my response to Shankar's post above regarding the top-level trim.
On the used car part, unfortunately, I do not have the luxury of waiting, I'm sure that a good used car fitting more of my criteria would be available. However, I am in need of instant gratification because managing with one car in the family (my wife works + my son needs to be ferried around) is becoming very painful. |