Friends,
Buying a car is proving to be really a tough nut to crack! Just when I was thinking that all my car selection woes are behind and was expecting the delivery of my Octavia 1.8TSI by end of March or early April, I was in for a rude shock. After already having waited for 3 months, I came to know from the dealer that the delivery of my car may happen (that too not guaranteed) only after May. A mail to Skoda asking on the delivery schedule has not elicited any response for the past 2 days. So, I am back seeking guidance from the expert community now on the subject "Octavia TSI vs. Jetta TDI". Let me summarize the situation:
Inspite of reading many posts of GTO where he strongly recommends diesel over petrol regarding German cars, I have been sticking to my choice of a Petrol car mainly due to the NVH levels. Because I am hard of hearing, I need a relatively quiet cabin to make any conversation possible. When I test drove the Octavia TDI, I felt there was this constant thrumming noise in the cabin which was very disturbing. So, I ruled out a Diesel and stuck to petrol. When it came to petrol, Octavia 1.8TSI was THE choice. Though there was always that nagging feeling about the reliability of the Octavia (from all those threads from failing Superbs, Adi's earlier problems with his TSI etc), the horror stories about Skoda A.S.S, and the fact that the Skoda dealer is about 30km away from my place, I still stuck to Octavia justifying to myself that the risks are worth the fun that I will get from driving the TSI and 7 speed DSG.
Now the delay in delivery! I believe I am in the same boat as iliketurtles was a few weeks back. He too was a petrolhead, had booked the Octavia TSI, but ended up with a Jetta TDI. And he is as happy as one could be. So, I have decided to revisit my Petrol vs. Diesel choice. I even get a feeling some Guardian Angel above is repeatedly sending me a message
I made the following comparision between Octavia TSI and Jetta TDI.
The main advantages of Jetta TDI are overall reliability, better A.S.S than Skoda, paddle shifts and the immediate availability. Considering the fun quotient provided by the 2.0TDI + 6 speed DSG combo will be comparable (if not the same) as that of the 1.8TSI + 7 speed DSG combo, the main disadvantages of the Jetta TDI are lack of sunroof, not so fresh look as the Octavia, lack of bixenons with AFS, lesser space and smaller boot. Of these, I think sunroof is not a big deal. The young look, bixenons and interior and boot space are going to be the major compromises I will have to make. Maybe these compromises are worth the peace of mind!
Now here are some questions that come to my mind while considering the change to diesel.
1. Exactly how much fun will I be missing when I choose the 2.0TDI vs. 1.8TSI in terms of power and acceleration? How rev friendly would the diesel engine be compared to the petrol? Also, how does the 6 speed DSG compare with the 7 speed DSG in terms of smoothness of shifting? I believe ride and handling for both would be the same as both have multilink suspension.
2. How much difference do the Bixenons with AFS make over the Xenons without AFS? Will there be any change in brightness levels? If the Xenons are as bright as the BiXenons, then I think I am fine with the lack of AFS. As I do lot of night driving, the brightness is very important.
3. Resale value: The Jetta 2.0TDI costs 23.1L on road vs. the 22.5L of Octavia 1.8TSI. After 5 years how much difference in resale value can I expect between the two? Resale value was never a concern for me. This is just to know how much I am gaining if I change over to diesel.
4. How much noise levels should I expect in the Jetta? In one of his posts iliketurtle mentioned that compared to Octavia TDI, Jetta TDI is very quiet. I will be doing a test drive today evening and will have a first hand experience of the noise. In case I still find some noise to be present in the cabin, should I just ignore it? Is it just a matter of getting used to? I would like to have inputs from other users who have changed over from petrol to diesel cars. What were your first impressions on NVH levels and how do you feel now?
Please let me know your thoughts. Thank you once again for all your support through these difficult times!!
PS: I am taking a test drive in another hour's time. I will soon provide an update on my test drive experience.