Re: Used Skoda Octavia vRS or used Fiat Linea T-Jet I have recently joined team-bhp and this was the first thread that I started. Thanks a lot for this overwhelming response.
I had read somewhere that Octavia mk1 was much more reliable than Octavia mk2 (Laura) as it didn't have much electronics, which was the reason I was considering it but maybe that's not the case.
Considering all the points that you have mentioned it feels that it will be better if I stick to diesel and consider Linea MJD. Maybe consider a remap later.
It will check all the boxes for me. Quote:
Originally Posted by Doge I would be more worried about the RSīs maintenance, was also looking for a used drivers car a few years ago and the RS, Laura TSI and Tjet came to my mind. I loved the Octavia but it was never a trouble free car, especially the early ones when new. After 11 years it would be very expensive. A friend had bought a used RS wagon(!) for 1.5L a few years ago but spent quite a bit on the upkeep. The ground clearance is indeed quite low, scrapes on large breakers when loaded.
The Tjet is a hoot to drive, not in the same league as the RS but very good none the less Another good option is a Fiesta 1.6, doesnīt have the outright power but brilliant chassis. |
I personally like Linea's looks more than that of Fiesta. Also, I'm expecting TJet to be much more engaging to drive than the Fiesta's engine. So if I end up buying a petrol car then I would prefer a turbo petrol. Quote:
Originally Posted by Skyline_GT Did you mean to say Laura VRS and not Octavia? As per my knowledge only the Laura came in the VRS guise when it was on sale. I would say Skoda as it's a much more well built German than the Italian. The vRS is a mind boggling car suited for cruising as much as enthusiastic driving.
If you want a pre owned sedan which you can drive around with a CNG try a Corolla or a Camry. |
Skoda did launch an Octavia vRS but that was for only 3-4 years most probably.
I haven't driven corolla or camry, but I'm not sure if they are designed to be driver's car. Quote:
Originally Posted by brraj These are not the cars for you if you are looking at fuel bills and a tight budget of 2-3 lakhs.
Buying can be cheap but maintaining it will be expensive.
Why dont you stretch a bit and look for diesel hatchback and remap it if you need more fun. |
As I had mentioned, I plan to do outstation trips and will require more space for luggage than what can be offered by a hatchback. Quote:
Originally Posted by //M Why not the Laura 1.8 TSI ??
For 3-3.5 lakhs (or even lower) in NCR, you can get a 2010-11 Laura 1.8 TSI in decent nick. IMO it ticks all your boxes. Plus buying a 6-year old Skoda is anyday better than buying a 11-year old Skoda.
Later in the future if you feel the novelty factor of the 1.8 TSI motor is lost, you can always slap some serious performance parts into the car as the Laura 1.8 TSI is still one of the most mod-friendly cars in the country. |
Laura TSI is an awesome car but I'm expecting it's servicing to be very expensive. But now that you have mentioned, I think I should think about Laura TDI. Quote:
Originally Posted by GTO The time to buy an Octavia vRS is long gone. Whatever examples are there are too old & the car's long-term reliability was nothing to write home about either. Forget about the vRS.
Between the two, I'd anyday pick the Linea T-Jet. You'll get a far newer car. You must also consider a used Laura 1.8 TSI (they're going cheap) and the mighty Abarth Punto (if you can increase the budget). BHPian S2!!! recently picked an Abarth up for slightly over 6 lakhs. This would be my top pick.
If you want to have your cake (power) and eat it too (efficiency), then look at turbo-diesels. But they won't match the sheer driving pleasure of these turbo-petrols. |
I guess you are right, I should stick to diesel cars for the time being. Is Laura TDI reliable enough to be considered? Quote:
Originally Posted by IshaanIan If you are coming from the position of an economical fuel bill, budget of 3 lakhs and possible fitment of CNG, I'd stop you right there and say forget the Octavia vRS. You need to have deep pockets to maintain the car never-mind worrying about fuel bills. Please do your research before such purchases. Here's a thread on our own forum detailing the issues with the vRS Octavia: http://www.team-bhp.com/forum/techni...les-heels.html
go through it and you will realise that fuel bills and a budget of 3 lakhs are the least of your concerns when it comes to possible ownership of the Octy vRS
If you must have one of the two, go for the T-Jet although I'm not sure it would be easy to find one in good shape in your budget, but don't ruin the experience with CNG.
Infact going by your budget constraints, I would recommend a turbo-diesel like some already have, but fortunately our market is not that bad, we still do have an option for a cheap to buy and maintain, safe and relatively modern fun to drive car; SX4 1.6 hands down. Go for early 2006/2007 pre-VVT examples as they had altered the damping on the face-lifted cars. The early models were much better to handle. The car is much better built than other Marutis, handles impacts very well, M16 motor is a treat in this car, mileage is not so great in the early non VVT cars, but because of its rock solid reliability, you can consider a CNG kit on this car. Ground clearance is great and the 16inch wheels offer loads of grip as well as side-wall height which is hard to come by these days. Practical, fun, dirt cheap and reliable IMO |
Even though SX4 1.6 is good but I don't want to buy a Suzuki right now. I prefer a bit exclusive cars. Suzuki cars are all around. Quote:
Originally Posted by lamborghini Most of the older Octy's available today have already had several owners, and aren't maintained well. This, plus a slightly more complex engine make it a no-go.
Linea is a great option but you need to ensure the example you're looking at is well maintained. Service is iffy, and if you're looking for a low maintenance, good fuel economy, reliable daily driver - I am not sure if I would recommend it.
For that, the Japs are the best. Look for a Facelifted Civic (with the square brake lights and smoked headlights), which is going for great deals + good service back up + reliable. |
Civic again has a GC problem and cannot be taken to hilly areas confidently. So I'm looking for better options. |