Hi,
I have been on the hunt for quite sometime for a sedan. The requirements being
- Comfortable with good legroom and good boot space
- Handling should be good. Ride quality is equally important
- should have all the bells and whistles like the ACC, Electric mirrors, etc.
- Safety features ABS and Airbags a must.
The max budget being 8.5 Lacs on the Road.
The three cars shortlisted are:
- Fiesta SXI
- Linea 1.4 FIRE Emotion Pk
- SX4
Test drove these cars and here we go with the observations during the test drive.
Fiesta (S version for test drive odo - 10K kms) - The test drive car color was the blue. The color suited the car but however the car was not cleaned.
The car is driveable in low rpms, engine is pretty refined and responsive. The brakes has a good feel/feedback/bite. Hydralic steering has good feedback.
Rear seat space is a bit of worry, felt it was cramped with somebody like 6 feet tall sitting at the rear seat.
+s
- good driver's car
- Decent FE
- Excellent price quoted (will reveal it later)
- VFM
-s
- Looks dated when compared to the lot
- Leg room at the rear is less
Linea 1.4 (test drive car Dynamic version - odo 6k Kms) - The car looks gorgeous from any angle. The color being silver suited the car very much.
The engine is refined at low rpms but felt at bit rough (rather more throaty) at the high rpms. Decent enough power for the city, somehow felt they could have tuned the engine better. 2nd gear acceleration was a bit lousy. The ride and handling very good (I would rate Linea equal to Fiesta if not better in handling). However scraped almost all the humps on the route IPTL - Varthur - Hopefarm - ITPL
Good space inside when compared to SX4 and Fiesta. Huge boot. Rear seats very supportive and comfortable. Plastics here and there are filmsy.
+s
- Fantastic looks
- comfortable space both at the front and rear
- decent FE
- Huge Boot
- VFM
-s
- Low Ground Clearance (even tough there are reinforcement beams to protect the chasis, I would rather feel uncomfortable when it scrapes the humps)
- Plastics
- *** (Has improved after the launch of Linea as per the owner's feedback here on the forum, but still a bit apprehensive about the ***)
SX4 - ZXI with 5K on the Odo - First of all, I need to mention that the sales rep was the best informed about the car as well as the competitor's cars. No bad mouthing about other cars.
About the car. The car had a bad clutch with a lot of judder. Gear shifts are ok. The engine is not responsive until it touches 3K rpm. The handling is not so confidence inspiring. The ride was a bit bumpy. The rest was pretty fine with the car.
The GC is a big boon with regard to the huge mountains on the road (humps
)
+s
- GC
- Maruti Service Network
- VFM
- decent space if not exceptional
-s
- Engine not so refined
- poor low end torque.
- Rear seat not comfortable. The middle is seat is literally a waste
Here are the observations
Looks: Linea> Fiesta = SX4
Performance- Fiesta > Linea > SX4
Comfort - Linea > Fiesta > SX4
Handling, ride quality & Braking - Linea > Fiesta > SX4
Bells & Whistles - Linea > SX4 > Fiesta
I have not test driven the Verna yet because of the reason that it does not have airbags. Honda City out of the list due to the price (Cant afford the E variant as well, its over 9 lacs OTR Bangalore). GM Aveo ruled out for obvious reasons.
Now comes the tough question. Which of the three is a good buy.
Please provide your feedback, inputs, ownership experience, etc.
Thanks in advance guys