Thanks for your responses guys. My parents are reading this too while we discuss.
Quote:
Originally Posted by khoj I would recommend you take a very serious look at the Mitsubishi Lancer Petrol.
The only negative I can think of is lack of air bags. If this is really an issue then look at the Cedia select. You get all of the above in a bigger & better package at 9.3 L ex showroom it is only slightly above Honda city manual prices. If mileage is an issue you do have the Cedia with LPG option(I think it is still available).
Personally the 2009 honda city was uncomfortable with my driver upfront and me directly behind (both 5'6") and my mother beside me on the TD. It felt like being inside a tube. Strictly my views and maybe I am claustrophobic. Heck no! the hc has a very narrow cabin. So how are your family with average male height being 6' going to be comfortable ever. Do a TD again and with everyone on board imagine it is a longish family outing and things will be clear.
By the way we have an Aveo1.6LT at home strictly for my parents. Very comfortable ride in the back seat. very quiet and spacious cabin. Getting in and out of rear seat is an issue as the door opening is not that big, but once you are inside the cabin is excellent in terms of NVH levels and ride comfort and it does have passenger side air bag! Has GM taken one out? With Halol being a stone throw away I do not think after sale service should be an issue. Factor in the three year service holiday coupled to a three year warranty and it should make up for a good chunk of the price differential mentioned in the thread. The odd ball is the stalk configuration for LHD but one gets used to it.
On the same note considering that average male height in your family is 6 feet
you should also look at the Optra petrol. It gives you all that the Aveo has plus the extra leg room for your legs AND GM just dropped the Optra prices last week between 40 to 70K depending on the model. Here is another car smack bang in the middle of Honda city manual and Automatic price band.
All the best & look forward to seeing your parents new ride complete with tbhp stickers. |
Lancer is a total no-no. too outdated. i know its an excellent machine. but its too long in the tooth. spares could be a problem.
if i was considering old design, i think they would have gone for ikon/accent too.
cedia is under consideration but my parents didn't like its look.
Aveo is still under consideration, but we felt 1.4 to be underpowered, gearbox very very notchy, won't slot properly. rest everything is good. stalks were a problem for my mom. but she said she can get used to it. service i guess shouldn't be a problem.
But my opinion for GM cars is that, both aveo and optra haven't been updated in long while, so i think they may update quite soon. is that a possibility?
they found honda city to be comfortable. as only my parents would be sitting at the back, i don't think they faced issue of narrowness. you know what i mean.
I am hoping, that they bring the car soon. Just not able to decide which one.
Quote:
Originally Posted by YaeJay Pretty simple! Your bro drives it, your dad does 5 km everyday. and your mom drives it. YOUR MOM DRIVES IT! Get whatever she likes. Moms are always the same, ask her what she likes and get it! Such a fuss over nothing i tell you! 10K a year is not much for any car. So I wouldnt bother much about maintanence etc. Ask her to test drive, backseat and drivers, get what she likes ( and also tell her that, its her CHOICE ) and You will find Peace!
Believe me, Your bro or your dad wont complain, let it be moms choice. YOu dont have anything to lose then! ; ) |
if my mom has her way, it won't be anything other than a HONDA CITY
Quote:
Originally Posted by neotraveller I've been told by few on TBHP to stay away from Verna-petrol.
I've heard a few BHPians saying that it gives awful mileage or something?
Please check with verna-petrol owners too.
You an consider the upcoming Indigo-manza too. |
yes, i have told them not to consider verna petrol. its still at their back of mind. but chances are it won't be finalized.
manza won't be under consideration. my dad is not too fond of TATA cars
Quote:
Originally Posted by aaggoswami 1) Aveo is a car that is designed to get the job done without drama. The cabin is has the best sound insulation below Rs. 10 lakh segment, but Aveo is not the best package. The positive aspect is that one wont have any issue regarding spares as Vadodara is near to Halol. For what it offers, Aveo is overpriced specially when compared to SX4.
2) The best car that meets your requirements is SX4 IMHO. It has almost got everything you want, but the suspension is on stiff side. But not bad ride quality. The SX4 with updated grille and new engine head comes on Oct 13 i.e. day after tomorrow. |
agreed with your first point. if i consider Aveo 1.6, it gets too close to linea and city levels, in which case, it make sense to go for either of those two.
as the best car, no sx4 doesn't meet that requirement. if it would have, it would already be in our garage. its too loud at higher revs, cabin quality ain't any good. mom was uncomfortable in the rear seat. they felt the thuds when going over potholes. which weren't there in aveo, honda city.
one important thing that is of consideration is status or image of car. Aaggoswami must be familiar with the morning walkers groups near Kamati baug. With our limited budget, we don't have much choices in this segment.