Well this should be a major twist! I booked Corolla GL instead.
I went with my brain on this one rather than following my heart. I figured its not the right time to buy the Civic for the following reasons.
1. The civic model is almost 3years old, and since most of the cars in the same luxury segment has a dozen more features than the civic, its pretty obvious that they would make an upgrade soon or atleast in the next couple of years, and that would terribly throw down the resale value incase I want to sell it after a few years.
2. The price is almost 1-2 lakhs more that the other cars of the same class, and again would be difficult reselling scenario for the car in a couple of years. Ofcourse civic will always have its looks, but the picky buyers are just going to point out the obvious.
3. Being a family with "big" people, the negative reviews on the GC and soft suspension is a big concern for me, and I know it can be fixed to an extent if I go for 17" wheels or get a harder suspension upgrade. Eventhough, it maybe just a few occassions where the back seat might be crowded, but I would hate to have a reason for my orthodox elders to pin point on something like scraping issue on city/town pot holes and speed breakers by a car worth 15L.
4. Corolla offered free insurance and I ended up saving 2L on my purchase (as compared to if I had chosen civic). So looks like I have enough left over for a Christmas/New year vacation! Ha!
So I decided to go for the Corolla GL MT. The 4speed AT version was available only for the usual colors and they refuse to even look for a Black AT. I saw some reviews that the FE is slightly lesser on the AT version being only 4speed, and also again, resale value could possibly be down on AT because there are other 5speed cars of the same segment.
Why worry so much about resale value? Because I want to get a good price to buy my next car after say 2 or 5
... might be an upgraded civic, or accord, or audi TT, or Nissan 350Z or BMW.
Hoping that indian road scenario would be better then so as to not worry about GC and other stuff.
The civic has always been a "love at first sight" on every aspect, but I rather wait a couple more years for an updated model to come, than to spend 15L on a model with less features.
I am still not 100% satisfied with the Corolla. The cabin space is much lesser than the civic, and I feel the front dash and steering is much close to the seat even when I pull the seat completely back. I also need to get used to the super sensitive brakes.
The booking experience wasn't that satisfying either because they did not throw in any free stuff! Not even Mats or Sun Film. Oh well, will have to spend a few bucks there. These things did make me think again, if I have to go with the corolla or civic.. but it was settled and booking amount given.
The car will arrive in a couple of days, and I will purchase it later next week after all the Pre-delivery Checkup
PS: Really had a tough time looking up for Black Altis pictures to help make my decision on the color. Looks like the Atlis is made 70% for the Pearl White (ivory) color and 30% for the Metallic Silver! TBHP has one post with Black altis, looks like mine would be the second