Thanks All for the suggestions.
Quote:
Originally Posted by imp! So I know that no one has made this suggestion yet, but, if you require a diesel sedan that performs well in the City and the Highway, then why not take a look at the Octavia Diesel? I know it is a previous generation car, but it is extremely reliable and is a work horse that will last you 200,000 km at the very least. Although, maintenance will be a higher than equivalently priced Japanese cars. |
Considering other skoda service stories, this is ruled out.
Quote:
....then the City will be your best bet. Although, IMHO, it is grossly over priced to be called VFM, it does offer better comfort than the Corolla Altis, Civic, Laura and Jetta. ....
The Vento, however, is what I'd wait for. ...Keep in mind though, there is no ways anybody can predict the reliability of the Polo/Vento. The way these cars behave in other markets is no indication of their reliability in India.
|
Thanks. Another friend too suggested Vento. Started reading the Polo ownership threads. So far impressed.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GTO Neither. Stretch the budget for a used car to 8 - 9 lakhs. ....
If you can't stretch your budget for a used car over 5.5 lakhs, then its better for you to buy new (as you have a 10 lakh rupee budget).
The ANHC fits your requirements best. |
Thanks. I guess used car is ruled out. I am exploring OD facility with banks, but my risk levels and rate of interest are simply high.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ACM 1) Tata Manza Aura + ABS Diesel - Best Value, Best Space, Deisel Economy. Good low maintenance Engine.
2) Fiat Linea Emotion Pack Option Diesel - Good Value, Best Looks, Diesel Economy. Good low maintenance Engine.
Used - Stretch budget to 8L and get
1) Corolla Altis - Post 2008
2) Honda Civic - Post 2008
3) Honda Accord - 2.4 AT/MT ( 2005-2007)
. |
Thanks. I am including the new cars suggested. Used cars that you quoted are out of my budget.
Quote:
Originally Posted by jayanth_yk 2250 Kms/month is a lot of driving around. My recommendations are defnitely a new Diesel. |
Yes. Thanks to my new house. I am still trying to optimize/ reduce this.
Quote:
Here is my list if you like it
1. Innova - Great for long journeys
2. Manza - A real big car and a true VFM
3. i20 CRDi? - Great Diesel car with all bells and wistles
|
Innova is out of my range. Even used car rates seem to hold value than Hondas.
Manza, yes.
i20 - will it be comfortable for 5 person family? I would also like to "upgrade" to a sedan/ SUV feel. For the heck of it, I will TD this and Polo.
Quote:
Originally Posted by jayanth_yk Some gyan on ANHC since you listed #1 in both used and new list.
I personally own an ANHC, ...
So ANHC would be the last option in my recommendation list, since running-in costs are still not comparable to the Diesels. |
Coming from ANHC owner, much appreciated. This is what TBHP is for. Candid feedback from actual owners. Much appreciated.
Yes, will keep in mind the fuel efficiency. Reading some of the long term ANHC threads the service costs of ANHC seems to be lower than my Santro
Thats a real tempting reason to have a hard look at ANHC.
I have moved to new locality trying to figure out my daily mileage and looking at ways to optimize. If the mileage can be reduced, then ANHC will up my ranking.
Summary of recommendations:
Used car - ruled out with my budget limitations.
New car - based on suggestions and my own perceptions, the following are in my radar (in no particular order)
Tata Manza
Fiat Linea
Ford Fiesta
Honda City
Vento
i20 & Polo - atleast a TD.
Scorpio - atleast TD
I know this is a sedan forum, but Scorpio was not discussed. Should I consider it?
Also having started travelling everyday long commutes and feel that Driver comfort should be a major criteria in any of the above cars. Any suggestions for this?