Hi all,
This is my first post here as a new thread. Hope I am not breaching any rule here.
I am actually in a dilemma
- thought of seeking advice from fellow BHP'ians. Have been trying to buy a 2nd car since my MUV (Innova) has already done 55K Kms since I picked up in Aug '07 and my need is clear;
1) Diesel - looking at the petrol price scene & good engines coming in diesel too
2) MT - I hate AT's since i think they take away the pleasure & control of the car (AT heads - no offense. This is just my opinion)
3) Sedan which has good legroom & boot space - since I already have a MUV i.e., Innova - which is amazing. My family loves it - so I will retain it by doing some pampering like new tyres, clutches, etc.,.
I first ventured into - Superb or Volvo - but dropped them since Superb did not have a Diesel MT option & Volvo S40 is still not launched in India (then why the hell they post in the India web page
about S40 & S60). Even thought about 3 series but dropped it since it was not in line with the price & what we get. (I agree that BMW tag is something which demands something premium - but can't throw away money for what we get in return).
Since - I had no other choice (i hate why guys can't have a diesel MT in all cars!!) Finally - I was forced to look a level lower & researched Laura, Altis Diesel, Cruze, Linea & Optra Magnum.
Of this - as I researched & test drove - Cruze & Optra dropped off simply because of their low resale value & to be honest - I didn't like the looks. Linea looked great & posture of the car was good - but dropped off the list due to it's hard steering & clutch. As well the TATA after sales service was a put off.
At the end - I am left with 2; Laura Elegance 2.0 TDI CR MT & Corolla Altis Diesel HG.
So here is my comparison of these two (only compared the ones which are significantly different from other);
Laura Elegance 2.0 CR TDI Corolla Altis Diesel HG Dimension (Length x width x height) 4569 x 1769 x 1485 mm 4540 x 1760 x 1480 mm Displacement 1968 1364 Transmission 5 Speed MT 6 Speed MT Boot Space 560 liters 475 liters Max Power 110 bhp @ 4200 rpm 88.4 PS @ 3800 rpm Max Torque 250 Nm 205 Nm Mileage (as per Sales folks) 12 to 14 in City 18 to 23 in City Ground Clearance 164 mm 175 mm Tyres 205/ 55 R 16 195/65 R15 Breaks All Discs but only front is ventilated (Inner cooling) All Ventilated Discs Antenna Normal Printed Antenna Audio Single CD with 8 speakers 6 CD changer with 6 speakers Seat Material Leather Fabric On Road Price 1910966 (Includes Insurance, Road Tax, Extended Warranty & Drive Assure) 1595913 (Includes Insurance, Road Tax & Smiles) Discount/ Offer 62167 (Insurance free, Corporate Discount) + Sun Flim + Teflon Coating + double (Fabric & Rubber) mats + mud flaps + IND registration plate) Nil (can give reverse parking sensor free) Net Price 1845489 (by not taking extended warranty) 1595913 Price Difference `+249576 `-249576
There are few other differences which crop up with Laura are resale value, after sales service issues (though i haven't heard recently - hope they are improving). But this car is fully loaded in all aspects & both interiors & exteriors look extremely rich.
When it comes to Toyota - I can vouch their service (being a customer for last 3+ yrs) & resale value is very good. But the car lacks presence in front of Laura on road. 2nd it lacks power technically (88.4 PS Vs 110 PS). However - i didn't felt that while I did a test drive up to 120 kmph. But couldn't go beyond since Hosur road was all barricaded that day.
So - I am confused & need your suggestions. I would like to book the vehicle this week itself since both cars have a good 1 to 2 month waiting period for black color.