Guys, had taken a few test drives before posting here and wanted to add that in the next post, however since I am a new member here, had to wait till the mods approved the first one. Am completing what I intented to say then.
Now for the observations about the TD's I had taken:
VW Vento
- Very Good to drive, but not brilliant.
-Found it pretty cramped. Even more so in the rear seat. Could not even sit straight!!! Ingress and Egress was not convenient for a tall guy. (Almost ruled out due to this)
-Cabin didn't feel ariy and felt physically and visually cramped.
- Pretty much like a hatch with a boot.
- Maintainence costs unknown.
- Seems to have a good image.
Pretty much ruled out because I can't even sit straight (am 6') in the back seat. The ingress and egress was terrible too. Fiat Linea
- Good fun to drive. Good Handling. A bit bumpy.
- The engine vibrations did seem to come through into the cabin and steering.
- Cabin gave a cramped 'feeling'. Attractive looking dash, however overly done up, but nothing one can't live with.
- Admiartion guarenteed! Except for the front, looks like a stunner. Even the inside.
- After Sales from Tata, which seems to give Fiat a step motherly treatment. Tata anyway not known to be too good with ***.
- Moderately good image.
Under consideration, but wonder if it is worth the extra money vis-a-viz a Manza which provides a lot more space Tata Manza
- Space, Space, Space! Loved the space inside the cabin. VERY comfortable.
- Supposed to be cheap to maintain.
- After Sales Service is suspect. Not known for it's reliablity.
- Fairly good driving experience. The vibrations, though a huge improvement over the Indigo, did come through into the cabin and on the steering.
- Frequent gear changes needed.
- Tata vehicles have a poor image (the Dilli-wala in me coming forward now!). Don't particularly fancy the idea of being in a Tata.
- Is the "logical" from the head choice car, however doesn't appeal to the heart at all.
This has been the base choice, but am looking for better options and the Tata tag isn't something I look forward to. Ford Fiesta
- Had taken a test drive long back and remember it being very cramped in front. Enough to rule it out. Remember it having a gem of a deisel engine though.
Too cramped, even in the front to be seriously considered.
Hyundai Verna
-Had sat in it when it was launched. Found the cabin pretty much cramped. Was surprised that the old accent had more space.
Again too cramped to be seriously considered. Maruti SX4 Deisel
- A very practical choice on many fronts.
- Spacious cabin. Easy ingress and egress.
- Don't like the styling of the car on the whole, but nothing I can't live with.
- Engine seems underpowered (1248cc for a large car). May not last the distance. I mean, I expect to keep the car for about 1.5L kms.
- Vibrations do come into the cabin.
- Seems to need a lot of gear changes, which may make city driving a pain.
- The A pillar Blind Spot is a HUGE bother. May be a big issue on hilly roads. Possibly enough to get one into an accident. It makes me wonder if it is prudent to even consider this car, given this issue.
Am very seriously concerned about it.
- If one can ignore the problems the A pillar and vision problems it causes, it may be another 'logical-from the head' choice.
A serious choice, however wonder if it it worth the extra bucks over a Manza, with only minor benefits of a slightly better image and probably better reliability, however may not be as rugged. The A-Pillar issue is a serious hindrance to my mind. Optra Magnum TDCi LS
- Whoooooooooooooo Hooooooooooooooooooooo! What a car to drive! Seriously!!!!! I mean, why, just why didn't this car sell in huge numbers?
- The driving experience was just wonderful. Have taken 2 test drives totalling to about 80 odd kms. Didn't feel tired after the drives, which were largely on open roads. Extreme acceleration. Loved the feeling of the torque and being pushed into the seat. Excellent brakes and straight line composure.
- Stable plaint ride. A bit of body roll and hence may not be the ideal car to be pushed into corners, but very good for everyday driving and more. Seems it would keep me comfortable on days when I need to drive 100 odd kms in a day in the city/city-suburb.
- Dated Cabin. However feels pretty ariy. I like that the dashobard doesn't get onto your face (unlike the newer "modern" cars like the Linea, City etc). The Music system could have surely been better, however those can be changed over time.
- Spacious cabin with ample head and leg room. Very comfortable seats- Front and back. Seems will be good as both- a self driven or as a chauffer driven car. (giving as powerful a car to a young driver does worry me a bit though)
- Not the smartest car on the block, but acceptably good looking.
- Seems to have a good image, though not top of the line. Please correct me here if my perception is wrong.
- Just loved the car and am glad that something like this is available at about 9L after discounts.
- Heart yearns for this car. Head wonders at it's prudence, given that it may be phased out soon.
Any idea if it really is going to be phased out? Now for the questions...
* As you may have guessed, am inclined towards the Optra Magnum TDCi LS. Am reluctant to increase the budget as much, but seems that the vehicle will keep me fresher during long days and hence may pay back by increasing my work effeciency.
* However have concerns about it's after sales service. Any gain in personal time and effeciency would be lost to frustrating After Sales Service.
*
My Biggest concern if the parts being available for the next 5-7 years, given this car may be phased out. I think it has been around in some avatar or the other since about 2000.
Guidance and views on this are very much needed.
*
Any idea of how long this car may be in production?
* Would Optra be reliable enough for 3000kms (or longer) trips?
* Any other opinions on what car may be suitable are welcome.
Quote:
Originally Posted by sidindica 1. Vento TDI HL
2. Verna RB 1.6 CRDi |
Sidindica, Was very surprised at the space in the Vento. Could not even sit straight on the rear seat. No headroom (am 6').
Verna, when I had seen it on it's launch too was pretty cramped. Even lesser cabin space than the Accent. Also, the Korean cars don't seem rugged enough.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mdsaab Sidindica is spot on with the choices
you can also add the new ford fiesta to the list which should be launched shortly. |
The new Fiesta shown in Autocar seems very appealing. Wonder if it will have the required space, considering how cramped the current Fiesta seems. Also, unsure if the extra bucks would be worth it. My search started with a Manza at about 7L OTR.
Quote:
Originally Posted by SPARKled The Verna VGT is on the way out and the Vento TDI HL are unlikely to be available for about 8-9L on the road. The lower variants of the Linea can be got at that price which drives much better than the Manza. But for sheer space Manza is the only choice. |
SPARKled, The Linea looks a whole lot better from the rear and the side. From the front, both look pretty bad. The handling seems better in the Linea, though the Manza seems better for everyday driving. Any other thoughts on how the Linea is better?
Quote:
Originally Posted by sidindica The problem with the optra is that its now an 8 year old product. The engine is 4 years old, but the chassis is the same Daewoo Nubira engineered in 2002. Second, the depreciation rate stinks like anything, even if the car is gonna be kept for 6-7 years. There are newer and better choices available then whats the point of the optra? The car's time has gone and it should be phased out. GM should come out with a stripped down Cruze LS for 2 lakhs less. |
Yes Sidindica, the chasis is the same Nubira/Lancetti one, however it seems to do it's job. Getting about 1-1.5L less
after 5-7 years is something I am willing to take given the sheer comfort and driving pleasure this car offers (may be more efficient in work to offset that cost
).
The big concern is about the car being stuck for days for the lack of spares. Being without it may paralyze my life. That is the big concern.
Note from the Team-BHP Support Team: Posts merged. Please use the "edit" button if posting within 30 minutes of the first post, instead of creating another back-to-back post.
Also use "Multi Quote" option for quoting Multiple posts.