Quote:
Originally Posted by pyrodrive I honestly think that this " milk and bread etc can kill your cat" is overhyped.
|
Milk & Bread cannot kill your cat if they eat other stuff also. But if they eat only Vegetarian stuff, it's guaranteed that they will suffer from taurine deficiency (and other deficiencies also). Humans & Dogs can synthesize their own taurine but cats cannot. The first thing which happens with taurine deficiency is that the cat goes blind. And this is not theory or something which happens to some cats - but will happen to each & every cat who doesn't have enough taurine in their diet. Vegetarian stuff has zero taurine. Even with meat & fish, cooking removes most of the taurine from the food, so feeding only cooked meat will also mean the same problem. Till the 70s, world over, cats were never fed by humans even if they lived with humans. Cats were kept as hunters to hunt on rats & other pests and that's what they ate. In the 60s & 70s, cats started being kept at home in the US etc. When cats were fed cooked meat at homes, all of a sudden there was a huge number of pet cats going blind. In pet food (dry & wet), they add taurine as a supplement because meat in catfood is cooked & lacks taurine. About milk, most cats unless they continously drink milk from childhood become lactose intolerant so they get diarrhea.
In general, the more vegetarian food, cats have (or even dogs for that matter), the more chances they get diabetic as they grow older & then you will have to inject insulin daily and eventually there is also kidney failure. Dry food has a lot of plant food as fillers mixed with meat so only dry food is not a good diet. Also if a cat is only on dry food, there is a high chance of having urinary blockage which is very painful.
Quote:
Originally Posted by pyrodrive But I still have one rescued street cat and he is probably in better shape than the royals in his diet of bread and milk in the morning and rice and dal at night. He turns up his nose at regular cat food but gets raw meat from time to time as treats. |
Unless he kills & eats other stuff, there is a chance that he is going to get diabetic with age. And depending how frequently or infrequently he gets raw meat, if he becomes taurine deficient, he will go blind. About raw, raw meat is best unless it's fish. Raw fish contains something which destroys some particular in the cats body. Again, if that's not all he eats, it's Ok, but if a cat's diet is 100% raw fish, he will be ill eventually.
As for milk, if the cat can digest it gives calcium which is good. Cat which eats only home cooked meat may get rickets because of calcium deficiency because in the wild, they eat the bones of small prey which gives them calcium
About my cat, he was a stray cat, I adopted when he was 3 months old. From day 1, he wouldn't touch milk. When he first came to my building, I had no familiarity with cats or any pets. When he came crying to me with acute hunger, I offered him milk. He slept next to the milk in our building stairway but didn't touch the milk & was hungry through the night. Next morning, I bought him some cheap fish from fishmonger & he ate what seemed to twice his weight within minutes, he was that hungry. He will also walk away from chappati or bread or biscuits even if he starving to death. Anyway, after a few weeks I adopted him & he is an indoor-outdoor cat - he spends the night inside & half the day outside. He doesn't eat anything outside even if chases prey & tortures them - I guess he has lost the habit of eating his own kill.
Quote:
Originally Posted by condor Generations of us have seen cats eating what we provide them - rice, milk, etc - the regular stuff that we prepare at home. And they have managed their meat needs outside. |
If you are not their only source of food, then it's OK, I guess. Cats on the street anyway don't live long, they either die in cat fights or come under some vehicle, so at young age, they are not going to get diabetic irrespective of what they eat & as long as they kill their meat outside, they are not going to become taurine deficient - especially if they eat raw meat. Raw meat is loaded with taurine.