re: Indian Army goes undercover in Myanmar - A Proud Moment for all! Quote:
Originally Posted by rookieraj The govt of Myanmar is ruthless and they are nobody's allies. China gives that country more than what India can give them. They are extreme nationalists and stood up to the might of the USA. Name one country that shifted its capital for fear of being invaded from the sea.
Myanmar has to tackle the 20 odd secessionist movements prevailing there. They do that by brokering ceasefires with most insurgent groups and sorting the others out one by one.
Informing Myanmar or launching a joint operation with them would have achieved absolutely nothing. Information would have reached the terrorists. |
I know its very easy to get carried over by misplaced patriotism, but conducting military operations in a foreign country without keeping their government in the loop is not patriotism. (if the media reports about the Burmese government being informed post operations is true)
Regarding your allegation that informing the Burmese government would have tipped off the insurgents, that's factually incorrect. The Burmese government has helped the Indian government in at least 3 publicly acknowledged cases of hugely successful counter terrorism operations.
I quote from an article in Indian Express: "Among the cross-border operations tacitly acknowledged by the government is “Operation All Clear” conducted inside Bhutan in December 2003 to eliminate North Eastern militant groups based in South Bhutan. About 30 militant camps —13 ULFA, 12 NDFB and 5 KLO — were the target of intelligence-based operations which included troops from 3 Corps. The then Army chief, General N C Vij, had announced that 650 militants had been “neutralised” — either killed or captured — during the operations. * In April-May 1995, following the signing of an MoU for “maintenance of peace and tranquility in border areas”, India and Myanmar (then Burma) conducted a joint military operation, “Operation Golden Bird”. The Indian Army’s 57 Mountain Division blocked a column of around 200 NSCN, ULFA and KLO militants moving through the Myanmar-Mizoram border towards Manipur, after it picked up a consignment of weapons on the Bangladesh coast near Cox’s Bazar." Quote:
Originally Posted by bhardwhu As an Indian army veteran, it gives me immense pride to see well executed military operation where the collateral damage is minimal/non-existent. To the point of whether Myanmar was informed or not, I would like to quote our ADGMO, per the attached news (seen the same statement in various other articles) that it was orchestrated keeping Myanmar informed and with my experience, likely to be a coordinated one.
The media tamasha is understood since it helps in TRP howsoever mindless that would be though. The NSG operation was televised live in Mumbai 26/11 and imagine the plight of our military strategy that it was all given on platter to the coordinators of that attack.
Media absolutely needs to be leashed and sensitized to our armed operations. But having said that, the same media has also helped our youth fill with pride about the army and that should be lauded. http://www.hindustantimes.com/india-...1-1357203.aspx
regards |
Sir, I'm quite certain that the Burmese government was informed prior to the operation, in which case, it is fine, however the media reports clearly state that they were informed once the operation was close to being wrapped up. See link: http://www.indiatimes.com/news/india...ar-233470.html
These news articles are most probably false bravado to try and buttress the public faith in the government's will to take decisive action in cases of terrorism across borders, but as an ex defence officer, you will surely agree that much more needs to be done on the ground to actually secure our borders, especially in the North East.
NSCN(K) has a strength of approx. 1500 cadres, of which 1000 are in Burma, this operation killed between 20-50, as per the media reports. One really needs to know what measures are being taken to neutralize or reform the other 500 cadres residing in India as well as secure the borders from future infiltration attempts. That will be a real victory, not this stupid show of chest thumping.
Last edited by Lalvaz : 11th June 2015 at 00:15.
|