Pros & Cons of security guards Topic: Are security guards becoming a liability ?
1) Shows unwanted arrogance while manning the gates of tech parks, apartments.
2) Common complaints that some of these guards get involved in cases of theft.
3) This one makes me very upset - In the name of checking (which is a farce) they handle the cars very badly. They do not care whether the car has an electrically operated boot or not. If you say anything to them, standard response is "we are poor". And there will be one supervisor who will come speaking something really illogical and makes the scene worse.
4) Cannot depend on them for security anymore - most of the guards are often weak, having struggle understanding instructions and got language barriers too. When incidents like fights, fire, theft etc. happen in front of their eyes, they try to be mute spectators than doing anything. They don't even report issues on time.
5) In some of the cases, common theme is that the security guard commits a mistake and he disappears. Some gets traced after a while but many not traced.
6) Two child abuse cases committed by the security guard and the victims are very young children. (I know this incident first hand) They got beaten up by other security guards and asked to leave. I heard after some time that they got another job in the same city and working for another security agency - not sure of the veracity of this information but won't be surprised if that happened.
7) They are trained to do speed checks inside IT camps using naked eyes. Twice i had to fight because the security guard stopped me at the gate saying I was overspeeding ? My scooter was not even at 20km per hour as there were speed breakers every few meters so accelerating fast after every speed breaker was impossible - especially on a Honda Activa. They were insisting on me paying fine but i refused and said feel free to complain to the management along with proof of over speeding, the topic ends there. Wastes a lot of time.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The life of a security guard is not easy too. They end up being hired as a security guard and goes through the following:
1) Standing in the sun and watching areas which otherwise can be monitored using cameras.
2) Lift operators
3) In apartment complexes most treat them with disrespect - makes them clean cars, lift heavy items (after shopping, while shifting house)
4) I remember my neighbor asking the security guard to even take care of the kids and accompany them to the park.
5) Very common to see them tired, hungry, sleepy - some work for 2 days continuously.
6) Salary is not credited to them on time.
7) Stays in very poor, unhygienic conditions.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
That said, are there any regulations on the mushrooming security guard business ? While there is lot of fancy stuff going around like "background verified" security guards available etc. are they really true ? Do they have powers or mostly vanity in front of apartments etc.? Why can't most of them be replaced by cameras, access controls, bio-metrics etc. ? Why can't we use heat/thermal/infra red sensors for explosive checking etc. while entering a private area ? Like hotels, IT parks, banks etc. ?
I understand the logic of providing employment to the numerous guards and helps them build their life. But I feel its becoming a liability -
1) Not sure if they have any powers
2) Having an untrained, demotivated, poorly paid security guard is a risk than the help he can offer (or expected to offer)
Are there any regulations governing the industry - private security ? Should not they be replaced by electronics and gadgets wherever possible ? Imagine a situation where the guard goes upset (for some reason) and uses his gun to shoot indiscriminately (especially the ones who carries a gun while guarding ATM's, cash delivery vans). Who will take the ownership in such situations ? The company which employed the guard ?
Thoughts?
Last edited by sunishsamuel : 10th April 2017 at 11:10.
|