|
Search Forums |
Advanced Search |
Go to Page... |
Search this Thread | 338,526 views |
16th May 2018, 22:12 | #16 | |
BANNED Join Date: Nov 2016 Location: Dehradun
Posts: 948
Thanked: 8,332 Times
| Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s Quote:
One thing I agree, if there is a single owner of a decent sized piece of land, he may be seen driving a Mahindra 475 DI and an Alto, but his sugarcane yield itself is enough to make him buy a BMW 3 series every year, but this is the condition for the farmer on the another end of the spectrum. Overall, the story is more or less same everywhere; the thing is that at the end of the day 'only the fittest will survive'; Indians love competing and they really don't care about the pity things like real knowledge, development of subordinates, ethics or other peers at times (and the dirty level office politics, idiotic bosses expecting personal favours etc are very common in India). Whatever is happening is nothing but the outcome of cheap practices and a mindset of people that once you are in, you are safe. Oh yes, this isn't it IT only; I have a cousin in real estate and he is searching for a new job with a CV in hand which reads 25+ years of experience. Coming to IT, bulk recruiters are visiting colleges and taking huge numbers of students every year. Trust me gentlemen, I have never done a job in It but still can beat half of my friends when it comes to coding and they are the guys who have been working since over an year - but what with skill? They do the same thing multiple times daily!! | |
() Thanks |
|
16th May 2018, 22:31 | #17 | |
BHPian Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Southern Calif.
Posts: 755
Thanked: 4,539 Times
| Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s Quote:
Sharing a personal story here - When I first became a manager (in So.Cal) I had hired an engineer who checked all the boxes. Very soon I realized this person was super smart, and hardworking, I put her on every big challenge, and she helped the team shine. 5 years, down the line she was my peer, then my director. (some 12+ years younger to me) Just reporting to a person that you hired, does not mean you will be let go. This person I hired, went on to lead a huge team at another company, and when they were hiring, I was one of the first few people she had on their interview list. When companies reward productivity, people who can learn quicker, work smarter, and harder shine. 25year work experience may have mattered in a different industry at a different time. At places producing products, where productivity matters (rather than people managers), people who can produce will climb up higher and faster. There is no shame in working for younger people who are rewarded with these opportunities to lead. These times call for understanding of meritocracy, and some humility (overcoming ego). If one choses to cook up stories of favoritism, and subservient attitude, as if every person who is promoted does not deserve it - it only causes great mental anguish, hatred, and feeling cheated. People who end up going around town claiming this, are often the ones who do not get strong recommendations for future jobs. Tangent relevant for these times (that I keep reminding myself of) - Love the work you do, not the company you work for. You never know when the company will stop loving you. Last edited by GutsyGibbon : 16th May 2018 at 22:42. | |
(3) Thanks |
The following 3 BHPians Thank GutsyGibbon for this useful post: | DrANTO, FINTAIL, The Alchemist |
17th May 2018, 00:34 | #18 |
Distinguished - BHPian | Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s Any tenured employee in the IT/Tech industry who still believes that their career growth can be tracked vertically (Manager>Director>Sr Director etc) is kidding themselves, in the current evolution of the industry. I must admit the article reads like an auto-biography for most if not all mid-senior level IT/Tech employees: if you have crossed 18-20 years in the industry, it best that you have an exit plan in place for that near-certain probability of you getting laid off. Perhaps not surprisingly, the suggestion I read about moving towards agricultural ownership is something I've heard many peers speak about in unison! |
() Thanks |
17th May 2018, 02:03 | #19 |
Team-BHP Support | Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s
Wow, I just looked him up, he was still in college when I was already working in TCS. While he took the finance route to the top, many of my peers who are still in TCS are stuck in middle management because they worked as engineers. This is a common theme. Although these companies make their money through IT services, those who do the actual IT services work are disposable. Indian IT companies are in the business of making money, and not in the business of technology innovation. Therefore, real power/control lies with folks in sales and finance. They are the real rainmakers of Indian IT companies. Once I understood that, I left TCS and joined a tiny company where I too have some power/control. Still there after 20 years. Members from non-IT fields are saying that longer experience is an asset in their fields. Actually, it can be true in IT too, provided folks were careful in their choices. But, most of them weren't and aren't careful about it. People often talk about re-skilling, as if they can change their profile like a costume. In my opinion, the most valuable asset a professional has is their domain knowledge. When doctors/lawyers work for 20+ years, what they gain is domain knowledge. That is what makes those years so valuable. Similarly, if an IT professional builds domain knowledge about an industry, it is much more valuable to the company than a skill you pick up over a month from some certificate course. Technical skills are just tools in your mental toolbox. Knowing how to apply those tools to solve problems or build products/solutions for an industry, is domain knowledge. For example, to develop a banking/taxation software, the knowledge of banking/taxation is 10 times more important than knowing programming. Unfortunately most IT professionals keep hopping from one industry to another, without bothering to learn anything about the domain. These days many IT folks are learning statistics/data-analytics/ML. But these are tools too. If you don't have domain knowledge, you will not know how to apply those tools to that domain. Last year, a 17 year IT professional was seeking a job at my company. He was making insane amount of salary in Bangalore, but was willing to take a pay cut so that he can work in his native village. My biggest problem with him was that he didn't understand what domain knowledge meant. It went something like this: Me: Looking at your CV, I don't see any domain knowledge relevant to enterprise telephony. Why are you applying here? He: I have lots of experience in embedded programming, so I can pick telephony programming easily. Me:I am not talking about programming. The domain knowledge in enterprise telephony takes many years to learn. All the fresh engineers take at least 3 years just to get a hang of it. And I expect much more than that from seniors, they have to be good enough to advice customers. It is not something you can pick up over a month via some training. You have to go through full life cycle, more than once. He: Hmm... Me: BTW, going through your CV, I couldn't really make out what domain knowledge you have. Can you shed some light on it? He: <he listed out some 8-10 fields>...and agriculture... Me: What? It is not possible for someone to have domain knowledge in so many fields. At least, not in more than 2-3 fields. It appeared he was just naming various industries for which he had developed software. So I asked for clarification. Me: You have domain knowledge in agriculture? He: Yes. I have developed software for an equipment that measured soil moisture. It is used by farmers. Me: So, are you an expert in farming? He: Ugh... No. Me: Listen, having domain knowledge means knowing the customers business better than they do. Most of the time, customers have clear business requirements, but have vague ideas on how to solve it. In those circumstances, because we would have implemented solutions numerous times in that domain, we can suggest/provide effective solutions and advice on the best practices. He: Oh, that makes sense. Me: Now can you tell me whether you have such domain knowledge in any industry? He: <he gave some shaky answer, I don't remember it clearly> He clearly had no definite domain knowledge. He had worked on various platforms using various programming languages. He just had a big toolbox. His long experience created high salary expectation, while providing no value in return. This is how long experience becomes a liability rather than an asset. |
(18) Thanks |
The following 18 BHPians Thank Samurai for this useful post: | ani_meher, bj96, BlackPearl, cnu, deep_behera, DrANTO, FINTAIL, Iyencar, nissar, sandhyab, SaptarshiP, shancz, Somil07, sups, swami, thebengalee, VinsWagen, WalterWhite |
17th May 2018, 07:36 | #20 | |
BANNED Join Date: Nov 2016 Location: Dehradun
Posts: 948
Thanked: 8,332 Times
| Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s Quote:
Team-BHP is indeed a treasure of knowledge, you always have the right person here to answer the query. Just did my maths and I can guess that your experience itself should be more than my age itself. Noted down both the points above and will be applied with time. It is indeed a very important tip for any new comer - "know the business of your customer and you will know what exactly to develop for them". | |
(1) Thanks |
The following BHPian Thanks VKumar for this useful post: | Samurai |
17th May 2018, 09:33 | #21 |
Senior - BHPian | Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s When I look at jobs in linkedin - most of them ask for technical skills first and then domain knowledge. Probably in the US where most software product development and sales happen , domain knowledge is a lot more important . It matters if you run your own business. Agree to what civic-sense and Hayek have said . If you passed out in the 90s and rode the liberalization boom and led a conservative lifestyle , you should scrape through for the rest of your life. A friend's friend works in the Rajasthan govt's IT department . They have the usual software dev,testing etc jobs. He has a secure job till 60 , but I suppose his salary is much lesser compared to what private firms pay . So in the end it does average out. High growth can't last forever. I also saw that Jagadeesh Maiya has found a job after leaving Cisco - he must've taken a pay cut though . So things aren't as bad as they're made out to be , something eventually does work out . |
() Thanks |
17th May 2018, 10:18 | #22 |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Bengaluru
Posts: 4,375
Thanked: 2,256 Times
| Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s Have just changed job with 25 years of experience. Being in wireless/datacom area and with 5G development/IoT picking pace was able to move quickly. The positions open are lesser in numbers but they are also in the architecture/system engineering levels. If you have been technical and working on new technology every couple of years, its not that bad. You also kind of know everyone or know someone common who have also moved up working in the same companies abroad and India as you I am glad that I did not choose a management role. Not that its bad. I know people who are now moving from Cisco/Nokia/Ericsson etc to Amazon kind of companies. I also know people quoted in the first post from same company who were managers and are now out of jobs. At least with very good pay they are not that badly placed in life. Its equal to being in Indian companies for twice the amount of time ! |
() Thanks |
17th May 2018, 10:29 | #23 |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: CNN/BLR
Posts: 4,243
Thanked: 10,081 Times
| Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s Most IT employees focus on HOW to do their tasks, and very few are interested in WHY they do it. HOW to do can be learned by anyone and execute the task. Knowing WHY part is what separate expert/leaders in their field from the rest. Last edited by Latheesh : 17th May 2018 at 10:30. |
() Thanks |
17th May 2018, 10:31 | #24 | |
BHPian Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: chennai
Posts: 99
Thanked: 49 Times
| Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s Quote:
Probably we are just discussing semantics here, but I would like at it differently. Your Stats/ Linear Algebra/ Probability concepts are not going to change. The tools would be your Python, R etc. And these can keep changing. And therefore there will be strong value on the conceptual understanding following by tool specific competency. | |
() Thanks |
17th May 2018, 11:14 | #25 | ||
Team-BHP Support | Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s Quote:
One can probably remain purely technical in large companies. In smaller companies like mine, one has to know the business side of the domain once you exceed 10 years of experience. I don't mean sales. But they'll have to understand the cost of product development life cycle, and the value it offers to the customers when compared to rival products. Quote:
If a person with domain knowledge learns statistics in a class room, he/she can immediately see numerous opportunities to apply it. But a statistician can't learn domain knowledge in a class room, so it is a lost cause. I know this from first hand experience. Couple years ago, I had to learn markov chains in 2-3 months to create a very complex algorithm for a telephony application. But an expert in markov chains couldn't have done that because domain knowledge can't be picked up so fast. | ||
() Thanks |
17th May 2018, 11:24 | #26 | |||||
Team-BHP Support | Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s I am on the very wrong side of 50 and recently left my company since 1: All new roles were junior technical roles 3: Ran out of room to grow. It was a choice of lots of pressure in what was now a hum-drum job or explore what is outside Quote:
Loans and EMI - I could see my situation coming. I bought my property outright a long time ago. I had taken loans for investment properties which I cleared months before my impending circumstances came to fruition Quote:
Quote:
My ex-company does a lot of substantial product development but now outsource a lot of it out! There is a joke that one or two of the suppliers have skills to design a rival product if they see the big picture. "Manager" - I was a manager - I managed processes, a service, a domain. However, the outside world considers managers as people managers. I was not interested in this because of dealing with the "entitlement" factor. As for development, it was more in terms of technical skills for the technical team As for my job after I left. Part of it was geo politics. Part of my job went to another Geo to some juniors. Another part of my job is left wide open - they are looking for someone with the domain knowledge but cannot find someone on the cheap. Quote:
Quote:
Summarising, I possess a high level of Operations and Security Risk management skills. I have the required certification but my age and lack of technical skills is posing a disadvantage. When I speak to HR, they assume Age = Over the Top Salary. They do not understand the concept of market forces fixing the salary based on work done. Last edited by Aditya : 21st May 2018 at 07:57. Reason: Minor typo | |||||
() Thanks |
|
17th May 2018, 12:00 | #27 | |
Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: May 2010 Location: Bangalore
Posts: 1,898
Thanked: 12,014 Times
| Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s Quote:
For example, I would gladly take a pay cut to move to a job which is more challenging or to a job at an office location that is near a metro station. I have even stated the same right up front during the first contact with HR. But they have a set formula in mind that involves experience, age and salary and cannot seem to deviate from it. Last edited by SDP : 20th May 2018 at 23:24. Reason: Minor typo | |
() Thanks |
17th May 2018, 12:24 | #28 |
BHPian | Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s Being in IT for 11 years, this topic piqued by attention. Many of these cases may be due to: 1. Company tightening the budget/optimizing due to a crunch situation. 2. Some are plain unlucky 3. Some are in already top heavy pyramids that , suddenly due to down sizing etc, you find two 40 years old managing a 20 member team in which 1 of them becomes redundant. But this is actually due to the younger employees also suffering a down sizing 4. 40 years are paid heavily so during a pruning they may be targeted 5. Many (not all) 40 years may be just a generic Senior Management type and may not have a USP 6. Macro factors such as policies in US etc. 7. Also may be not expect big pay hike at this juncture and find a job that you love and where there is scope. But there is hope. In this industry, things are always changing, and you need to keep pace. One can't just stop technical/domain learning after 8 years and expect to just be a people's manager for the rest 22 years. Create a niche for yourself. Even though pyramids these days are top heavy, but, talented, technical, innovative people are still rare and valued. Expertise yourself in a field. Don't be a jack of all trades and master of none. Know about everything, but don't forget your core technical skill be it Software Architecture, Networking, Hardware, Programming, DB, consulting, testing, build, some other technology, some other tools or processes. Become better at it, become the best at it. A boss who knows more than oneself is highly regarded and respected. At this level, core techie people are less than 1%. Don't follow the flow and get promoted to generic positions, have a career aim and be at it. Be a specialist, be a guru, become an expert, but also keep an eye on the relevance of your niche. Sometimes you may do all this and still find yourself at the wrong end of the barrel, but carve your space, be excellent at some core thing. Your chances will only increase. Last edited by GTO : 18th May 2018 at 09:40. Reason: typos |
() Thanks |
17th May 2018, 13:46 | #29 |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Feb 2013 Location: India
Posts: 1,756
Thanked: 6,318 Times
| Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s The title might need a bit tweaking. Rather than blanket IT professionals , its professionals from IT service sector who might be facing the heat more. 5 years back when I had my last switch , the calls were thick and fast and I could negotiate terms easily. Within a month of floating resume on naukri/monster I landed with 3-4 offers. But now things surely have changed as soon as I crossed the magic 10 year mark. Suddenly calls have dried up. In last 8 months of job-hunting I could manage only 2 offers that too from service firms again, which ultimately I let go as it would have been a similar job with slight better pay and eventually more risk. In current organisation atleast I am in touch with the competency and get enough opportunities. Before dropping the axe, am sure atleast 1% weightage will be given to the service I have provided for last 5 years. Downside though is, responsibilities increased but hikes have almost dried up in last 2-3 years. Seeing the current trend and talking to few of the HR folks what I understand is , IT Services Industry now prefers folks from 3-7 year bracket primarily because they are on a shoe-string budget nowadays and affording senior folks is tough unless they have some super-niche skillset. Similar job is shouldered by a 8 year exp guy more often than not that a 12 year exp guy would do at 2/3rd the salary. Plus you don't need to spend/invest in training them as that would have been done by the previous firm already. Folks who joined in 90s sure have been in the best era as when they were 10-12 years exp(2002-2005) real estate and all were still reasonably priced and salaries comparatively were higher. But now, salaries haven't really increased exponentially but real-estate prices sure have gone out of the park. Investing in them is damn scary looking at the prices and shaky future of the industry. Keep upgrading yourself technically and save for the rainy day. You never know just ike bangalore rains it might catch you by surprise. Last edited by SoumenD : 17th May 2018 at 13:48. |
() Thanks |
17th May 2018, 13:55 | #30 |
Senior - BHPian Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: Pune
Posts: 1,058
Thanked: 3,717 Times
| Re: The plight of IT professionals in their 40s This is an interesting thread and I want to write a lot on this, but right now I am at a client location in Middle East and wont find time until I go back to my hotel. I am a guy in my early 30's and have seen how IT people in 40s are always in danger. But the good part of the story is that the ones who are really good at adapting to changing dynamics of the industry can easily get through. I've seen both examples of people in their 40s. Some finding it hard to get a job and some sailing through very easily even when they were asked to leave (not on the basis of their individual performance though, just the tech they worked on got obsolete !) I will write a detailed observation soon as I get time ! Something about me : I started my IT job in a mid-tier company, and so far I have been changing jobs after every 2 years at an average for some reason or the other. I've worked for one of the big fours of consulting, worked in one of the 'truck' companies, and worked for another big service based company. And know quite a few things on how each of these work. |
() Thanks |