Quote:
Originally Posted by ABHI_1512 ..Sorry for being little melodramatic here but what has happened to the migrant workers because of the lockdown is inhuman and dastardly. We may build as many satellites and highways and latest guns and what not in the future but we will never be absolved of these cruel atrocities on our own countrymen !! |
Not melodramatic at all. In my lifetime in India, I have not seen human tragedy of this scale that has not been caused by a natural disaster.
Before people come and correct me that the virus is a natural disaster; let me say that the migrants deaths are not caused by the virus. They are caused by the lockdown which is our disproportionate response. It need not have been like this at all.
Someone told me that India's normal
death rate was 0.8%; and that the virus would have increased that by 20%. So, if I understand that right, for every 100 people, 0.8 people are dying during normal course of time. A 20% increase in death rate would mean that this virus would have resulted in 0.96 people dying for every 100 people. And for that we are penalising all 100 people to supposedly save them from this virus. I have not heard of a more foolish math. Also, this math does not account for the deaths that occur DUE to the lockdown; such as chronic patients and general people not getting access to healthcare; or migrants dying due to fatigue or due to being forced to trudge home. And this math definitely does not account for the deaths that will occur over the longer term due to the societal response to the fear that has been sown in people's minds. What a travesty!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by kiku007 The level of control the CPC exercises over its citizens is quite shocking. |
Indeed!! In my years abroad, I have prided myself on us being the world's biggest democracy. Yes, we have our problems. But, would I want us to be like China? No, thank you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by kiku007 ..90K+ cases and 53K+ active cases and India doesn't have community spread. If people believe that but question China's transparency (or the lack of) then it's the heights of irony. |
I suppose that the government was, and is, trying to prevent panic. But, anyone with half a brain would have figured out that community spread happened long before we even detected the first case. This virus is enormously resourceful. It needs very little to survive and propagate.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Asish_VK We had the lockdowns of the sake of it. The government is not strict enough and the public is not aware of the depth of problem....
People are roaming freely where I live in Bangalore, without any mask or concept of social distancing. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by poloman Do you call it a lockdown when more than a crore people are travelling across the country? Lockdown 3 was total farce. So as Lockdown 4. |
Sirs... you are right about one thing. A lockdown by definition means that no one, and I mean NO ONE, should venture out. But sirs, please understand that a lockdown by that definition is simply not possible in India.
Even if everyone obeyed (by way of some miracle) we would still have the virus spreading due to essential services. We need food, water, medicine and quite a few other things to live. The process of delivering those products and services to us will result in the virus spreading. No way around that reality.
On top of that, we have an economic landscape where people just don't have money to eat if they have not had a chance to earn that day.
What do you expect in such scenarios? That the infections would drop? This virus is not H1N1, or Nipah, or any of those pathogens that are more self-limiting in transmission. This virus has enormous stamina and versatility. It can wait entire generations out. To expect that a lockdown of a few weeks will stem the tide is being quite unrealistic.
I actually do not blame the government at all for the virus's spread. I don't think that anyone can do anything against this virus.
Quote:
Originally Posted by poloman Now slowly the blame on Govt will shift from economic misery to death toll as expected. |
Well, whether people will blame the government for virus deaths remains to be seen. I personally will not. That said, the governments' (both central and state) handling of the crisis has been far from ideal. Even states like Kerala are being delusional if they think that they have defeated the virus.
The only way forward is to accept risk, and to expressly ramp up capacity, innovation and boldness in healthcare. The recent home quarantine rules for asymptomatic or mildly symptomatic patients is a good first step. We should not be choking our hospitals with people who don't really need any help.
Also, we need to ramp down the fear. The fear is driving people to do
absolutely horrible things. Covid is NOT a death sentence. It is in fact very very very far from a death sentence for more than 90% of the infected. Punishment for ill-treatment of anyone due to Covid must be to require the perpetrator/s to spend a month with other Covid patients in a quarantine center.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ramzsys An exercise to those who are mercilessly thrashing every government move regarding covid:
There is a very severe cyclone spinning in Bay of Bengal....
What would you do? |
You are making the point for us. Besides this virus, we have a 1000 other problems as a society and as a country. A lockdown achieves nothing other than to tie our hands to respond to every other crisis out there.
A lockdown uses up all capacity of policemen, doctors and administrators. Also, it allows no way to earn money to compensate the first-responders, or even to pay for other essentials like food, water, and medicine. So, with no capacity in personnel and in finances, how can we respond to cyclones, or to terrorists, or to economic offensives, or yes, even to other pathogens lurking out there?
Incidentally, we have a large population of diabetics who have been denied their daily exercise. Diabetes is a gateway illness. It opens the door to N other maladies. With this self-perpetuating lockdown, we are shooting ourselves in the foot (no pun intended) in a thousand ways. A lady I saw on the news in the US said "we are committing suicide so that we don't have to get sick. This is madness". I could not agree more.
Quote:
Originally Posted by mvadg ..I'm not good at reading the general public's mind it seems Now I'm trying to understand the reason why almost 50% of our members still favor the lockdown. I've read their points of view, but I was expecting a change as the situation progressed. Oh, well! |
Quote:
Originally Posted by mvadg ..Just look at the poll results right here on TBHP. Emotions are more powerful than rational thoughts, and fear is the key here - can't blame anyone. ... |
You are reading this a bit incorrectly. In the original poll, over 60% had said yes to the lockdown. Now, that number is down to between 44% and 45%.
Also, in the original poll, only 10% voted a categorical no for the lockdown. That number is now up to 41%.