Does speeding really kill? First the disclaimer: I am in no way promoting speeding in any form. In fact I strongly recommend following all the posted speed limits everywhere and driving according to the road and traffic conditions.
Now back to the topic of this thread. I came across a few articles and also did some research on my own when I was in University and thought I should share all this with everyone here.
I am of the opinion that speeding alone does not always kill. In fact there have been rarely any scenarios where speeding was the only contributing factor to an accident. Accident rates are not necessarily higher just because of speeding. As an example, the unrestricted sections of the German Autobahns which have no posted speed limits, have some of the lowest accident rates in Europe (one of my 4th year University papers, also numerous links on Google). The number 1 cause for accidents in most countries is driver fatigue. Speeding alone is responsible for less than 3% of the accidents, and the websites I've mentioned have plenty of information on that.
Most of the accidents involving speeding drivers were because of driving too fast for the conditions (e.g. slippery roads, less visibility etc.) while they were still below the posted speed limit. And speeding under the influence of alcohol or drugs is the second most common statistic for accidents caused by speeding.
Also in the US, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), mostly funded by the insurance companies works closely with traffic cops for establishing and enforcing blanket speed limits. It's the same story here in Canada, where they have even been known to sponsor speed and photo radars for the traffic cops in order to maximize speeding tickets for offending drivers, and hence revenue.
So why this mutual back scratching? That's because in most countries in Europe and North America, your insurance premiums will go up by 25-50% with 2 or more speeding tickets, and it also means increased revenue for the traffic police. In fact, in many of these countries, the insurance companies have simply refused to lower their premiums despite having lower accident rates in the past decade. We have also seen Jeremy Clarkson promoting the demise of the dreadful speed cameras, something which we have been lucky so far not to have in large numbers in Canada.
So I found these 2 websites, which provide scientific and statistical evidence about what I've been blabbering so far, and are a great read for everyone. SENSE - Is speed killing us? Car Bibles: Fact vs. Fiction about speeding
Feel free to add in any of your comments below on this topic. I can already smell an interesting discussion brewing up.
Last edited by sujaylahiri : 29th October 2009 at 09:40.
|