I've been tracking this thread for sometime, and over a period used services of few self-drive operators.
Zoom, Bangalore
Booked a Scorpio for 2 days in Aug 2014. This was for local use in Bangalore, also to check out their service and vehicles.
Booking process: Online, and was smooth.
Pickup process: Smooth, but with a little delay. They were cleaning the vehicle when I reached, and was ready in 15 min after my scheduled pick-up time. Documentation is simple.
Vehicle condition: It was a base variant which had clocked around 80K and was about 1 or 1.5 years old then. Condition was not great, but okay.
Drop process: Simple.
Rate: Around 4300, fuel included. Since I did not cross the kilometer capping, did not pay anything extra.
Autoriders, Delhi
Booked a Scorpio for 15 days in Sep 2014 for Leh-Ladakh trip after lot of research and analysis.
Booking process: Mail communication, and online transfer of full estimated fare. Security deposit of 30K was paid in cash while taking the delivery.
Pick process: Smooth, without any delay.
Vehicle condition: It was a 2013 model Scorpio 4WD, serviced on the day of our pick-up and was in good condition. It had clocked around 80K, but was in very good condition - washed & vaccumed. It also did not give us any problems throughout the journey of 15 days considering the terrain we went through.
Drop process: Smooth, without any delay.
Rate: Cost us 3k per day, plus 10k as surcharge for Ladakh wear&tear, 4.95% service tax, which came to little less than 60K.
Carzonrent, Chennai
Booked an Innova for 3 days in Dec 2014 from Chennai to Pondichery.
Booking process: Online, and was smooth.
Pickup process: Very good. They had confirmed that they don't provide pick-up from railway station. But they suggested us to take the local train and get down at a staion near their office/pick-up point, and they will pick us from there. They guided us promptly and were waiting once we got to the local staion.
Vehicle condition: Very good. I guess it was 2014 or late 2013, with around 50k on odo. Was clean inside out, thoroughly washed and vaccumed. No issues throughout the journey.
Drop process: Smooth, no delay.
Rate: Cost us around 8500 I guess (can't recollect the exact figure), including taxes
Carzonrent, Bangalore
Booked an Ecosport for 3 days in March 2015.
Booking process: Online, smooth.
Pickup process: Smooth, with some delay. They had to get the key of the vehicle from the security office which caused some delay.
Vehicle condition: Very good. A 2014 Oct Ecosport, with 9800 km on odo. Not the top most variant, but the one just below that - without push start/stop button and few extra airbags I guess. Otherwise fully loaded with music player, alloys etc.
Drop process: No delays, smooth.
Rate: Around 6800, including taxes.
My take on Zoom
Pros: Online booking, good service, more options on vehicles and pick up points, good rates for weekdays, fuel included, hourly billing, cashless process, less deposit (if it matters), good policies like earn credits if vehicle is returned early.
Cons: Distance capping, rate surge for weekends and holidays/long weekends, only in Delhi/NCR, Pune and Bangalore
Zoom is good if you plan to drive within the distance capping for the rental period. Also hourly billing gives a little flexibility on when to pick-up and drop. Also I dislike their fare hike during weekends and for holidays/long weekends.
My take on Autoriders
Pros: Good service, offers vehicles to Leh (not a big point here, though), no distance capping, reasonable rates.
Cons: No online system, no wide range of vehicles to choose from - compared to Zoom or Carzonrent, not a cashless process.
Autoriders is good if you cannot get a vehicle from Zoom or Carzonrent. Limited cities covered.
My take on Carzonrent
Pros: Online booking, good service, more options on vehicles and pick up points (more vehicle options than Zoom in Bangalore, it will vary from city to city), good rates overall, no rate surge for weekends/holidays, cashless process
Cons: Higher secutiry amount blocked on credit card, Fuel not included in the rates.
Carzonrent is good if you will be driving a lot during your rental period. Hourly booking is only until 23 hours, and if it is more it has to be booked under daily tag (multiples of 24 hours), which means even if you return the vehicle early there is no credit/refund unlike in Zoom.
I choose Zoom or Carzonrent based on the distance that I will be covering and the rates. But invariably, we travel during weekends/holidays and Zoom has a price surge during those periods. Also Zoom is present only in 3 cities right now. So if it is Mumbai or Chennai, Carzonrent it is for me.
Also there was an offer running due to which there was no security depost charged for my Chennai rental of Innova. For the Ecosport, they've released the blocked 50k and I've got a confirmation. They release the amount when we return the vehicle, and you get the confirmation in sms, with a pdf statement link.
I guess most of the operators try to have new vehicles which are 2-3 years old max, and mostly mid to top variant, and with a Yellow-on-Black board. Zoom and Carzonrent have tablet based systems with their staff (what I've seen) which can scan and update our pickup and drop timings, and only paper work is the agreemnt that we sign.
The only case where issues will crop up is if there has been any damages/accidents. I've not faced any, so can't comment first hand. I've heard differnt versions, so can't comment on that. Let there not be a chance where I've to comment on that first hand
Anyways, as long as these companies compete to provide more cars, more pickup points, better rates, we, as customers, can sit back and enjoy the benefits.
Hope this helps people who are planning to go for self drive options.
- from a person who has sold off his car to rely entirely on Zoom, Carzonrent, Autoriders, Uber, Ola, Taxiforsure (now part of Ola), Meru, Tabcab, BlaBlaCar