I usually do not post much on Team-Bhp, but have been a member since ages and there has been not a single day that I haven't visited the website. I know that there are already threads related to traffic offences and motor vehicles act, but felt the need to put my experience in a new thread, as it might be helpful to others and also to help me to get some more expert opinions on the same. It's lengthy, but I thought it was worth putting an effort into it.
Two days back, I was on my way to Uttan for a weekend getaway with friends. I was already running late. As I drove out of my lane to S. V. Road Goregaon West, when my wife's (co-passenger) phone rang. I strictly do not answer phones while driving. I have a habit of rejecting calls with pre-typed messages. But as I had to co-ordinate for the address, my wife handed over the phone to me without putting it on speaker phone. I just held the phone trying to move to the left to halt the car. Before I could do that, two traffic police officers, riding on bike behind us, saw this and pulled me over.
On getting off the vehicle, the traffic police demanded my driving license (D/L), which i handed over. He opened his receipt book to issue me a Form "L" Tem. I asked him for the penalty amount. He said, that if I pay him Rs. 600 against the "L" Tem, I can drive away with my D/L and he will take care of everything on my behalf. I found this a little fishy. I demanded him to show me the act, list of offences and the penalties. Meanwhile, the pillion rider, the other traffic police officer, offered that if i pay Rs. 300, there will be no Form "L" Tem issued. I went to my car, to speak to my wife, who is a practicing lawyer and to grab hold of my mobile phone for a quick search on rules. My wife was not well versed with the Motor Vehicles Act. When I returned to the traffic police officers, they asked me what was my final call? I again demanded for the list of offenses and penalties. To this, they were offended and abused me. They asked me to check the internet, as they saw me doing that near my car.
I told them, as they were not kind enough to show me the act and rules & regulations I had to check on the phone. To this, they started behaving nastily and the one of them suggested the other office to book me under Sec 250 (a) and 184 of MVA. To this, I demanded the list of offense to be shown to me before booking me under any section. The officer issuing me the Form "L" Tem, suggested to the other office that I should be video recorded for misbehaving with the traffic police, to which I politely said with a firm voice that I demand to see the section details under which I am being booked. Finally, they agreed to show me a laminated, cyclostyled paper which had no mention of any Govt. Dept. which issued it. Sec 184 mentioned driving dangerously with a fine of Rs. 1,000 and Sec 250 (A) mentioned use of mobile with a mention of M M (Mumbai Magistrate Court). Dangerous driving at the speed of 10-20 kmph on a jam packed junction! I protested that I cannot be booked under Sec 184, so finally they issued me a Form "L" Tem and asked me to appear in court. They just wanted to charge me with multiple offenses so that I could be fined heavily in the court, as I didn't agree to go as per their whims and fancies. They asked me to appear in court on 04/05/2015. If not for my agitation, they would have booked me for an offense which I did not commit.
Post this entire incident, I carefully read the Form “L” Tem. I Googled for all the mentioned acts and their respective sections on returning from the trip. None of the websites related to Motor Vehicle Act., Road and Transport Ministry, Mumbai Traffic Police had updated Motor Vehicle Act 1989 (MVA) or Maharashtra Motor Vehicle Rules 1989 (MMRV) under which the Form “L” Tem is issued and Sec 250 (A) is enacted. After referring to many sources and obsolete Govt. Dept. websites, I could crack the code to an extent. The Mumbai Traffic Police website’s FAQ mentions a fine of Rs. 100/- which can be paid at the local traffic police station (
http://trafficpolicemumbai.maharashtra.gov.in/FAQs.htm). The Motor Vehicle Dept., Maharashtra has a different story to tell – a penalty of Rs. 200/- (
http://mahatranscom.in/offen_penalties_schedule.aspx). As per my research, which I do not claim to be foolproof, as I am not a lawyer, Form “L” tem issued has a mention that I can get my offense compounded (settled) at the local traffic police station within 10 days of the offence commitment date and collect my D/L. As per the MVA 1988 Sec 177, talking on mobile phone is to be penalized Rs. 100/- which falls under MMVR 1989 sec. 250 (a). It also has a mention in the procedure issued by www. Mahatranscom.com (
http://mahatranscom.in/pdf/OFFENCES_..._PROCEDURE.pdf) .
In order to reconfirm the same, I tried calling up few numbers mentioned of the traffic police website. And, I bet you will be ashamed of apathy of the system, for which we are completely responsible. I called up the Control Room Officer to ask about the same. The female at the other end confirmed that I can settle my offence by paying penalty at the local chowki. On trying to confirm the penalties, the female fumbled realizing that this might create an issue for the local traffic police chowki. So, she replied that she doesn't have any details on penalties, which I need to confirm only with the SHO, of the local traffic police. So to reconfirm, I called up Assistant Commissioner of Police, West. The Police Sub Inspector (PSI) on the other end confirmed that I can pay my penalties at the local traffic police chowki and get my D/L. When, I confirmed the penalties, he said it could be Rs. 1200-2000. To which i said, "Sir, as per Sec 250 (A) MMRV which comes under Sec 177 MVA the fine mentioned is only Rs. 100." He debated that the Act is amended, to which I replied that it is still at Rajya Sabha level. To this, he confirmed that the fine is Rs. 100. Post this, I was so appalled at the incident that I tried contacting Deputy Commissioner of Police, Western Suburbs. But his office clearly directed me to the Prosecution Dept. without paying heed to my words. Finally, I came across a very gentle PSI at the Prosecution Dept. who patiently heard me out and guided me to request the SHO to accept the penalty payment and release the D/L.
I am not trying to defend my mistake. We all tend to commit them and learn from them. But my point is, why are we being misguided? Had it not been for my presence of mind, I would have charged for a offence which I never committed. This could have led to suspension of my D/L. Who is responsible for this system and why is there not a transparent platform where we can clarify our issues, get correct and apt information and not get vague replies and get our grievances addressed?
Please advise me and correct any of the facts I mentioned above. Expert opinion and guidance is always welcomed.