Re: To the Chennai Airport: Bike vs Car vs Metro I would say, the calculation should be done from home to lounge and not from the Metro station to lounge as the travel from home to Metro station is also a matter of concern (really a "big" concern as the last mile connectivity is always a question).
I assume if this race was done from home to lounge - everyone on their mark, ready to go, the guys book the CAB (one may drop the metro guy by his CAB to the nearest station), once the booking is done, the scooter wala starts from home, CAB and Metro guys wait till their CAB arrives, Metro wala is dropped at the station and then proceed to airport. In this scenario (from home), the scooter wala is definitely going to win. Again purely depending on the circumstances en-route to the airport (like traffic, if it is very light, CAB wala may eventually catch up with scooter and overtakes it).
If I am an "actual" traveler and if my luggage is light to medium, then I will use a combination of CAB+metro. If my luggage is really light (like a laptop + an overnight-er) then I may also ask someone at my home to drop me in bike or scooter (if they can and this purely depends on the situations). If I am traveling with family with normal to heavy luggage, then CAB would be better to avoid the hassles of transiting on the way.
I did this yesterday in Bangalore (not from airport) and here is how it went.
My train from Hubli reached Yeshwantpur at 6:45am.
I walked to the Yeshwantpur metro station which took a good 10 mins as I was having a slightly heavy trolley suitcase with me and outside the station, I didn't want to pull it, but lift it and go. Took the tickets and reached the station (2 levels up) in another 5 mins. In the mean time, I saw one train leaving the station. I waited for another 5 mins or so and got into the train which left at approx 7:05 am. And I reached Mantri Square station in ~15 mins. This costed me Rs.19/-.
From Mantri square station (which is the current last station on this leg), I came out, got into the bus (took ~5 mins) which took me to the Majestic Metro station in approx 15 mins. Being a holiday morning and that too Diwali, the rush was less, else, I am sure this could have taken upto 40 mins. This costed me Rs.12/-.
It took me 15mins to reach the platform from bus drop point after buying a new ticket (they wont issue a single ticket) and just missed the train and had to wait for the next one which took 15 mins. Majestic to Indiranagar, I covered in another 20 mins and this costed me Rs.22/-.
From Indiranagar Metro station, I walked up the road to the bus stop and got the bus to Vignan Nagar. Walking time + waiting time was approx 30 mins.
From Bus stop to Vignan Nagar, it took another 20 mins. Again, the traffic was really thing even at Tippasandra market area and I was purely lucky to cross this area so quickly. This costed me Rs.17/- (I feel in terms of VFM, this leg was the costliest).
From Vignan Nagar bus stand to my home, I had to walk (again lifting the luggage, as I didn't want to lug it on road) and this took a sweet 10 mins.
Overall cost was 19+12+22+17 = Rs.70/-
Overall time spent from Yeshwantpur to Vignan Nagar (door to door) is ~155mins.
Had I taken a CAB from Yashwantpur to Vignan Nagar (door to door), it would have costed me min Rs.250/- and also would have taken similar time since the traffic overall was thin, but for normal Bangalore traffic, I assume it would have taken atleast 25 mins more. However, there is no hassle of lugging the luggage everywhere.
Last edited by Jakku : 1st November 2016 at 21:40.
Reason: to add matter.
|