Harleys or superbikes category is meant for liesure riding (IMO, commuting on a Harleys or most other superbikes is not a great idea especially in a country like India as traffic conditions are not conducive for riding these big bikes due to heating, power and weight issues) but, if owners choose to use their big bikes for commuting then it is purely their call but, they will certainly not have a comfortable time on saddle
As another member rightly commented, Harleys and Bullets feel like raw materials and have nothing refined about their experiences. Having owned a RE Classic 500 for nearly 4 years, I had developed an affection towards the brand but, when I discovered big bikes then I started thinking with my head and realized hanging on to emotions that RE is a wonderful experience is a naive thing to do especially when you are exposed to big bikes which have powerful, extremely smooth motors which ride and handle in an almost surreal way. Well, yeah RE experience was nice but, only till the time you are not exposed to big bikes
I enjoyed my 4 years on Classic 500 and, one fine day decided to upgrade to a Triumph Bonneville and owned both of them side-by-side for nearly a year.
This is when reality struck me, It started to dawn on me that I am riding the bullet lot lesser and each and every-time would reach for keys of my Bonnie since the difference in riding experience was absolutely stark. This allowed me to take a quick decision to get rid of my bullet and enjoy the finer things in life. I personal belief is to move on in life and not hang on to emotions even if happier times lie ahead of us in future
Here is a comparison report of Iron 883 vs. Bonnie that I shared back in time. You can see how easy it was for me to chose a Bonnie over an Iron 883
http://www.team-bhp.com/forum/superb...ml#post3354264
Coming back to Harleys, I have ridden most of them (Street 750, Iron 883, 48, Fat Bob, Dyna Super Glide in India) and have Infact spent a full day riding in torrential rains in Japan when Harley invited Team-BHP to experience the improved 750, 883 and 48' .
If you compare Harleys with competition who are launching truly improved bikes, there was nothing really improved with new Harley's except a lot of marketing lingo about improvements which are mostly cosmetic
Here is my Japan Harley Ride report :
http://www.team-bhp.com/forum/superb...ml#post3816579
I'm yet to ride my favorite model from Harley line-up (Fat Boy) but, I'm assuming it may be nothing radically different as I have ridden the Triumph Thunderbird Storm which has a butter smooth engine and wonderful ride but, as with all cruisers handling does not truly exist.
And, according to my personal opinion such motorcycles do not belong in India (low GC..anyone?) and can only be enjoyed on arrow straight beautifully tarred roads of USA or other such countries (Well, come to think of it, what is there to enjoy riding a motorcycle in an arrow straight line? I personally dont enjoy straight 4-lane highways and start yawning 50kms into it)
No offense to Harley owners, I find everything about Harley's appalling (except the 750 which I actually enjoyed riding the most, sadly Harley fanboys think is not even a Harley), their engines are coarse, braking experience is sub-par, ride experience is like steel rods going through your back when you go over slightest of bad roads, less said about handling, it's literally scary to take corners. Only time you feel comfortable astride a Harley is when you are on straight tarred roads. This essentially takes away the fun of riding a motorcycle. Ask any motorcycle enthusiast, if you cannot enjoy corners then that motorcycle is NOT worth riding/buying
I lived in USA for a little while and multiple business visits since 2003, I totally agree with Jeroen comments that most Harley riders are 50+, big guys with tattoos and beards living their alter ego's over weekends
. Their idea of fun is large group rides and enjoying the ruckus they create with their loud engines..Haha
Another thing that legendary is Harley owners attitude which is not even favorable to their own clan because they look down upon Harley owners with smaller bikes. I have heard multiple stories of how smaller Harley owners are sneered at which does not add up to the overall experience of owning one
To sum up, Unless Harleys can completely overhaul their entire technology which is highly doubtful from the existing rustic, torquey, enjoy-in-a-straight line theme to compete with their competitors, I personally feel they will continue to lose their market-share as time goes by and I truly doubt if they can do anything about it as globally both young and old alike are choosing different styled category motorcycles (Classic, Naked, Adventure/Sport) theme as comfort, smoothness, handling is becoming a priority over style-statement which made Harley popular in the first place