Quote:
Originally Posted by drmohitg Hey just wanted to make sure you didn't miss out on the Ford Endeavour option.
I would most certainly suggest you to not go for a new scorpio. However good a car is, one does get bored after some time. |
I too feel that a repeat Scorpio might become boring, especially when I intend to use it for a at least the next decade. The Endy option Doc, is ruled out, I have driven one extensively and felt very uncomfortable due to its sitting position, that quirky autobox and its pathetic FE. The version I drove was a 2011 Sept 4x2 AT.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ashwin_seattle Stay away from Pajero - specially used ones. My cousin bought a used one last year and believe me, he is cursing the day he made that decision. Lots of maintenance, unrefined, and uh that 90s feeling. It was a good vehicle in the 90s/early 2000...not ANYMORE! |
You know that is the problem. The Pajero seems to be a "love it or loathe it" vehicle. I m neutral though. While actual users like your brother loathe it due to it unrefined nature, people like Mahesh and GTO recommend it. Aargh..why is this so difficult.
Quote:
Originally Posted by shankar.balan Any day a New or Used Fortuner in comparison to the XUV.
However, if one is slightly more discerning, one would step back a bit and take a longer view before making a decision.
Perhaps it might be a good idea to wait for that new Captiva OR Trailblazer OR at least view the Ssangyong products when they come, before plonking money down now.
Others like the Force One, Safari Storme etc are completely out of the running in my opinion because what they have offered to consumers is too little, too late. In any case they arent close to expectations when it comes to a discerning customers requirements.
Yes indeed, we still dont have that many proper SUV options but this is changing quite rapidly. |
Precisely Shankar, the XUV, at least in its current avatar and known issues of flywheels, front suspension, MID and others, does not appeal to me, today. Moreover, I d rather have a full blown SUV with proper low range transfer case than a crossover.
Also, the XUV's rear bench has been compromised on width which makes it uncomfortable on long journeys for tall people. I have actually measured it with the Scorpio and Safari rear benches and it is around 3 inches shorter in width.
Quote:
Originally Posted by HappyRoadie I will suggest you to go with Scorpio as Pajero is quite old and its engine is underpowered. Although I would suggest you to check out second hand Endeavour as well. |
The Scorpio is certainly in my books but look at what the others say about it. Gawd I m stuck, big time. The Endy is ruled out, I never liked the seating position one bit.
Quote:
Originally Posted by nilanjanray Yes, good suggestion: why not a second hand 4X4 Endeavour?
I test drove the 4X4 Endy once, it seemed tough. Perhaps a little more truck like than the Fortuner. |
Not a little more but "very much" truck like Nilanjan. Moreover it lacks basic features I d expect from a vehicle of its class; auto a/c, steering mounted audio controls, high floor, low seats, lack of driver seat height adjust. The Pajero is not expected have these features since it known to be old and outdated, but the Endy...doesn't cut it for me at all.
Quote:
Originally Posted by khoj If the size meets the requirement, I believe the OP should wait for the Renault Duster. |
You see Khoj, my issue is the availability of spare parts, especially small spares which has always been the Achilles heel at M&M. I do not know if I should trust a newcomer, Renault on this front. Waiting is no problem though.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GTO Therefore, I recommend a pre-worshipped Pajero over a new Mahindra Scorpio to you. In terms of quality, ride & handling, the Pajero blows the Scorpio out of the water.
Equally, I'd highly advise you to check out the Mahindra XUV500. In my books, it's amongst the best SUVs on sale in India. If you are worried about niggles, give Mahindra another 6 - 12 months (longer the better) to iron out the initial gremlins.
An XUV would be choice no.1 for me and the Scorpio no.3. |
Rush, what about the cost of regular spares and other consumables? If they are prohibitively expensive, I mind end up getting a white elephant. Coming to the XUV, like I said, I prefer to choose "when" I want to engage 4WD and "if" I want 4H or 4L, rather than a computer doing it for me.
Quote:
Originally Posted by drmohitg BTW if diesel is not a strict requirement then you can probably also take a look at a used outlander perhaps. They lose massively in the used car market and you might get a relatively new car at a throwaway price. |
No Doc, I love the Outlander but its running costs owing to its petrol heart are up there, in the stratosphere.
Like the Coffee Bite ad, "The Argument Continues"....for the benefit of all.