As an update , TD'd both the Pajero Sport and the Fortuner
Fortuner
+ve's
- You get a great feeling of power inside/Outside. Very Butch Looking (i did not like the front view much although the Sides/Behind is really great)
- Peppy Engine No Lag
- Very Spacious
- Excellent handling and very responsive
- Cost of Ownership is very Low (Servicing + SPare Parts)
- Good electronics..anything i want is there.
-ves
- Ride Quality.this is where the fortuner really fails . I did get a chance to discuss with a friend on his Fortuner who had to upgrade the suspensions to Tien Advanced as he drives a lot with family and that improves the ride quality really well. but at a 1.45 L cost , around 25 mm loss in clearance and a cost of 7K per 50K Kms for retuning the suspension.The ride is worse in bad roads and not great in Good roads like NICE either :( and felt most in the 2nd Row seat.
- View from Drivers seat- was a bit of a disappointment as the scoop is obvious and need to strain a bit to get a comfortable view. Again could be something to get used to and it appears between a Sedan and an SUV in that aspect
- Disappointed there is no switch option between 4x4 and 4x2. although the full time 4x4 is great and from what i learnt , this is a lot more stable and can easily go much faster than 4x2. ideal for Highway warriors as well
- Braking : I would not call it very bad and not a deal breaker for me.can easily live with
- Interiors: Not great especially for a 30L car- but again not a big issue
- A minor point, the gear stick vibrates only slightly lesser than my 7 year old scorpio- is that a Demo Car issue ?
Pajero Sport
+ves
- Great Handling !! I just becomes an extension in 1 min. When i released the clutch the car Leaped forward (used to a Scorpio)
- View from Drivers seat. very very good. Can see bonnet and its edges very well
- Very good ride quality- is rock solid in good and bad roads and on-the-fly 4x4 is a great feature
- Great Interiors
- Looks menacing from the front, sleek from the side and not so great behind. looks smaller than the Fortuner, although still looks powerful
- Excellent Gear transmission and handling
- Fantastic Brakes : Rock solid and gives great confidence
- seat configurations and very thoughtful arrangement of Tool Set. 12V socket in the 3rd row too !
-ves
- MItsu Future + no of service centers this is what i am the most worried. having been trying to fnd out more around it.
- Cost of Ownership (service + parts). from what i could understand not as bad as it is made out to be.
- there is a Turbo lag in low speed, but can be overcome especially as gear changing is amazingly comfortable. So it could be a matter of getting used to.Not as bad as i expected after reading reviews
- 3rd row is expectedly bad wrt underthigh but surprisingly comfortable for short distances
- Noise levels : engine noise is high (cant remember if higher than the fortuner) but overall adequate
In Summary
In sheer driving Pajero Sport >> Toyota Fortuner stock
In sheer economics Toyota Fortuner >> Pajero Sport (including resale value)
After I factor in the 1.5L for Tiens + any Braking upgrade the net cost of the Fortuner (4x4) is only slightly higher than the Pajero over 5 years (both give 3 year warranty). but moment you factor in resale value, the Fortuner is significantly higher. The 4x2 is definitely cheaper..but its ride quality is worse and at this price level, IMHO need to have 4x4 options even if it is only for 2% of usage
Although the Tiens mean a separate entity to go to for serving etc and suspension will not be managed by Toyota A.S.S..and a risk around how long they (TIENS) continue in India
I did get a chance to speak to someone connected to Toyota and as per them they do know about the issues around Suspension but they dont intend to do anything about it as today they as selling anything they manufacture. And other than a 4x4AT, no changes going to come up over the next few years.
I am exceptionally worried as a much younger friend is having back problems due to the fortuner seat (No Lumbar)+suspension .
Over last 2 weeks have spoken to several owners and ex owners of Mitsubishi vehicles and heard different versions around spare part costs and A.S.S . What I could conclude is that on an average upto 5-7 years there is almost no spare part issue of a significant nature, although there is a probability associated to it
The paid service charges vary from 8-1k per service per and SVR is not really as abad as i initially heard. There are SFX and outlander owners who are still happy with this and there are other who are not -like Any other dealership except Skoda
.
While equal % of people are happy with the Fortuner service quality ( !!) the cost of servicing is about 3K - 7 K ie half ! and that makes folks very happy. Again very robust parts and usually no failures.
So stuck here and taking my time over deciding.
The following were discarded
1. XUV- great value for Money but feel worried about the HU being the brain of the vehicle in some way, Also dont like the Looks much.Finally will I be equally happy owning it 3 years from now ?
2. X-Trail- no +2 Seating options and looks really dated. also they did not bother to come for a TD !. New Version supposed to come this year sometime
3. Ford Endeavour. Too dated + Leaf Spring suspension. Again new version expected
4. Captiva: Great alternate option. Too expensive and depreciates very fast. i believe the AT option is a great 2nd Hand option.
5. Santa Fe. new version expected this year and supposed to be very good. But Trident Hyundai not interested in selling it appears !