@anshuman - Thanks for opening the thread.
For the past few weeks, I have been thinking of upgrading my Honda City iVTec to a SUV after going through the bad roads in Bangalore City. The high level requirements for my need were are follows:
- A SUV that commands road respect. In the eye level of a bus driver/water tanker driver and a vehicle that scares a two wheeler and a vehicle that is used by politicians
-The SUV can take on bad roads when required, such as a detour through a muddy diversion where large pot-holes which are typically created by buses/trucks
-Avoid large stones and foot paths scraping your bumper or running board.
-An international model which is selling outside India
-7 Seater
-Good comfort features & shorter turning radius
-An automatic with cruise control (Preferably)
I had shortlisted the new Pajero Sport Anniversary Edition and Fortuner AT from the whole list of Rexton, SantaFe, Endeavour, Captiva, Safari, Scorpio, Innova, & XUV 500 which are within the 30 lacs class. The entire premium segment (BMW X1/Audi Q3) were taken off since none of them support 7 seaters. The reason for short listing Pajero Sport is supposed to be a very well built vehicle with a nice look (not too aggressive), refined and has a lot of new features .
Pajero Sport Anniversary edition Specs:
-2.477 litre 4 cylinder 16Valve intercooled Turbocharged DOHC common rail DI-Diesel
-Power of 177bhp @4000 rpm
-Torque- 400Nm @2000-2500 rpm
- 5 speed manual gear box and ‘Super Select 4WD’ with 4 modes “2H, 4H, 4HLc and 4LLc”
- 0-100kmph in 13.3 secs
-Approach angle-36 degress and Departure Angle -25 degrees; Ramp breakover angle -23degrees
-Fuel capacity: 70 liters (old pajero had 92-liter tank)
-Fuel average: 8.5kmpl(city) & 10.8kmpl(highway)
-Price: 24.23 lacs ex-showroom + 5.09 lacs (Road tax+Handling)+ 70K I(insurance)= 30.03 lacs (On-Road@ Bangalore)
-Ground Clearance: 215mm
-Wheelbase: 2800mm
-Length x Width x height: 4695mm x 1815 mm x 1840
-Kerb weight: 2065
What I liked:- Solid suspension and feels wells built
- Bright and airy interiors
- On the fly 4x4 shifting
- Three ways of 4x4 –basic 4H, 4HLc and 4LLc
- Full-fledged central media console with GPS maps and Bluetooth
- Superb 3rd seating – lots of space for even large adults above 6 feet
- 8 way electronic driver seat adjustment
- Third row seats drops properly to give flat boot space.
- Rear brakes with both disc and drum
- Higher city fuel average (~12kmpl) – Need to verify
- Shorter turning radius for 4x4 (5.6m)
What I did not like:- Single dealer in Karnataka – only 150 cars per year in Karnataka
- Hydraulic steering which is too tight for city driving. Pretty rough and need to slow to take U turns.
- The gear ratios are not very perfect for city driving.
- Hard clutch, difficult to run on half clutch in the stop-go traffic
- No thigh support for 2nd row passengers.
- Engine noiser than the Fortuner.
- Body roll higher than Fortuner.
- Does not have the road respect like a fortuner
New Toyota Fortuner 2WD 5 Speed AT
I know some of you might say that I am not doing a fair part by not comparing the Fortuner 4x4 manual. I did not even try the 4x4 since I was not happy with the poor turning radius (5.9m) and heavier diesel engine(3L) which needs powerful clutch operation since I need this one to be primarily used in Bangalore City.
Specs- 2.982 liters 4-cylinder inline with 16 valve Intercooler Turbocharger and DOHC Common Rail Diesel Engine
- Power: 171ps @3600 rpm
- Torque:360nm @1400-3200rpm
- Warranty – 3 years/1,00,000 km
- Fuel tank: 80 Liters
- 0-100 kmph - 12 secs
- Top speed; 185kmph
- Fuel average: 8.5kmpl(city) & 10.8kmpl(highway)
- Fuel Consumption: 8-9 km/l (City), 10-12 km/l (highway)
- Ground clearance: 220mm
- Kerb weight: 1880kg
- Length x Width x height:4705mmx1840mm x 1850mm
- Price: 24.16 lacs ex-showroom + 4.89 lacs (Road tax+Handling)+ 75.79K I(insurance)+6.8K (ToyotaCare)= 29.88 lacs (On-road@ Bangalore)
What I liked:
-Very smooth automatic gear box
-Soft steering and short turning radius 5.6m (for automatic). It also feels good to turn due to the electronic Power Steering
-Silent engine and comfortable cabin.
-Did not feel like driving a large car, felt mostly like an innova on the road
-Road presence and road respect
-Good service and support network.
What I did not like:
-No GPS maps on the central console
-Third row not good for adult men
-The third row folds up on the side which takes away cabin space and the boot floor is not uniform even when the second row folds.
Verdict: In summary, the driving of a Pajero Sport like a MM540 whereas the Fortuner felt more like the Innova. Hence, unless you are a serious off-roader do not think about Pajero Sport. Look for Fortuner if you are looking for an Urban SUV. However, I would wait for the next version of Fortuner (2014) to arrive before making the buying plan.