Re: Ford EcoSport versus Renault Duster Quote:
Originally Posted by engrohit I voted for Duster ( not only because I own one) but because at 6' 2" I care about space. I want a car which has butch SUV feel seated inside.
Today while returning with colleagues from office we passed by a test drive Ecosport on GB Road and both my friends said in tandem "Itni chotti hai" (it's so tiny), and that my fellow friends is the road presence that Ecosport offers. |
So one buys a 4 wheeler tagged as SUV mainly for road presence? The Tata Safari guys would be saying the same thing when they pass by the Duster. Kitni chotti hai.
Just a high stance doesn't make a vehicle SUV. The Duster currently sold is no SUV either. Quote:
Originally Posted by drmohitg Most people haven't even TD the Ecosport and if have then for extremely short distances. |
Unless a car is really not selling, which dealership offers really long TDs? People are lining up to td the EcoSport and obviously they'll only be able to do a regular/short td. Quote:
Originally Posted by turboverbo The EcoSport is a 'neither here nor there' vehicle. As a 'sports utility vehicle' the EcoSport falls short of the expectations because of lack of space. The duster has more space, for people and for their belongings. The EcoSport is a hatchback with more ground clearance, and nothing more. If you want a feature laden car, the Hyundai i20 is ummatched. Even the Asta(O) variant, with its sunroof and six zirbags, is much cheaper by Rs. 80k than the 1.5 l petrol Titanium EcoSport. Would you like to pay that much more for what is essentially a hatchback on stilts?
The Duster's size makes it more of an SUV than the EcoSport. Of course, it's a softroader only as of now. The AWD version will change that. My only grouse against the Duster is that the petrol versions are not packed with all the features, especially safety. |
Actually you may be wrong. It's not the EcoSport that the 'in between' vehicle but it is the duster, that is. The Safari's, Jeeps and Pajeros are the real SUVs. Everyone knows the EcoSport is just a taller hatchback. The Urban SUV is a tag given by Ford and that doesn't make the vehicle an SUV. So which is the neither here nor there vehicle now?
Also, space or vehicle size doesn't permit a vehicle to be called SUV. It's based on what the vehicle is capable on. Currently neither the duster nor the EcoSport are SUVs and that's the reality, no matter how much anyone wants to debate. Quote:
Originally Posted by nilanjanray Voted for the Duster. I am actually surprised to see the EcoSport trouncing the Duster. Are pricing and refinement the main reasons?
A SUV should have some SUV traits - and the Renault - relatively speaking - comes closer than the Ford.
Apart from the looks and positioning, how different is EcoSport - from the old Fusion which was a very practical vehicle? That flopped, while it seems the EcoSport is gonna be a big success, going by the interest. |
Just 1 point based on the SUV traits. By the claim and the statement above, duster is more of an SUV than EcoSport then? But in reality it isn't and that's a shame. At 200mm GC, the EcoSport has 550mm water wading capability (useful for cities where rains cause flood havoc). Pity the so called larger 'suv' duster is only capable of 350mm, having 205mm GC.. Some trait.
Point is both vehicles are not SUVs and just be claiming to be bigger, the current Duster doesn't become an SUV. Get that right. People are lining up to buy the EcoSport simply because it's more vfm and practical than any other mini-suv. Not everyday do 4 wheeler owners seat 5 adults in the rear bench and carry in excess of 450 litres of cargo. Still, the duster probably has a wider rear bench seat and a large 475 litre boot.
And with respect to size, the attached photos below should stop all irrelevant and silly comparisons on size.. The Duster is just larger than the EcoSport. Not 'waay' larger.
Funny after claiming the comparison is apples to oranges, the duster is still being claimed to be the better 'suv'; don't know what is more childish.
P.S: I own neither vehicle nor a fanboy of either.
Photo credits: Motorbeam.com
Last edited by k_ajay : 30th June 2013 at 16:46.
|