If anyone is looking to change the front struts of their 3rd generation Honda CRV, this experience of mine might help you do that at a remarkably low cost, compared to what the "suggested" part for your trim might be costing.
Backstory:
I was looking to change the front struts and came across some really baffling options and costs for starkly varied prices (check reply #44 onward at this thread:
https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/techn...counter-3.html (How I got Honda to sell me spare parts over-the-counter))
Thinking like a design engineer of a business, I know it makes no sense to completely redesign every individual parts for the same model over the various production years, unless there has been any major change to the core structure/design. It just simply does not make any business sense for production/inventory/distribution etc. As it turns out, the 3rd generation Honda CRV shares a lot of parts between the various trims for all the models ranging from production years 2007-2011.
So searching with this criteria in mind it becomes very apparent that my initial statement will hold some truth. So I went out to test my hunch and it came true. Since the body is same for almost all the trims (mostly only engine/transmission differs), most body parts, and the associated spares are same, though it will
NOT appear so when you search based on CHASSIS/VIN number, both on Oriparts or at the Honda spares inventory/database at any ASC. For whatever reason, the Honda engineers kept most common parts the same but renamed the individual part number with subsequent iterations of production/trims.
My trim/production year/chassis type:
Region: INDIA
Production year: 2008
Engine type: R20A1 - 2.0L SOHC I-VTEC (PETROL)
Chassis type: SWDV2UA1
If I search on Boodmo with this criteria for front shock absorber assembly (both left and right) these are the two "suggested" parts that both Oripart and ASC database will show:
51602SWAJ31(Front-Left)
₹25,067.00
Boodmo URL:
https://boodmo.com/catalog/part-shoc...061.1628995042 51601SWAJ31(Front-Right)
₹25,114.00
Boodmo URL:
https://boodmo.com/catalog/part-5160...061.1628995042
Doubts started to creep into my mind when I saw the prices for the same part (within this same generation) being priced considerably cheaper for a later year production for a different trim. My engineer mind just could not agree to this because, why would I want to redesign a shock absorber, unless the platform was not changed? So I went into the catalogue and checked the individual parts that make up the strut assembly (like Mounts, Springs, Strut, etc.) and compared them to the parts across the various trims in the production year range of the 3rd generation: 2007-2011, and voila! They were the same! If the mount is the same, then logic will say the strut fitting into it will be the same. So I went out to test that too. Luckily, the struts for the various trims/production years has photos, so I carefully examined them to check if there were any change in the design (placements of brake calliper mounts, length of the strut, etc.) Careful analysis of the photos made me conclude that each of them were identical.
As I had noticed, and mentioned in my earlier thread, a stark and steep difference in price from the struts of the various trims/production years I searched the entire catalogue for 3rd generation and found these two as the cheapest ones:
51602SWAJ41 (Front-Left)
₹7,749.00
Boodmo URL:
https://boodmo.com/catalog/part-shock_absorber-7429430 51601SWAJ41 (Front-Right)
₹7,751.00
Boodmo URL:
https://boodmo.com/catalog/part-51601swaj41-12395288/
Which were the parts of this trim/production year/chassis type:
Region: INDIA
Production year: 2010 - 2010
Engine type: K24Z1 - 2.4L DOHC I-VTEC (PETROL)
Chassis type: SWAW2UB7
I was dumbfounded by this remarkable difference in price. Surely, there was nothing that engineeringly different in the earlier version that commanded such a steep price? Furthermore, I know for a fact that Honda, typically only improves the quality of their iterations, not degrades. So why this steep price? Chances are these are the likely reasons:
- Early on during the sale of CRV's in India, they were CBU's (Completely Built Units) so the entire vehicle was imported from Japan, and likewise all the spares were too. So the price might have been high, initially?
- With more demand (CRV is Honda's most successful car in the US and in other parts of the world), production to economies of scale would have reduced part costs, which is highly likely?
- Honda might have manufactured the part in India itself from the later iterations of the same generation?
Whatever the actual reason, I was not that keen to pay ₹25,067.00 for something that was also being sold at ₹7,749.00 so I took the plunge and bought both struts of the later trim. Boodmo anyway has a return option (check their conditions for a successful return).
The parts arrived and after careful examination at the FNG of the removed strut from my CRV it turns out they are the same!!!!! Furthermore, these parts were
Manufactured in Japan! (Sorry I did not posts photos of the boxes with this information, I can do so if someone wants me to.)
So got them installed, and they have made an incredible change to the ride quality at less than a 3rd of the price of the "recommended" one for my trim.
For those who find it hard to believe, check all the parts numbers in the attached photos. Hope this helps someone else that has the same trim that I have.
Bear in mind, this will only apply to common parts shared between the trims and production years of the same generation, it will not apply to: Engine, Transmission, and other such obvious categories, which makes the trims different.
All the best in saving your money.