Team-BHP

Team-BHP (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/)
-   SUVs, MUVs & 4x4s (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/suvs-muvs-4x4s/)
-   -   Tata Hexa vs XUV500 vs Innova Crysta vs others (https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/suvs-muvs-4x4s/183773-tata-hexa-vs-xuv500-vs-innova-crysta-vs-others-9.html)

Shreyans_Jain 10th September 2017 19:25

Re: looking for a new Car
 
Hexa is a fantastic vehicle but is not the right car if it will be used primary in the city. It is a tailor made for highways and is a bit too big and cumbersome otherwise.

You should limit your search to the Creta and the Jeep Compass. Creta if you want to get from point A to B with minimal fuss and effort. Compass if you like your car to have character and personality and feel in the way it drives.

ta1017 10th September 2017 19:38

Re: looking for a new Car
 
Hi Shreyas

when I was looking for a car an year back , I had TD'ed Creta Diesel AT and I purchased XUV as simply it was a superior car as well as more VFM.

Am Still considering XUV but my only grouse is that its ride is bumpy !

compass - i havnt TD'ed it but IMHO its same size as an ecosport which is quite a competent vehicle ....and am not the one who goes after brands.
another question that comes to mind is that the money I spend of compass - I am not getting as much....

confused :(

Shreyans_Jain 10th September 2017 19:59

Re: looking for a new Car
 
Size to price ratio of the Hexa is unmatched. Problem is, the huge size and turning circle make parking and taking U-turns a pain. Otherwise, it is THE car to buy in the 10-20L range. I drive an XTA myself

Creta is not my favorite car either. But it's merit is it's compact size, top notch refinement and super light controls. It really is a breeze to drive in traffic. It should be your plan B. Non controversial choice which will get the job done. Nothing more, nothing less.

As for the Compass, I suggest you do wait to test drive the Automatic, which will be launched sometime around Diwali. Think of it as a Creta which will appeal to your heart as well. I TDed the manual, and liked it.

sridharj77 16th September 2017 12:23

Re: Tata Hexa vs XUV500 vs Innova Crysta vs others
 
Tata Hexa seems to be the clear winner, but I don't see many Hexas' on the road. Sales numbers also don't seem to be high. Is there the perception in Indian consumer's minds that Tata is a "Taxi" brand and hence the brand image is not good?

abhi7013 17th September 2017 11:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by sridharj77 (Post 4271050)
Tata Hexa seems to be the clear winner, but I don't see many Hexas' on the road. Sales numbers also don't seem to be high. Is there the perception in Indian consumer's minds that Tata is a "Taxi" brand and hence the brand image is not good?

The reason being: it is not yet offered to the taxi fleet and all the numbers only reflect regular customers.
Add to that, it's a new product in the market and GST has effected the sales numbers greatly for the months of June and July for all brands.
One year post launch should give us a clearer picture.
Besides, am seeing more and more Hexas on road here on bangalore with every passing week.

vinodvayyat 22nd September 2017 22:13

Re: Tata Hexa vs XUV500 vs Innova Crysta vs others
 
Lot has been discussed in this thread. Still, let me talk about my choice - Hexa XTA.

Have been owning a Punto 90HP and it still serves me really well. Punto 90HP being a powerful enough hatch with outstanding ride quality and quality on good roads and especially a mile muncher, my choice by default went to a Jeep Compass with a budget of around 20L.

But my wife was a little adamant about buying a 7-seater, which is butch enough, comfortable and easy enough to maneuver around - so Compass is out from the plan. Consulted with a close friend who has been owning Tata Safari over its last two generations and he suggested a test drive of Hexa. It took me just seconds to decide after doing the test drive - Outstanding ride quality, amazing interiors and features, full worth of the money and amazing road presence. It has a lot of exclusivity and I thought that this is the vehicle I should probably own next. The size never bothered me after having the test drive and I just fell in love with its "Race Car mode". :D I may not use a 4X4 to its fullest and XTA has rear wheel drive with an LSD - I would settle for the time being with such an SUV. Booked the vehicle and still waiting for the delivery. :)

2500cc 26th October 2017 12:22

Re: Tata Hexa vs XUV500 vs Innova Crysta vs others
 
Experts, please help me with my purchase:

My requirements:
1. 7 seater is must
2. Comfort ride (old parents)
3. Will be keeping for 10+yrs, hence reliability is must.
4. Budget not more than 17L +/- 50k.
5. No automatics for me.

Am totally confused between Hexa XM and XUV W6

For Hexa:
-Excellent Ride quality.
-Classsy all black interiors.
-RWD

Against Hexa:
-Ergonomic disasters (no place to keep the left foot, armrest is useless in long drives)
-Small audio system is not impressive.
-No place for small things like mobile phone, coins, etc

For XUV:
-Feature rich and lot of space in the middle row.
-Known devil
-Better Ergonomics

Against XUV:
-FWD
-Ride quality not class leading despite being monocoqe
-No luggage space with all seats up.

This purchase will be in less than 10 days

amit_mechengg 26th October 2017 12:32

Re: Tata Hexa vs XUV500 vs Innova Crysta vs others
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 2500cc (Post 4294080)
Experts, please help me with my purchase:

My requirements:
1. 7 seater is must
2. Comfort ride (old parents)
3. Will be keeping for 10+yrs, hence reliability is must.
4. Budget not more than 17L +/- 50k.
5. No automatics for me.

Am totally confused between Hexa XM and XUV W6

For Hexa:
-Excellent Ride quality.
-Classsy all black interiors.
-RWD

Against Hexa:
-Ergonomic disasters (no place to keep the left foot, armrest is useless in long drives)
-Small audio system is not impressive.
-No place for small things like mobile phone, coins, etc

For XUV:
-Feature rich and lot of space in the middle row.
-Known devil
-Better Ergonomics

Against XUV:
-FWD
-Ride quality not class leading despite being monocoqe
-No luggage space with all seats up.

This purchase will be in less than 10 days

Dont even think of Xuv if your criteria is ride comfort. " Small Audio" is totally functional and the best in the segment and above it. Try listening to Harman in hexa and ones in BMW and merc.

The points mentioned against hexa like coin holders and what not cab be bought aftermarket at peanuts price. But the basics in which Hexa really excels cant be fitted as an aftermarket.

Choice is yours :thumbs up

comfortablynumb 26th October 2017 12:38

Re: Tata Hexa vs XUV500 vs Innova Crysta vs others
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 2500cc (Post 4294080)
Experts, please help me with my purchase:

My vote goes to the Hexa. The XUV is getting a bit long in the tooth, plus it's too ubiquitous, methinks.

The Hexa's fundamentals are quite sorted, plus at least I haven't read of any deal breaking issues in the Hexa thread yet.

Cheers,
Vikram

abhi7013 26th October 2017 12:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by 2500cc (Post 4294080)
Experts, please help me with my purchase:

My requirements:
1. 7 seater is must
2. Comfort ride (old parents)
3. Will be keeping for 10+yrs, hence reliability is must.
4. Budget not more than 17L +/- 50k.
5. No automatics for me.

Am totally confused between Hexa XM and XUV W6

For Hexa:
-Excellent Ride quality.
-Classsy all black interiors.
-RWD

Against Hexa:
-Ergonomic disasters (no place to keep the left foot, armrest is useless in long drives)
-Small audio system is not impressive.
-No place for small things like mobile phone, coins, etc

Will address your "against Hexa" points:-
1: yes, dead pedal is a sore miss and i had this in the back of my mind. However, now that i own it, i have gotten used to it. I simply place my left foot under the clutch.

Regarding the armrest, it does come to great use on the highways and city. Your posture in this car needs getting used to cause you stretch yourself comfortably thanks to the arm rest on the left and the one on the door. With a thus laid back position, driving experience is a bliss on highways!

2: Comparatively, XUV has a good infotainment system with great features added into it. Its a feature loaded car. But the stock nippon speakers are far behind the audio quality when compared to Hexa's JBLs.
But it seriously annoys to think what made TATA stop from giving this car a good big system with Android/iOS compatibility. The touch doesn't feel great and the system lags a bit.

However, if rumours are true, Hexa would get the same UI as that on Nexon in one of the updates.

3: I place my cell near the gear knob where it sits snugly without coming in the way. As for other smaller things, the driver only has the armrest compartment to look into. While passengers have lots of places to put away stuff, the driver has no other options. Bit irritating at times.

Also, since you are looking out for manual, would like to highlight that the gear shifts are a bit rough. However, after clocking sufficient kilometres, they tend to become smooth. Its much better in mine now than when it was new.

Good luck in your purchase and keep us updated on your choice!

amit_mechengg 26th October 2017 12:45

Re: Tata Hexa vs XUV500 vs Innova Crysta vs others
 
By the way checkout for the new limited edition Hexa, it has 15 new features with heads up display, rear 10 inches screens etc. Its an amazing new package.

2500cc 26th October 2017 13:47

Re: Tata Hexa vs XUV500 vs Innova Crysta vs others
 
Leaning towards Hexa. This morning I had placed call to XUV and Hexa, I got 4 calls from XUV already with the best offers and am yet to hear from Hexa, in fact I called them 3 times and everytime am told I'll get a call back in 5mins from Hexa salesperson.

Edit: Now they are even cutting my call.

Latheesh 26th October 2017 14:00

Re: Tata Hexa vs XUV500 vs Innova Crysta vs others
 
@2500cc - Get in touch with other dealers, this dealer don't deserve your money. If you are OK with XUV go ahead and get it.

tifosikrishna 26th October 2017 14:01

Re: Tata Hexa vs XUV500 vs Innova Crysta vs others
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 2500cc (Post 4294154)
Leaning towards Hexa. This morning I had placed call to XUV and Hexa, I got 4 calls from XUV already with the best offers and am yet to hear from Hexa, in fact I called them 3 times and everytime am told I'll get a call back in 5mins from Hexa salesperson.

Edit: Now they are even cutting my call.

It will be apt for TATA to use Other SUVs are cars, Hexa is an emotion. I had very similar experience here in Chennai. My car is now two months old and still official floor mat (promised as free during delivery) & side step (50% discount) not installed.

I have called the sales guy umpteen times and every time he will say he will come back with an update, but he hasn't come back till now. Once I went to get the complimentary 3M polish done but unfortunately the ONLY guy in charge of accessories was on leave & took the keys with him :Shockked:, so they could not get the floor mats.

Planning to call him again today. Shall update.

In spite of all this, product makes me forget about it. My suggestion would be not to get swayed by the lackadaisical attitude, interaction with sales team is going to be very short one compared to the time you are going to own the product.

Edit: Now am thinking what TATA marketing team really meant by tag line "Whatever it takes"

jetti 26th October 2017 14:07

Re: Tata Hexa vs XUV500 vs Innova Crysta vs others
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 2500cc (Post 4294154)
... am yet to hear from Hexa, in fact I called them 3 times and everytime am told I'll get a call back in 5mins from Hexa salesperson.

Edit: Now they are even cutting my call.

That's too bad. Try different dealers. Dealer experience is not consistent and some are better than the others. In Hyderabad, Malik is better than others. Concorde here seems to have cleaned up their act but other dealers are still living in another era :)


All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 17:39.