Re: Hatch Back Vs Sedan ( Ride, handling, comfort, Power, Space, etc) My first car was a Maruti 800, and the boot was seldom enough for any of our family outings. Even if we were to run to Pune for a single day, the boot would usually be full. Imagine how we coped with 3-4 days of outstation travel with five members on board! Finally after a few months I got a roof carrier fitted to the car to provide some breathing space, as otherwise the passengers would have to carry loose luggage items in their laps!
The Santro is bigger, but it's still inherently a hatch. The boot is bigger than the M 800, however with a full complement it still overflows.
Then came the Ikon with a cavernous boot (that's how it looks to me after having seen the hatches). Now except the hand luggage which should be with the passengers (such as eatables) I can store everything else in the boot. I could ferry my bro from airport to home and vice versa, accomodating two huge suitcases (though not with ease and some luggage had to be stowed inside the cabin). But it allowed us to travel together, a mini family outing, which is unthinkable with a hatch.
That's about the luggage space. Now some other characteristics.
After a ride in the Ikon, my mom opined that it was more comfortable to the Santro. Being a little longer and being a sedan, the Ikon obviously has more ride comfort than a hatch. Plus the legroom is marginally more (and even though it may be marginal, it does make a difference!). Three people can sit on the rear seat without making it crowded. Patches and uneven surfaces on the road don't cause a sudden braking, as the car can more easily plough through/over them.
On my recent trip to Kolhapur I could sustain three digit speeds on the e-ways and open roads, something I wouldn't dare do in the hatch. The new tyres and the TPMS did help build up confidence, but all things being equal the hatch would still cruise at lower speeds.
Now some pros: The hatch provides an excellent all round view (however this seems to be particular to the Santro and not a general hatch characteristic). Getting in and out is a breeze, the driving position is comfortable (in terms of knees hitting the steering) and it's generally roomier. Also when parking, the Ikon with almost double the length does make it difficult. With the Maruti I could almost park it wherever I found a gap. The Santro requires some more space, while the Ikon requires a lot!
The FE that the hatch returns is almost always about 2kmpl more than the sedan. Plus on crowded city streets it's much easier to navigate the small car around the various (moving and non-moving) obstacles on the road than the sedan.
So each type has its own strengths and weaknesses. It's a matter of evaluating each and decide which strengths you cannot do without and which weaknesses you can live with. |