The curious case of sexy Civic and its shoes? (Sherlock Holmes needed) Hello everybody,
This is a very curious case which has left me with mixed feelings of sadness, anger, frustration and bewilderment. In spite of trying every possible option, I have not been able to find a proper solution, hence reaching out to you for thoughts. Since the post is big, I will put in parts. The cast
The Heroine: Sexy White Civic (pic with my son and doggy below)
Main Characters: Me , Bridgestone, Honda service center, Honda, Yokohama, M-Tyre Villain : To be identified Introduction of the characters
Civic : well known for giving the adrenaline rush amongst other good feelings, brings a smile every time I get in.
Me: A software professional; In past 16+ years my cars have been : Maruti Omni, Maruti 800, WagonR, Maruti Esteem, Honda City, Honda Accord, BMW X5, Honda Odyssey, Honda Civic . I have crunched over 1,60,000 Kms on various terrains in India, US, UK
Bridgestone, Yokohoma – Car shoes companies
Honda Service Center, Mysore
Honda – Creator of my Civic
M-Tyres – biggest supplier of tyres in Mysore and provider of some machinery to Honda service center in Mysore The Case In 27K kms, tyres changes 3 times Bridgestone, Yokohama A-Drive & Yokohama DB series (Premium Range), the brand new premium range tyres also found bad as per Honda service center, Tyre company disagrees! Is the problem with Car, tyres or service center? Everybody is pointing fingers at the other. Problem : Rumbling sound Accused : Bridgestone - Bad in 22K kms Reasons given : Chemical spill, road, civic eats more rubber Problem : Pulling to left Accused :Yokohama A-Drive - Bad in 4k Kms Reasons given : No problem, inherent behaviour in road, tyre mark & valve not aligned properly, manufacturing moulds 10 yr old, inherent manufacturing defect Problem : Pulling to left Accused :Yokohama DB series - Bad in 0 Kms Reasons given : Yokohamas are not meant for Civic The Details
As you would see from above, I have a decent driving experience across a range of cars and roads. I have changed many a cars, not for problems but upgrades, changes in my location etc. But the problem that I am facing now, I have never faced before. Feb 2011 - Without going too much in the past, let me start –with 22K+ on odo now, I took the car for its regular service to Honda service center. 25k service was done as 6 months were over from last service. I noticed a rumbling sound which used to come when car was between 40-60 Kmph and put its down as something to be checked. The car was very nicely serviced and handed over to me. On driving, I noticed the decibel levels increasing a little bit and after 2-3 days, I again take her back to service station. After multiple rounds of rotation, alignment & balancing the problem was diagnosed as - tyres which were stock Bridgestone. The treads were checked and they were absolutely fine. During various stages of discussions, I was told by service advisor : I have driven over some chemical spill which has altered the character of all 4 tyres. I didn’t recall when I swam through the chemical pool. For a second opinion, I took the car to M-Tyre. They checked – aligned, balanced again and said tyres don’t have a problem instead they have enough tread to last another 10K. I take the car back to service center and another round of check, rotation, balancing – they put another set of tyres from another Civic and drive – the sound went away. “Sir, please change your tyres now’ So, I go back to M-Tyre and ask them for Michelins. Unfortunately, they were not available and I settle for Yokohama A-Drive (195/65). I pay 17500 for tyres and additional for balancing, alignment etc. Voila! no sound and car is absolutely silent and is pleasure to drive. contd.....
Last edited by punkuz : 16th September 2011 at 07:43.
Reason: corrected typos
|