Fiat Punto engine failure @ 57000 kms! With heavy heart I am starting this thread here. I purchased my 1.3 MJD Grande Punto 4 years back. It was a decision taken from heart and I loved the vehicle throughout my ownership.
Eventhough there were many niggles with the service centre during TATA times as well as after changeover to FIAT, I have never complained about it as this car was very close to my heart and I wanted the FIAT brand to shine.
I have done all the services on time and have done all the suggested replacements from the service centres till now.
Story starts 1 month back when I have taken my car for early 60K service when it had clocked 55800kms at Vecto motors Bangalore (Singasandra). I was well within my 15k service interval from previous service. I only had minor issues like glow plugs change and some minor rattle sound from rear seat.
After leaving it for service, I got a call from service advisor Dayanand stating that there is some sound coming from engine timing belt and he is suggesting to replace it. As per his own words, this timing chain replacement is not mandatory for 75hp punto, but for 90hp punto/linea it is scheduled to replace during 60k service. He suggested me to go for it as my extended warranty was going to get over. He quoted a price of 11.5k for doing this.
I had a few concerns over this
1) I was unsure of changing the timing belt so soon @ 55800. I heard from many friends that it needs to be changed only at 1Lakh+
2) It was not a recommended change from fiat service manual
3) He was not able to show me the engine noise that he was suggesting when I went for taking delivery
5) I didnt had enough money to shell out for it before getting the salary. Already regular service bill was coming to 14k.
With all this in mind I told them I will come back later for doing the timing belt replacement.
Three weeks later, I was driving to Trivandrum from Bangalore for Pooja holidays with family. Starting from bangalore, the car showed no signs of any problem. I was able to take it to 120+ kmph. 40kms before Salem I started feeling reduced power from engine. It is not able to gain speed much. Still there are no indicators coming up in the console - no low oil, no engine heating. I thought of getting it checked in Salem fiat service as it is going to be night drive after that.
At 57400 kms at odo I drive it into Salem Truesai motors service centre. The service advisor there was a helpful person and quickly started checking for any problem. First thing that he noticed is engine oil level is very low (around 1.1 litres only) and it shouldnt happen to a car serviced only 3 weeks back. He topped up the engine oil and suggested me to get it checked again in trivandrum. After that he notices the most dangerous symptom. Smoke coming out of engine oil dipstick nozzle. He didnt recommend to drive it at this state and he needed more time to tell me what is the problem. I leave the car there and hire a taxi and continue my journey to Trivandrum.
After 2 days of Pooja holidays, I get a call from Salem service centre which has given me the biggest shock in recent times. That the engine is gone bad completely, there are scratches all over the crankshaft bearings. He is unsure of why this happened. For furthe analysis, the engine needs to be opened completely. He said the repair possible is an engine overhaul which will cost me possibly 1Lakh+ !!!!
I raised a complaint with fiat-india customer care describing my problem in detail. I get a call from Fiat india to give it to Vecto motors and they will follow up with them. I tow the car from Salem to Bangalore and give it to Vecto motors last Monday.
Yesterday, I get call from Vecto motors saying that the engine has gone bad and the reason for that is I didnt change the timing belt !!! They gave a reply by mail to the complaint I raised to fiat also giving the same reason.
My questions to fiat india were simple
1) Why would a timing chain problem cause such serious engine damage?
2) All this damage was caused only during that 1500kms (in 2 weeks) which I ran after the service?
3) What reason will you tell me if I had brought my car for service only now at 57k kms which is still within 15k service interval and only 13 months from last service?
Without any satisfactory answer to these questions, fiat has closed my complaint.
I would request fellow bhpians to help me with what all options I have here.
I am not in a position to spend over 1Lakh for engine repair.
Can I escalate it to some more higher authorities in fiat and request them to cover it under extended warranty which got over just few weeks back.
Do you guys really think that a timing chain problem which comes at just 57K kms can damage the engine so much? |