Quote:
Originally Posted by pgsagar MrIncredible, since it is Scorpio gearbox trouble thread, I did not want to respond to post #5 about where the poster spoke about DSG blowing Torque Converter (TC) into weeds etc. But I wonder if he has really driven an Accord V6. Last year I was bent on getting a pre-owned Laura diesel DSG or Cruze AT and drove several examples. Did not understand what all the fuss about DSG is. It was hesitant off startline and shifts did not seem faster than TC to me. At least not noticeable. Cruze AT seemed just as quick.
Coming to Accord, my cousin bought a 2005 Accord 3.0 V6 with 45 K KM on odo last year March. He used it till Feb mid and after that went to US for a few months on assignment. Since last March to this Feb. He drove like it was his enemy's car. Yet, not a day spent in garage. And acceleration? Oh my God. It just butchers almost all D segment cars in acceleration. Yes, it is big and barge-like and wallowy on corners. But in a straight line it will kill most other cars in its class. Wheels spin on first 3 gears. But, on the downside, it has none of that sporty exhaust note big American V6's have. I take it out for occassional spin once in a while since March this year and oh my god. I grin like a child every time I step on the go pedal. I think those 5 lakhs are my cuz's best-spent money. You can't have more bang for your money than this. Yes, it drinks fuel. Granny style driving would get you 9 to 10 kpl. But then why drive a V6 then? Explosive acceleration driving would give you 6 to 7 kpl. But I say it is a small price to pay for the fun you have. This car should be bought as an additional fun car, apart from having a econo diesel car as daily drive. |
Pgsagar, I wrote post#5. I think you may have misunderstood me. When I say DSG blows a TC AT into the weeds, I mean the shift times and fuel efficiency, not outright speed of the vehicle. Try being at 40/50/60/70 and then slam the acceleration down. In sports mode. In both types. See how fast the gear changes happen in both.
Obviously, a 3l V6 will beat a 1.2 turbo, no question, twice the power. . Or a cruze.Yes, Its a different thing that my 4 cylinder Accord is slower than my Tsi till 150 and gave me 7 kmpl in my office commute.
Driving a TC AT by itself is great. Smooth when your inputs are normal. In fact, my wife who drives the i10 AT couldnt make out the difference with the polo DSG, just said it feels more eager.
We also had a civic AT in the family (now replaced by a freelander 2). In both, the gearboxes are competent. But again, in both, shift times are nowhere close to a DSG.
Drive a laura DSG and a cruze AT side by side. Hard, as well as in city traffic with occasional hard throttle to close gaps. And check the fuel efficiency in both. Youd wonder why an engine with 15% more power cant shake a laura dsg off, AND gives worse mileage. Drive a i10/i20/Verna/city/civic AT. And drive a polo/vento/rapid DSG side by side. See which set you had more fun with... I'd like to think how much fun and fuel efficient the accord v6 would be with the DSG.
Of course, do drive the 320d with the ZF 8 speed - best of both worlds, smooth and as fast in shifting.
Last edited by d_himan : 16th May 2015 at 16:58.
|