Felt really sick reading that.
Let me very quickly summarise my recent experience with Maruti A.S.S.:
Gave the car to them (Millenium) for painting, removal of small dents and replacing the cross member. All in Insurance. Had to opt for their pick up and drop facility as its very far and I just didnt have time. When the car was delivered to me, the exhaust was making an awful noise... like it does when it has holes/is ruptured. I asked the driver what is the problem, and how on earth did he bring the car in such a state to my place. He obviously put his hands up and said his job is only to deliver the vehicle, and he dosent know anything else. I called up the supervior and demanded an explaination. Now to cut a long story short, just consider the explaination given to me - Esteem exhaust consists a bent pipe from the engine that goes to the catcon which is under the driver seat. then the pipe connects to the end exhaust muffler. The catcon and muffler are corroded and should not be used in that state. The catcon is completely corroded from inside and has lost its functionality totally. It will cost about 8 - 10k to replace everything. (cant recall the exact quote, moreover this was just a tentative quote)
I flatly refused to pay for any replacements, and asked them how did the problem start only after giving the car to them. No concincing explaination was given. I told them to bring it back in the condition it was given to them, by whichever means...
They delivered the car back after a day, saying it has been welded. But I should get everything replaced. If I dont, there is a risk of fire as the catcon insulation plate was removed during welding to use it for the welding job, so some such crap. Since this was done, the heat from catcon may damage the underside, or may lead to fire.
Now the worst thing is, since exhaust systems are not at all visible unless you put the car on a ramp, I had no way to verify what I was told.
After this, I took the car to 3 garages to get second opinions.
Now the funniest thing is neither I nor any advisor in any of the garages could detect any sign of welding or any external work done on the catcon or the end muffler. The middle muffler did have signs of external welding.
Btw, I saw for myself that the Esteem exhaust is made of 1 catcon, 1 small middle muffler and 1 bigger muffler at the end (which is visible from the rear). So the theory told to me was WRONG!
1st garage (not authorised):
Advice - catcon has no sign any damage or anything else, and does not seem to need any replacement. Just replace both the mufflers. I could see that the middle muffler was quite corroded and was welded from the outside. The 2nd muffler again had absolutely no signs of any corrosion or damange and I have no idea why he adviced to change it. He anyway did not have an MGP end muffler and anyway, since still had my doubts, I left that garange.
2nd garage (not authorised)
Advice: Both catcon and end muffler do not need replacement. Just change the middle muffler. Price quoted - Rs. 2,500 with labour.
3rd garage (Sai Service, authorised)
Advice: The service advisor was not even ready to put the car on the ramp. He just go inside, accelerated the car a bit to hear the exhaust and declared that everything is perfectly fine, and we should not change anything as long as there is no problem. I said the middle muffler is quite corroded and has been temporarily welded. He said just dont worry about it as long as it is working, change it only after you start hearing abnormal exhaust noise. He totally rubished that there can be any fire risk due to catcon/exhaust heating and sent me off.
So you can see the very wide range of views obtained for the same problem. Which one should you trust? In the end you gotta use your own head, if you dont want to be ripped off and dumped with gibberish explainations.
Can anyone who knows better give any comments on the above? |