Quote:
Originally Posted by aarenes Here's my prespective. Point is
Now that I am back, I looked for nothing less that ABS and Airbag variants of the car which mostly means top end variants. I drive 50% on highways and 50% in the city.
My heart wanted the Linea so bad but since the MJD E+ was darn expensive for me, opted for the Punto MJD E+. Nothing without Airbags and ABS for me going forward in my lifetime.
You may chose to put a price tag for your life, but most certainly not your co-passengers. Family changes perspective. With options available on almost all cars sold today, I would recommend go for a segment lower but dont compromise on these utmost necessary safety features. Else stretch your budget. |
Well said, brother. Family does change perspective and ABS and airbags were on top of my list when I went shopping for our second car. The first one was a Swift Vdi ABS(I had to pull some strings to get an ABS variant at that time - it was very rare !! Shame on Maruti for not having a Zdi). Zeroed on the MJD Punto E-Pack, though it was slightly above my budget, nothing else would do.
Quote:
Originally Posted by McLaren Rulez That's a very slippery slope you are on right now. This isn't Europe where everyone can afford a car in the first place. Having it mandatory in India is a ridiculous idea. |
It is not so ridiculous, actually our country attaches such a low value to human life, that legistlation is sometimes the only way to go forward. Do you know that buses/trucks only started offering power steering after it was mandated by legistlation? Till then, what was preventing the manufacturers from offering it? Then again, it all boils down to the India attitude for getting everything cheapest, rest of the stuff be damned. That said, people still mostly(if at all) wear seatbelts because the law demands it, rather than for personal safety. I can understand the ignorant taxi driver doing it, but when educated folks refuse to belt up, I feel like
Quote:
Originally Posted by McLaren Rulez Let's say the government made ABS and airbags mandatory. The Tata Nano would then cost a large amount extra. From a one lakh car, it would go to a two lakh car because these are not cheap technologies. Think of those who will therefore have to continue ferrying a family of 4 on a scooter. I'd rather see them in a Nano without ABS and airbags which is far safer. |
Firstly, the law does not allow family of 4 on a scooter, it is just that law enforcement turns a blind eye to it. If nano's could have had ABS, the cost for it would come down from 20k to 5k. Similar to airbags. Mass production and competition would make it affordable. World over, the Swift has only one model, with all the bells and whistles and importantly, ABS & Airbags. We get a stripped down Lxi, Vxi etc. Because, Indians would rather save that 50k and be sorry than spend it and be safe !! Everyone thinks, what is the probability that I will have an accident? Very small - so let me save that 50k. Or, as somebody wrote in this thread, I drive only in city, so I don't need it. 99.99% you don't, but what about that uncertain .01%? Do the people who think on these lines abhor life insurance as well?
Quote:
Originally Posted by McLaren Rulez They could make it mandatory for expensive cars but then all of these models above a certain price point already have ABS and airbags as standard features in at least one version. The best they could do is to ask manufacturers to have these two in all the versions if the car is above a certain price point. That too is a bit of a slippery slope in terms of deciding at what price point to enforce this law, but it is certainly a lot better than asking all carmakers to have airbags irrespective of price. |
Price point - that distinction is already there, without legistlation. As you said, customers of higher end cars have started demanding this feature, even if it is primarily percieved as a luxury feature rather than as a safety feature. How else do you explain manufacturers clubbing ABS in their high end variant only? Maruti tried to alter the game by offering at least ABS as option in their Vxi/Vdi range, but Indian public showed that we ae still to evolve.