Quote:
Originally Posted by SushilBajpai That's a brilliant review and comparison. Your review provides interesting insights and perspectives. I have never driven a Civic. However reading your review, I could visualize what it must be like to drive one.
I issue from the reliability point of view would be more of availability of spares etc, as the dealers might not be keeping adequate inventory and if Skoda too relies on imports rather than local manufacture then we could have delays in getting the issues fixed. |
Thanks Sushil! Same is the case with us and both cars have completely different characters and different strengths and weaknesses, but like they say, even the strongest have an Achilles heel!
Quote:
Originally Posted by oxyzen That is one great combo for a garage. A petrol & a diesel. A Honda (japanese) and a Skoda. (Check/German). A sedan & a SUV!
Whats even better is the review. Great work.
BTW these are my favorite C+ segment sedan and SUV.
Considering the handling between Civic and Yeti what is your take on body roll. The Yeti does have a higher CG but the suspensions are hard.
What about quick steering or agility?
I love the Yeti for everything it offers except the looks. The front looks aggressive and tempting but the rest of the car must have been designed by a drunken architect. To add to the final insult the bumpers are not even body coloured. |
Thanks oxyzen! The Yeti has negligible body roll and you will not feel it at all even if you corner at 100+ speeds. The civic however is in a different league altogether and is designed like a low slung race car - so its body roll is very less. The Yeti's body roll in comparison to other SUVs is a very small fraction as the CG is not too high. The overall height is not more than a Wagon R, and track width (distance between the wheel on the same axles) is wide, giving it a wide, squat stance, which is good for stablility.
Steering is excellent on the Civic (typical race car style, with good high speed handling, but a little stiff at slow speed. Comparatively, the Yeti is a little soft at slow speed, but weights up with speed. As it is a pure EPS (electronic power steering)so there is a little loss of road feel, but it is very accurate and there is no understeer / oversteer.
The front looks quirky and aggressive, but the back is definitely too plain
. I have tried to add some spark to the back by adding a small chrome strip. Skoda should definitely work on the rear end of the Yeti to beautify it a bit! The unpainted bumpers are actually by design, as when vehicle is taken off road, the body coloured bumpers get badly damaged. However, we also did not like the unpainted bumpers and hence took it in Black where it is least visible! Also, in the Yeti, the B Pillar is body coloured and not black, while A and C pillars are.. this also looks odd and is visible in other colours, but not in black!
Quote:
Originally Posted by v.anand Wonderful write-up and comparison. Kudos to your garage, terrific choice of cars.
One thing I noticed in your Yeti is the headrests of the front and back seats are inter-changed. Any particular reason for this, since I believe its positioning also aides or affects seat comfort as well as safety. |
Yes, you have a sharp eye! I did swap the front and rear headrests for two reasons: The back headrests give slightly better support to the neck as they are more forward than the normal ones (however, they are not active head restraints) and the second being is that for passengers sitting in the back the view is better if the front headrests are smaller. With the normal ones, it completely blocks the front view for the rear passengers!
Quote:
Originally Posted by dot Did you use the paddle shifters during the drag race? I have a feeling the results might have been a bit different with the paddle shifters and a 100% floored accelerator. BTW, it is awesomely cool to drag with your wife.
Regarding the bottoming out issue, in my experience if the Civic is taken over bumpers slowly, nothing really happens. Unless of course, the humps in your area are truly mini-mountains. |
Nope..! (Luckily wife does not know how to use the paddle shifts!) But it was in S mode and she did drive it flat out. It was still very close, but I am sure with the paddle shifts, the Civic would have won, due to the higher power to weight ratio and better aerodynamics. But you really need to push the engine to 5000-6000 rpm to draw its power! The Yeti on the other hand comfortably pulls ahead in the 2000-4000 rpm range, due to its peak torque in the range.
If the Civic is with 1-2 passengers, there is never an issue, but load up 4-5 heavyweights, then the underbelly does scrape the mountains near our house! (The breakers are much larger than acceptable standard in Gurgaon). Same was also the case with our earlier Ford Fiesta 1.4 Zxi, which also scraped the breakers.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Axe77 What a fantastic piece. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this. I currently own a 2009 civic A/T. Love it to bits. I am 60% chauffeur driven and 40% self driven. Comfort while I'm at the back and driving pleasure when I'm at the wheel are both equally important to me - I would find it very tough to compromise too heavily on any one of these in favour of the other. Given the above, if I had to define what I'd really like as an upgrade in my garage, here's what I'd want:
- CRV / Outlander size SUV that can provide somewhat car like handling with all the softroader advantages;
- Neither as small as yeti, X1, Q3 etc nor as big as Fortuner, Endeavour, Captiva etc. (5 seater is fine for me);
- DIESEL engine that's FAST!!! Doesn't have to be outright fuel efficient. Any reasonable FE will also do if it's diesel powered;
- Auto tranny (sophisticated and at least 5 speed);
- Honda / Toyota type long term reliability and peace of mind;
- Generous boot size;
- Price: 20 to 30 Lakh acceptable although I'd even pay more if something checks all the boxes above.
Unfortunately, at this point, I can't think of any offering that even meets 90% of these requirements.
PS: On a side note, even if I get all of the above in another vehicle, I can't imagine giving up my civic. I'd probably try and talk my wife / mum to give up one of their cars (i20 & city automatic respectively) and peddle my civic down to them rather than let it go. Like I said - I absolutely love my civic to bits even with all it's minor shortcomings.
Cheers. |
The Civic is a great car, both as a driver's car and also as a Chauffeur driven one. The Yeti on the other hand is only a driver's car!
My wishlist is also similar, and only a CRV with a diesel engine may come close to this! But unless Honda decides to start assembling the CRV in India and price it at reasonable levels, this dream may not come true. To give you an idea of the unreasonable price levels in India. I was in Dubai recently, and came to know the Civic 1.8 V MT costs around 8 lacs (equivalent INR) there. The CRV there costs Rs 9.5 Lacs . Also, the Fortuner costs 16 Lacs there and hold your breath, the Land cruiser costs 20 Lacs! Couple that with the cheap cost of fuel Rs 22 per litre of Petrol and Rs 21/ Liter of Diesel, you can buy and afford any car there!
I tend to think that the Indian Auto segment also needs to be deregulated a bit to encourage better quality cars to come into India at more affordable prices!
Drive safe!