We have a Honda City and a Honda Civic in our household too. I bought my pre-owned 2007 Honda Civic VMT 18 months back for a little over Rs. 9 Lacs. And last month, my brother bought a new Honda City SMT for about the same price. I have driven the Honda City for around 200 kms and the Honda Civic for around 15,000 kms. Here are my thoughts on Pre-Owned Honda Civic Vs New Honda City -
ADVANTAGE BRAND NEW HONDA CITY:
1)
Better low-end torque and city driveability. The Honda City engine pulls cleanly from 800 - 1000 rpm even in the second gear. So there is no need to downshift to first gear over humps. In bumper to bumper traffic, just slipping the clutch will get the car moving - even without pressing the accelerator. In the comparison, Honda Civic has poor city driveability and you have to visit the first gear too often. However, you get used to the driving characteristics of the Honda Civic after a few thousand kms and I no longer feel that this is a huge negative.
2)
Better low speed ride quality. The Honda City sails over bad patches of roads below 40 kmph. Even sharp ruts do not pass on the vibrations to the driver through the steering wheel. High speed ride quality is pretty decent too. In comparison, the Honda Civic has a lot harsher ride quality at low speeds. Doesn't ride like a Rs. 16 Lac car. However, the rear passengers have a comfortable ride because of softer suspension at the back.
3) I expect my brother's Honda City to have a
lower maintenance cost in the first year because the car is new.However, my pre-owned Honda Civic needed new tyres, new clutch and new brake pads in the first year of ownership. The 6 CD changer conked out thrice and I have given up on it totally. I have now purchased a AUX-IN to USB convertor and play all my music from a pen drive. I also had to purchase new insurance policy within 2 months after I bought the car. All this cost me around Rs. 80,000 extra. But my second year of ownership has been light on the pocket so far.
4) Honda City gives
better mileage - around 11 kmpl in the city and 15 kmpl on the highways. In comparison, my Honda Civic gives 9 kmpl in the city and 13 kmpl on the highway.
DEUCE - No particular car has a significant advantage when comparing these parameters:
1) Both cars have equally rev-happy engines and hence the needle keeps visiting the 7,000 RPM levels quite often. However, the Honda Civic engine feels a little bit smoother (possibly because the Civic's engine is nicely run in, while City's engine is still new).
2) Price! We bought both the cars for around the same price. We both got ribbons, balloons and chocolates with our cars. However, the Honda City came with plastic all over the seats and that new car smell (which the Civic didn't have).
3) Rear seat comfort of both the cars is similar. But perhaps Honda City has a slight edge over the Civic because of that angled footrest at the back.
4) Although Civic has 6 speakers and City has 4, both the cars have similar sound quality.
5) Both the cars have equally good high speed ride quality.
6) City's boot space of 500 litres might be more than that of Civic's (430 litres), but the Civic too can pack in lot of stuff. You just need to be a bit creative and know where to place the luggage.
7) Driver ergonomics & gearshift quality of both the cars are similar, with the Civic having a slight edge.
8) In the looks department, both the cars have a striking front end, elegant side profile and fussy/boring/ugly back end.
ADVANTAGE PRE-OWNED CIVIC:
1) Honda Civic has lot
more features/equipment than the City. I get climate control, electrically foldable side view mirrors, fog lamps, alloy wheels, fatter grippier tyres, full leather interiors and a 6 CD MP3 player that works only for 3 months before conking off. However, my brother's Honda City has got stereo mounted audio controls & a GPS Navigation system (offered by the dealer).
2) Honda Civic has a lot
nicer interiors, especially in the VMT trim. However, I'm not quite sure what the fuss is all about on Honda City's supposedly bad interior quality. Seems fine to me.
3)
Steering feel and feedback for Honda Civic is a 9 out of 10. However, the EPS unit of Honda City, although light, is not too bad either. I get a fair amount of feedback from the wheel and one gets used to it after driving for sometime. However, at moderately high speeds (100 kmph) on a dual carriage way weaving through traffic, somebody who is used to driving a Honda Civic will find the Honda City a bit disconcerting.
4) Honda Civic is a
much better handler than a Honda City. However, changing the shoes of the Honda City should bring it closer to the Civic. The stock skinny tyres on the Honda City however will suit 80% - 90% of the buyers.
VERDICT
:
There are 4 parameters where Honda City can be considered to be distinctly better than a pre-owned Honda Civic. And there are 4 parameters where the Honda Civic trumps the City. And in many other parameters, the comparison between the City & Civic is like comparing apples and oranges. Overall, in my opinion, Honda City is a better City car while Honda Civic is a better highway car.