Going through the forum I could not find a detailed type 'pictorial' review on A-Star "Manual Transmission". So I decided to start a new thread which covers all the pros and cons of owning an A-Star MT for nearly four and a half years.
Decision
The only other car considered was the Chevrolet Spark. But it was discarded because of the casual attitude of the dealer. The dealer took about a week to provide a test drive. Next option was the then newly launched A-Star. We were much impressed with the test drive and looked no further and booked the A-Star.
Dealer Experience
The dealer experience was a bag of mixed opinions. The Sales Executive was very friendly and a nice guy. But the delivery experience was not such a good one. The only freebies offered was a cheap steering wheel cover,some door mats as thin as tarpualins, and perhaps a chinese dash mounted perfume. And not to forget a box of maha lacto candies. The security system was installed on the day of delivery itself. The mechanic who did the installation perhaps was an auto rickshaw mechanic, who kept the opened bumper on concrete without bothering for the scratches. Overall the dealership experience was just average. The free servicings were done with the dealer. But after dissatisfied with the quality of sevice by the dealer Jyote motors we moved on to a MASS Indo Japan motors. The service experience with Indo Japan has been so far good.
From a owners point of view after owning the car for more than four years here are some pros and cons:
What you will like:- Funky design and styling
- Excellent fuel efficiency
- Euro ncap rated vehicle
- Cheap spares and wide service network
What you won't like:- Poor engine performance at low rpms
- Too much vibrations during idle
- Extremely compact boot space
- Rear seat isn't comfy and limited legroom
- Thick C pillars create severe blindspots while reversing
Exterior and Styling:
The bug eyed smiling face is the most beautiful part of the car to look at.
The eye shaped fog lamp bezels do blend well with the huge bumper without a grill.
The fenders do get a treatment from the Swift with the beefed up wheel arches.The turn indicators seem to have come from the Amby era.
The front doors are huge for this size of car but they shut with a 'thud' instead of a banging noise.The ORVMS are sturdy and move backward in case of an impact. The rear doors are smaller and need a bit more force to shut them. The ingress and outgess becomes difficult for the rear passengers due to the smaller door at the rear. At the back the hatch is very small with a huge bumper which makes things loading and unloading a bit difficult. The rear profile of the car is a love it or hate it design.
Interiors:
The interior has a dual tone grey and black(grey being replaced with beige in the spiced up newer version)combination.
The steering,geat knob, circular side AC vents,door handles,power window controls & locks are a straight lift from the previous generation Swift.
The dashboard plastic quality is marginally better than the outgoing Swift. The stock ICE has a metallic silver garnish. It looks and sounds good too.
An USB port is sorely missed though there is an Aux port.The steering wheel doesn't get audio controls even on the highest variant.
The budget quality wipers and light stalk get a matte finish unlike the shiny stuff of the previous generation Wagon-R.
And as far as AC controls are concerned the get a touch of silver. The circulation on/off slider does not look out of place. The hazard lamps are placed a bit oddly below the AC controls. Near it the car gets a 12 V accessory socket. Below the socket and hazard lamp switch there is a cubicle for storing CDs etc.
On the gear console it has two cup holders with a removable ash tray in one of them. Just below the handbrake there is a shallow space for holding mobiles,mp3 players etc.Not very useful. Not to forget there is an illuminated storage place just above the AC controls which can be used for holding mobile phones,idols. The glove box is decent in size.Coming to the rear the problem faced is that the handbrake console extends into the floor hump making the problem for the 5th passenger even more. The rear door pockets can hold a 500ml bottle comfortably unlike the front door pockets which can hold only a newspaper.
The rear seats can be folded with the help of two straps on either sides.The jack gets a separate space.The boot space is the unique non selling point of this car. However decent space is generated with the rear seats folded down.
Engine and manual gearbox:
The 1.0 litre K10B petrol engine is rated at 67 bhp@6200 rpm and the maximum torque is 90 Nm@3500 rpm. The engine is quite smooth and vibe free at higher rpms but at idle speed the vibrations inside the cabin is very much noticeable. Moving the car from a standstill is something that needs 'getting used to.'Even on slight inclines it tends to stall when the accelerator is not pressed. But at cruising speeds the engine is pretty quiet and revv happy.
The 5 speed manual gearbox has nothing much to complain about except for the reverse gear. Sometimes the reverse gear does not engage and makes a krr-krr sound while releasing tbhe clutch. Very annoying.
Ride and handling:
The ride quality is neither too soft nor too bouncy.Most of the irregularities of the road are taken care of with ease. On the rear seats the ride becomes a tad bouncy making it a bit uncomfortable for the rear passengers. Thigh support and bolstering is also not great in the rear seats while the front seats are very well countoured and well bolstered which helps in minimizing body roll.
On the handling point of view the bug is an absolute gem. The perfectly weighted EPS is good for both city as well as highway runs. The feedback is good and the car moves exactly on the line you intend to.
Some random snaps:
The remote boot and fuel release levers:
MORE PHOTOS IN THE NEXT POST