There’s quite nothing like a garage full of BMWs to wake you up on a lazy Sunday afternoon. After a quick lunch, I headed to test the Bavarian automakers latest Indian offerings. Joining me was a neighborhood buddy and Dad. Dad because he loves to come along for test-drives and watch the rpm needle hover into the red zone.
Chris Bangles weird lines still haven’t grown on me and I don’t think they will ever. I still find the front end quirky and much prefer the previous 3’s clean and proportionate lines. Also, the rear end looks surprisingly ordinary for a 30 lac sedan. The build quality, as expected, is precision redefined. Even when you expect a lot, a BMW will still leave an impression on you.
The alloy wheel choice is horrible. Both – the 16s and 17 inchers – come in very ordinary designs.
It sure is expensive with a 29 lac on-the-road price for the 320i petrol, a 33 lac price tag for the 320d and a 37 lac tag on the full-blown 325 (all Mumbai prices). I would have thought BMW will opt for a more aggressive pricing strategy under-cutting its arch rival; more so in a country where the three-pointed star is so much more entrenched.
The 325i sounds like an absolute MONSTER! If you thought the Vtec is the most revv-happy engine in India, think again. But for the test-drive, we got the 320D. We presume it will be the most popular version in India. I was also very keen on comparing it to the C220 which, after 30000 kms of hard-driving, I know inside out. The first thing that strikes you is the perfect driving position. Somehow, high end German cars have a knack of fitting you like a glove and the Beemer 3 is no different from the Benz in this area. A multitude of seat adjustments and perfect ergonomics make you feel at home. I was looking forward to the drive from Chembur to Thana. And back.
Interiors are well-built and boast of the finest quality materials. But it’s just that. They are not exceptional in any single way and I missed the cocooning effect of the Benz where everything wraps around you. There are no swoops and curves with everything coming across as boxy or rectangular. With respect to the rear seat space, the restriction of the C and the 3 continues. It is a little more spacious at the rear than the C220 but still cramped and can seat 4 at best. No one can sit behind me in the driver’s seat in the C. And no one can in the 3 either. The 325i has much better interiors, what with its iDrive and gizmos but at a 35+ lac price...its in a different league.
Before we hit the highway, there is a 2 km stretch through the backlanes of Chembur. Surprisingly the steering felt very heavy and lifeless at low speeds (below 30 – 40). The 2 liter common-rail is pretty loud from the outside. However, shut the door and the noise is history. Such is the quality of sound insulation. Unfortunately, the manual transmission does not figure anywhere in BMWs Indian plans and the 6-speed auto box is the only option available. It does have a tip-tronic but experience has taught me that the gear lever is best parked in D.
Boys will be boys, and the minute we got on the highway it was pedal to the metal! It normally takes a little time to familiarize yourself with the behavior of a new car, but what struck me most was that I felt at home in 5 minutes flat. The chassis / suspension combo is so unbelievably intuitive and responsive that you feel like its reading your mind. The acceleration is fast and very linear (no torque push in the back like the C220). The engine develops a distinct and addictive road as you climb up the rpm meter but up shifts, even a full throttle, at only 4300 rpm. The mid-range is astounding even for a diesel and the sheer drivability is superb! A word about the auto-box: The automatic gearbox is silky smooth and offers fast seamless up shifts. This is amongst the best auto-gearboxes I have experienced and far superior in response to the Merc E-Class slush box. Even in hard-driving, the BMW returned 8.5 kpl (according to the on-board comp). Sedate driving saw the figure going to 11.
Highlight of the test-drive was a friendly encounter with a green modified Honda 1.5. No difference in performance on the straights but come bad roads / handling / braking, we left him for dead. After 10 minutes, we couldn’t even locate him in the back.
The handling is beautiful, and the overall feel is very agile; agile to the point where the Beemer feels far smaller than it actually is. The brakes are fabulous in feel and in effectiveness. We had a stint where the brakes were slammed at high speed; and the Beemer stopped with no drama and in a straight line. As the speedometer climbed higher, we discovered one huge drawback – High speed stability. It was nowhere as close to the C220 at high speeds (and we have done 240 in the C220). Forget the drivers, even the my Dad and friend on the rear seat complained of a wafty light feeling. I didn’t expect this from the BMW. Even otherwise, the Beemer did not feel as “solid” as the Mercedes.
The ride quality is astoundingly good; and light-years ahead of the C220. The C can be very harsh over bad stretches but the 3 simply wafts over and only a soft nudge of the bad roads reaches the cabin. I expected the ride to be stiff due to the run-flats but the BMW impresses over bad terrain.
My verdict: The 3 is not that much better than the current C as I thought. In fact, both have their own strengths. I would give the engine, interior and stability card to the Benz while the Beemer scores on ride quality and handling. Plus, to me, the Beemer comes with quirky lines and does not have a manual gearbox. If I were looking for a 30 lac sedan, I would wait for the new C. If initial reports are anything to go by, it’s going to be a stonker.