Test Drive & Comparo: Honda CR-V vs Ford Endeavour vs Suzuki Grand Vitara Hey all,
I am looking to upgrade from my current ride and recently test drove the Honda CR-V M/T, Ford Endeavor 2.5 XLT 4x2 and the Suzuki Grand Vitara A/T in attempt to zero down on my new car. Since this forum has been a wealth of information for me, I thought I'd share my experiences in order to benefit others considering purchasing these SUVs:
1. Ford Endeavor 2.5 XLT 4x2 Pros:
- 7 seater and honestly the third row of seats is not all that bad (I'm 5'11" and could sit there comfortably for atleast half hour)
- Diesel economy and rather good mileage for a car its size
- Rear A/c vents and fan controls (u can increase the fan speed for the back seat while your chauffer can have lower fan speed) Cons: - Too big for city driving (almost 5 meters) and would require 1.5 parking spaces
- Acceleration s**ks (feels like I'm driving a tank, can't imagine how sluggish old Endy must have been before engine upgrade)
- Actually works out to be quite expensive as basic car is too basic (one needs to add atleast Hurricane package which costs Rs. 1 lakh) Verdict: - The only reason I would buy it is if I had an outhouse (few hours away from city) that I visit once or twice a month and needed to be chauffer-driven (else 5 seater may suffice) 2. Suzuki Grand Vitara Pros:
- Looks good (like a mini version of range-rover)
- 5 lakhs cheaper than Honda CR-V Cons: - Interiors very dull (black interiors with silver trims) and similar to Swift
- Ride is very hard and quite uncomfortable for rear passengers
- No luxury features that you would expect even in a 10+ lakhs car (forget 15+ lakhs!) such as automatic side view mirrors, digital thermostat for a/c, audio controls on steering wheel etc.
- Under-powered engine (120 horses) for an SUV
- No rear a/c vents Verdict - Felt like its a poor man's CR-V. Not worth 15 lakhs given lack of luxury features and Suzuki badge. The ride control feature is quite useless for India unless you live in a village. 3. Honda CR-V Pros: - Looks great (very contempary and european styling)
- Aux-in for connecting IPod (this is huge since all the cars come with factory audio units which means u got to use cassette adapter or ITunes to plug in your IPod)
- Good acceleration (160 horses makes it quite thrilling to drive) and handling (not scary to turn a corner at 60 kmp/h)
- Feature laden: Power seats, telescopic steering wheel, auto retract side view mirrors, dual climate control Cons: - Rear seat is not super comfortable to accomodate 3 passengers since its 40:20:40 split, although more comfortable it its only 2 passengers at back
- Most expensive of the 3 SUVs tested
- No rear a/c vents Verdict: - Definitely the SUV I would buy given the option. Its good for self-driving and also has enough snob value to be driven around in. Conclusion: 1. Honda CR-V
2. Suzuki Grand Vitara
3. Ford Endeavor
In the end, Honda CR-V emerged as the clear winner in my books. Its expensive but that depends on what you are comparing it to. If you're comparing it to an Accord, Corolla or Civic, its expensive (since they are quite feature laden) but if you're comparing to Grand Vitara and especially Ford Endeavor, its actually more bang for the buck (the endy doesn't even have an automatic radio antenna!)
The CR-V is the perfect mix between a city vehicle (80%) and an offroader (20%), which I think is the ratio in which most people will be using the vehicle.
The Grand Vitara can emerge as a competitor for the CR-V but not with the current list of standard features (no leather seats, auto side view mirrors, digital thermostat for a/c). Also the ride quality for back seat passengers is not ideal if majority of driving is going to be done on city roads or highway.
The Endy is too big for city driving and definitely to be driven-in rather than drive. Its 7 seat utility is negated by its driver un-friendliness and after visiting dealer I got the sense that I had been bait"ed" and switch"ed", meaning that basic car price makes it sound like a great deal but when you see what you are getting you have no option but to upgrade to one of their packages that cost between 1-2 lakhs extra. This makes the price difference between CR-V and Endy just 2-3 lakhs and tips the scale in the favor of the CR-V
Hope this helps. |