Transferred from my report in Formula India:
My work took me to worli today, and since I had an extra hour I decided to drop in at Vitesse and testdrive the Baleno. Maruti has just given a massive price-cut and the Baleno with tax and insurance works out to only Rs. 719270 Ex-Thana (which is the preferred choice for us Mumbaites, since we save on 4.5% octroi charges.) Vitesse is currently offering a 13000 cash discount on this price. If you opt for finance the discount will be proportionately higher. Also MUL has very recently launched a stripped of "mags and wings" version at Rs.6,46,000 on -road. Heres my first impressions after a 45 minute session with the Baleno.
On the looks front, the Baleno can be termed as plain horrible. The front end is the only saving grace on this car, while the rear is an absolute disaster with those boxy non-wraparound lights. The side profile is okay, but the mag wheels that Maruti provide with the car look even worse, in my opinion, than regular wheel caps. The 165mm tyres also look really skinny on a car of this size. Incorporated in the front bumper is a neat looking set of fog lamps but the other new addition; the rear bootlid spoiler, is a feeble attempt at trying to make the rear look presentable.
Speaking of magwheels and foglights, for a car of this price the Baleno is extremely well-equipped. It comes FULLY LOADED with power windows, electric mirrors, keyless remote entry, central locking, alloy wheels, spoiler, decent remote-controlled kenwood stereo, fog lights, tilt adjustable power steering, power antennae among a host of other smaller details.
The minute I started this car I was instantly impressed at the free reving nature of the Suzuki 1.6 liter engine. Its acceleration is really really good, and a nice torque curve gives it amazing city driveability. The refinement though is not at all in the league of the City(old or new)/Lancer duo.
Another pleasant surprise were the brakes. Though they felt a tad over-servoed, they are just brilliant in feel and stopping power supplying the driver with tons of confidence. The gear shift though is horrible, and it felt like a really stubborn hard plastic eraser (the type we have all used in school). Power steering is very well-weighted and I especially like the three spoke design (which I think has just been introduced).
Marutis flagship sedan handled the bad Mumbai roads pretty well and ride quality is only second to that of the Mitsubishi Lancer in this segment. It is far superior to what the older Honda city offers, but I don't remember the new City's drive that well to make comparisons between these two. The rear seat in the Baleno is no great shakes.
Interior quality was decent, but the dated design shows all through. There are now some new chrome inserts and a kenwood to spruce up the dash, but the almost decade old design still shows through. Typical suzukiness shows in the way that, if you manually lock the drivers door from inside, all the other doors don't automatically lock. You have to use an ergonomically uncomfortable central locking switch on the drivers door to lock all passenger doors. The good thing about being inside this car is that the air-con was an absolute chiller, inspite to today being a hot afternoon.
After a highly spirited drive on the worli seaface I pulled back into the parking lot of Vitesse. The thoughts that were running through my mind were all around why its not hard to figure out the market failure of this car. It has been a sales disaster in India, but its hasn't exactly performed well in Asia, Europe or the United States either.
Inspite of a powerful engine, it did not come across as being refined. It has good brakes and is well-equipped but I still wouldn't buy a Baleno, not even at this price. First and foremost is that when I pay 7 - 8 lacs for a car, I want it to feel special, luxurious, upmarket and classy. The Baleno is neither of these. Looks are very important to me and the Baleno fails miserably on this count too.
Lastly the depreciation is LIGHTNING fast on this car. In the year 2000 the Baleno was priced more or less in the same range as the Honda City (+/- 5 %). Butttttttttttttt you can get a three year old Baleno for 3 lacs odd, while a year 2000 Honda city 1.5 will fetch you around 4.75 to 5 lacs. For most people in India, a car is the second largest invenstment after a house and the Baleno can, at best, be termed as a stupid investment.
I guess that I am not the only enthusiast to opt out of the Baleno. How many Balenos do you see on the road with a good set of alloys, meaty grippy tyres and a free flow exhaust system? I still haven't seen a single one. Compare that to the endless number of Citys/Lancers/Zens/Esteems etc. and you will know what cars Indian enthusiasts prefer. Also enthusiasts will definitely do more research than the corporate types and will know an exciting car from a boring one.
If Maruti had done what Suzuki had globally i.e. replace the aging Esteem with the new Esteem (a.k.a. Baleno) maybe things would have been different for this car. As things are, its no wonder that Vitesse has a problem selling 5-8 Balenos a month and this is Maruti's best dealer in Bombay!
GTO |