Thanks a lot for these wonderful comparos and advices. I must say the promptness of the replies really made my day. This community rocks and so do you guys!!!!
@ .anshuman : I would surely checkout the Polo petrol like you suggested. But one question regarding the polo is, is it really worth going for it at almost the same price as the Swift VXI, considering that its 3 pot heart would be lower on technology and refinement compared to the swift. However, I am not at all questioning the peppiness of the engine or the ride quality of the polo which appears to be better than the Swift.
I had called up Varun Motors (Jubilee Hills) for a test drive of the swift and Malilk Cars (Banjara Hills) for a test drive of the punto, this morning. I was confirmed by both places that the demo cars are available and time slots were booked.
Malik Cars (TATA - Fiat) : First in list was Malik Cars. Time of test drive was fixed at 12 noon. I reached the place precisely 2 -3 minutes in advance. The sales person greeted me and went to check out on the demo vehicle and came back after 10 minutes with the news that the vehicle was off to some other place and would not be back within a couple of hours. Seeing that he is keeping mute about arranging a separate time or bringing the demo car to my place some time later, I enquired about it. But his response was, "Sir, are you going to book the car today?" I was taken by surprise that a guy who failed to keep his commitment about a TD and is asking this question on the very first visit. Put-off with this behavior, I proceeded to Varun motors for the TD of Swift.
Varun Motors : I reached there more than half an hour in advance of the scheduled time. The sales person had apt knowledge about the car, (which is quite obvious considering the age of the swift). He arranged the test drive of the Swift within 5 mins. He also managed to talk me into taking a back to back TD of the Ritz.
The Drives : I took TD of a Swift VDI, followed by a Swift ZXI and a Ritz VDI at the end. In each car, I took one 5 Km round on good roads, and 2 rounds of 1Km on a rough patch, as a driver and the as a rear seat passenger in each. The pickup on the Swift VDI was great and the feel was lovely too on the good roads. I was shifting up a bit early and the traction was still awesome. I wont talk much on this since these are universally known facts now.
I had hoped to hear some diesel clatter, but there was nothing as such. Engine noise inside the cabin was low on idle and while picking up speed it was like a heavy Voooooommmmm.... sound. But nothing close to any clatter. The sound could not be termed disturbing buy any standards, and I think I kind of liked it.
On the pertol, the engine note was entirely absent during idling, with AC on an windows rolled up. Only indication of engine running was the tacho. While picking up speed the note of the engine was much sportier than the diesel and was easily picking up higher revs. The engine inspired me not to make any early up-shifts on this one. The sound of the engine was like if the BASS of the diesel engines sound had been turned off.
I liked this sound better than that of the diesel. I must say that I am very impressed with the petrol and I am convinced that it could give me more than enough driving pleasure that I was looking for.
The Ritz felt almost similar to the Swift on all aspects, except for a higher seating position. The ride quality was the same. It just had a bit more of a feel god factor since the interiors look and feel better. I understand that it is more practical than the swift, but I still feel that it lacks the attitude that the Swift has.
On the rough roads the ride was bumby, especially in the rear on all the vehicles. Going over potholes caused "thuds" inside the cabin that were way more than just audible. The ritz did not have rattles, but the swift had rattles coming from the rear left door and the parcel tray (in the ZXI).
As per my calculations, the Swift VXI is coming to 5.34 lacs on road + the ICE = 5.5 lacs. The Figo TDCI EXI (with inbuilt ICE) comes to almost the same price. So the EMI on both of these would be the same. Thus the figo would save me a bonus 1k every month on the fuel costs and would work out to be the cheaper option for me.
Please pour in your comments and suggestions.