Did not think I needed a separate thread to post this. So tagging along. Mods: Please fork as appropriate. I took delivery of my Spark LS LPG about a month ago.
After all the help, guidance I got from this site, I thought it is criminal not to let you all know how this site helped me with all the decision making and made my car buying experience good and that your help is really really appreciated by many rookies like me
. Thanks to Mods for getting me in easily into this great group.
I should say that initially I did not even know what I wanted out of my car. This was partly because I never had any. I was pretty much content with my Honda Unicorn for the past 4 years. I quickly turned to internet to research first on the requirements and what to expect of a car. I read posts from three other forums at least before seeing tbhp and once I'm here I have never visited those forums again. I spent 5 hours a day reading at least for a week and then I could decide on the below requirements.
Smallest dimensions, turning radius possible but should be able to seat 4 medium built people with ease. (Because my parking is in a small cellar and very very small.)
should be able to go on long drives of up to 500 kms at a strech.
should give mileage more than 12 kmpl (petrol).
should preferably run on alternative fuel (Deisel, LPG/CNG with Petrol)
should not cross 5 L on road budget.
Should not be same as my neighbors (A-star, Santro). Don’t ask me why. even I don’t know.
So I started looking for cars and finally could shortlist Alto, Wagon-R Duo, Ritz VDI, Estilo VXI, Vista ,Aveo UVA and of course Spark. I10 was never in the list because I never had a good feeling about it and Hyundai in general. Wagon-R was quickly out of the list as it is an outgoing model. Alto for similar reasons and partly because on the way to my home town there are steep hills and good length of ghat section and I had a feeling Alto might struggle in Ghats. Vista was out because of big dimensions and turning radius. It will be tough to park it without scratches in our cellar. Aveo due to mileage and 'not so great' reviews. Besides, it did not seem like a value for money for many other reasons. New Estilo was a good contender but I heard from others in this forum that the mileage in the long run is in question and the general feeling about this car was that this might not stay in competition for long time. So this was out with some difficulty. Ritz is something I liked totally (even the rear). In fact, looks were the last priority for me. Did not find a single negative thing about this car. Even took a test ride of a VDI. This was amazing car and nothing in the world seem to compare to this in its class and segment. I was totally prepared to stretch my budget and go for it. Don’t remember exact figure but Maruti people quoted more than 5.2 on road for VDI. Simultaneously, I started collecting information about Spark also and found that there are irresistible offers. With 37 K discount + 5 K corporate discount + 5 K accessories I’m getting LS LPG for 4.10 L. This included (central locking, ICE). On Ritz there was no discount at all (This was about a month ago). It was quite obvious that economically Spark is more viable. At this time, I started doing calculations on how the extra amount spent on LPG (about 35 K difference between Spark LS and LS LPG) , Diesel ( about 75 K between Ritz LDI and VDI) will even out in the long run and diesel did not look convincing price wise. Also, Ritz is little big for the parking place I have. I took about 2 weeks contemplating these two options. Spoke to many people and read a lot to come to a decision. I agree these two options does not even seem to be close in terms of their segment and cost etc. But with me, this was the case. Spark LS LPG pitted against Ritz VDI. Heart said Ritz but mind wants to go for Spark.
Finally I made my decision. It was Spark LS LPG. It had been about a month since it was delivered a drove around 450 KM.
Color: Linen Beige exteriors with Beige interiors.
Variant : LS LPG.
On road price: 4.10 including ICE (HU: Sony DVD, Speakers: Sony Xplod at front and rear) , central locking, seat covers, steering cover, mats, mud flaps, reverse parking sensor, Ganesh idol, car cover.
Dealer : Orange Banjara Hills.
Below is my experience:
+ves:
Car delivers everything it promises. Reasonably good performance, Spacious interiors. Did not measure the mileage properly but it seems to be about 12. (Distance / no lts)
Steering is very responsive.
Has great initial pickup. So I'm guy going forward first at a traffic signal.
Lot of space inside for its size. Even the boot was bigger than what I imagined (considering LPG tank located in it).
Peace of mind with extended warranty and zero maintenance.
No other can come even close to the way this can zig zag into the busy city traffic. I think this is mainly due to the low dimensions + great power combination. I'm only a little more careful than driving my bike.
Ac is fast and good.
Hassle free buying experience and customer care.
Beige color looks good inside and outside.
Parking , U-turns are very very easy.
-ves:
Only problem I faced so far, and I fear that might become more apparent in future is that while running on LPG, acceleration is not that good 5th gear. Even after fully depressing the accelerator, nothing seem to happen.
So cannot overtake vehicles confidently while running on LPG in 5th gear.
However, at the same time, there seem to be some kind of pull happening in 3rd and 4th gear. Meaning, the vehicle accelerates though I dont press the accelerator.
Breaking is predictably slow. I need to break really hard to stop the vehicle if the car is going beyond 60.
No tachometer. Even my bike has it. Don’t know why a car is missing it.
AC/fan is a bit noisy at 100%.
So in retrospect, do I regret not going for Ritz? Not really. When I think of the scratch I got while parking my Spark, I know it could have been a bigger scratch if it was a Ritz.
When I think of about 1.2 L I saved, I feel very happy. This car will serve my office commuting for the coming 5 years for sure.
When I have more money, I will buy a second car (much bigger than Ritz
) for other uses, like lenghty highway drives with my entire family.
Sorry I don’t have any pics at this time. but will post then in a week for sure.
I'm yet to get sun film done and planning to go to minster road to get this done along with others like side beading for door protection etc.
Also, planning to give for one month reassurance check this week.
I would like to thank Sawyer for this thread as this thread and his clarity on his requirements helped me decide mine.