Back 2 Back Ritz Vdi and Vista Quadrajet Test Drive Well, in a sudden turn of events my friend landed up in a situation where he needs to maintain a dedicated car for personal uses (We are a startup and have a Safari 2.2 DICOR that we lunge around a lot!). He got engaged recently and now his fiancee is changing job and moving to Bangalore, and his mother as well is joining them. Considering all aspects, we were primarily scouting for a vehicle that keeps pace with driving atyle we have developed over SAFARI, and be docile enough to be driven by a lady. Petrol was bever an option !
I have been in a dilemma regarding my car purchase itself (saving up for Punto, a minor setback and postponing of plans by few months), so laid down the options bare in front of my friend: Indica Vista Quadrajet, Ritz VDI, Punto MJD, Palio 1.3 MJD. Backseat comfort was also of critical importance. Owing to his prior experience with his brother's purchase of a Palio 1.6 and *** experiences, he had his preconceived notions about Punto. Swift was out primarily because of over exposure in Bangalore !
We had not been able to find time to fix up a TD for either vehicles because of overloaded schedules. However one lucky day, a meeting at Peenya ended prematurely, and we hit the Mandovi and Prerna motors in those parts of city.
First we went to Prerna Motors Workshop where they had a TD vehicle: Indica Vista Quadrajet Aura. The car looked appealing, and we just started discussion as to how much TATA Motors has improved, when we noticed the roof of the vehicle. It was clearly misaligned with pillar on one side in comparison to other ans corner was a good 5 mm offset! Anyway, we took a TD for 16 km through free highway stretch (5 km), bumper to bumper traffic (4km), more potholes and less of road (2 km), and 5 km of regular traffic. Here are my observations:
1. Although the trim offered seat adjustments, I was unable to find a confident driving position (I did find a comfortable position though). It could be attributed to prolonged driving on Safari and Gypsy, I must mention here that I find a Getz seating, without any adjustments, quite commanding and confident. The issue primarily was that apart from height adjustment, there was a valley to the bottom of seat that enhanced the low slung seating position. Absence of a dead pedal is a shame!
2. Steering response is quite accurate (however, steering feels a tad poor in quality).
3. Although the third gear offered good driveability across 20-75 speed band, the car seemed to jerk whenever throttle was pressed or released.
4. Suspension is a beauty and performs wonderfully for rear seat passengers.
5. I am 5'11'' and my friend is 6'2'', and we used to sit in a column, and even then none of us felt any lack of legroom (or headroom).
6. Plastic quality is fairly varying across components. Instrument console and primary dashboard of decent quality. However door plastics and lock/unlock levers were pathetic.
7. AC is too effective.
8. Visibility all around is good.
9. Glove Box Compartment is huge of functional utility.
7. Gear knob and lever are comparable in size to that in Safari and feel a bit odd to hold ! The gearshift is precise but a little hard. Fifth is a little tricky to engage.
8. NVH is fairly good.
9. The stock ICE is an absolute sucker and reminded me of the system my father had in his Padmini Premier in terms of sound quality. However it does offer USB support; those with softer acoustic responses might be OK with that, but someone even mildly recreating bass and guitar strings would just whack the system out of car. Checked with salesperson if it could be replaced but he seemed low on confidence.
10. The braking though decent might offer compromises in rainy conditions. For latter half of drive roads were wet with rain, and I managed to screech the vehicle with braking that I would definitely not call harsh. This vehicle requires an ABS atleast of not EBD. I asked the salesman if TATA is offering an option on ABS in ner future and I was told that by October they would.
11. The stock wiper blades were not veyr good. Either the vehicle gad defective/worn wipers, or else they are generically of poor quality in Vista. Someone with ownership experience may clarify.
12. The fifth gear engaged with cruising at 100 kmph was a luxury saloon like experience on highway, although absence of ABS will tend to keep you on toes. The steering again needs a mention and weighs in beautifully.
13. I had anticipated that central instrument cluster might be of a little issue, but it turned that it was not much of an issue.
14. Build quality in terms of strength and steel guage feels good. The boot seems a little smaller, say in comparison to that of Ritz. The wheel housing intrudes significantly into the boot.
15. Front seats could do well with a little more thigh support (again in comparison to Ritz).
16. Tilt adjustment on steering doesn't come low enough, and is a little weird to operate. Safari's is much better.
17. The seatbelt released by itself twice during the driving. Could be a one off issue.
Followup with Ritz VDI observations soon. |