When it comes to a new set of wheels for our cars, we always scout around the max before we get them. Possible reason: We ain't satisified with what is currently on or just looking for a change to see what the other tyre has to offer. In simpler words, curiosity So here is a brief preview as to what the different set of tyres does and to what kind of drive is it suited for. As the list is exhaustive, please feel free to add.
The most widely discussed/sold tyre is in order of preference is
1. Bridgestone
2. Michelin
3. Goodyear
This is followed by the rest of them but to say that these 3 are slogging it out for the top would not be wrong, although Michelin is slowly and steadly taking over the BS.
1. BS:
Of the various tyres that BS sells, the most commonly sold tyre would be
a Potenza(Sporty segment, although now not available)
bS322
c S248
2. Michelin
Of the various tyre Michelin Sells, the most commonly sold tyre would be
a.Energy XM1+
b.PP1/PP2
3. Goodyear
Eagle F1 GSD3
Eagle NCT5
GPS2
Here is what I think how these tyres would perform
BS Potenza: By far and large the largest selling tyre for all. A high performance tyre designed for a good ride comfort combined with excellent braking facilities. However, with the Potenza’s no longer in stock and other better options available, buying a Potenza now-a-days would be a not so wise choice.
Suited for
High speed drivers.Offers good grip in both dry and wet weather conditions.
S322: This tyre is designed to offer a good ride comfort without compromising on the grip. However, for all of us, who have used this set of tyre before, would nto quite agree with BS’s here. The 4 grooves do offer good grip on low speed but on high speeds and wet weather conditions, this set of tyres are beaten hands down over it’s rival.
Ideally suited for slow drivers or low mileage cars. Caution: Prone to punctures.
S248: Virtually the same as the S322.
Suited for – Low budget segement for those who carry, “It’s just a tyre” thought
Michelin’s
A class apart and in a league of their own. Have quickly and quietly taken over from the BS’s especially in the Indian market and are eating into a huge chunk of their share. BS really needs to come up with something special or risk loosing its Numero Uno title to its numero uno competitor.
XM1+ : This tyre beats all the other tyres hands down in terms of a daily use tyre. Last longer than any other tyre without compromising on the grip or its safety. Is being slowly replaced by on all cars and might be putting the MRF’s soon out of business. Although a bit on the expensive side (4400 in NCR), but totally worth the money. Ideally suited for, those who wish to have a comfortable ride and do not wish to change the tyres before 50K.
PP1/PP2: The king in the performance segment so far. Has forced the BS to stopped production for the potenza’s and is the favorite of all performance driven drivers. Excellent tyre offering amazing grip in both wet and dry weather conditions at good high speeds. Again, slightly expensive (around 4100 in NCR) but totally worth it.
Can't go wrong with the PP's
Goodyear:
Eagle F1-GS3D
As the company says “ Not for everyone”. This tyre being a uni-directional tyre is the ultimate in traction and handling.. IT’s a great choice for high performance enthusiasts. However, where good year looses out is probably on bad marketing and the “foreign” factor. Let’s just say that the company is bit outdated and needs to liven its take and needs to wake up to it’s competition. I guess it’s still suffering from the aftermaths of the BS destruction.
Ideally suited for Goodyear loyalists & wet weather conditions.
Not recommended for people who wish to make their tyres last for 50K and above.
NCT5
Is in competition with the PP1/PP2 but somehow lacks the technology to beat the Michelins. However, can be considered as a cheaper alternative to the Michelins, especially who don’t’ feel like spending 4K on a tyre. Not a bad buy. Good value for money. Not recommended for hill driving though.
GPS2- The same as the BS S248 but available at a cheaper cost of 2500.
In addition to the individual details, I would also like to take a minute to mention the significance of the grooves of the tyre.
Most of us are looking for a good tyre grip (after all that’s what tyres are for) along with a certain, good groove design to compliment the alloys. However, I feel it’s important to mention that one should also consider the environment where he drives. For eg, people who drive in wet weather conditions or moist areas like Vizag or Pondi or further down south, should avoid the BS S248 or the GPS2. Instead, for the wets, one should go for the uni-directional tyres such as the Yoks of the Goodyears Eagle but if people stay in the NCR and drive mostly around the city or on the highway, the uni-directional tyres may not be the best choice of tyres. Uni-directional tyres are designed mostly for wet weather conditions and in NCR, other than the last few days, there’s been little rain. This is the reason why the uni-directionals would wear out faster here than moist areas. For dry areas, go for the XM1’s or BS turanza’s or the PP's for performance.
A word of advice, For hilly areas, one should avoid the low-profile tyres.
Having said all this, at the end of the day, all that matters is not the car, not the tyre but the person driving. A little bit of common sense and a little bit of patience would make sure that the one’s waiting for us and the others at home, do get to see their loved one’s. Let’s just be respectful towards other people on the road remembering that not all make mistakes. Let’s keep road rage away.
Cheers!
M2S